A Heavenly Pie

Guard gated. Call, first 772-370-9535, 5789 Travelers Way, Fort Pierce
(772) 370-9535

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Callie Ander

We got a key lime for my birthday , it was the best key lime I've ever had !!!

Matt Coffey

For a $40 pie I'm very disappointed in the pie I got. As you can see in the picture the inside of the pie was soupy. Seemed like the cans weren't drained before being used. I also 4 cupcakes for $5 a cupcake my kids took like 2 bites were not impressed. My 4 year old didn't like a cupcake. That's not good sign.

charlotte williams

I travel from Indiana to Jenson Beach once a year and always order a KeyLime pie. They are delicious and addicting. Best pie I ever had in my entire life. Trust me you won't be disappointed.

David Miller

No longer a storefront. Order only.

Maria-Adriana Gomez

Love the pecan pie.

Ginny Mathie

Awesome pie... we had a lemon meringue... OMG. Yum. Yum. Yum. It's pricey but worth every penny. Delicious crust. Can't brag enough about lemon custard and meringue. Debbi sure can bake. Recommend highly.

Mark Denhertog

The treats I got were incredible, everything looked so good. I ended up buying pies, squares and cupcakes. Amazing jem found off the beaten path. Give a shot, you won't be sorry. Delicious!!

F. M.

I was looking for someone to make an apple pie for my widowed neighbor who loves pie. I was lucky to find Deborah. The pie looked amazing and my neighbor was so happy. She said it was delicious! I really appreciate you taking my order on short notice. Happy New Year!

Bill Ray

We ordered 3 pies for thanksgiving and they were simply amazing! The lime cream is out of this world!

Bill Ray

Absolutely delicious, we ordered 3 pies for thanksgiving and they were amazing! Each a little different and full of flavor. Highly recommended!!!

Jean-Ann Suchy

We are traveling and had a late night hunger for Key Lime Pie, and this was perfect!! Probably the best I have ever had. Do not pass up an opportunity to get something from her!

GG Gaming

I was looking for someone to make an apple pie for my widowed neighbor who loves pie. I was lucky to find Deborah. The pie looked amazing and my neighbor was so happy. She said it was delicious! I really appreciate you taking my order on short notice. Happy New Year!

JoAnn Starr

Ordered a Boston Cream Pie for my husband’s Birthday, it was perfect and delicious. Thank You, Debbie

Christopher E

I’ve been a customer for almost a year now, carrot cakes, chocolate cream pie, red velvet cakes, and pumpkin pies (and I’m not a fan of pumpkin pies!) have been my go-to orders. The best desserts I’ve had ever! Must call or check out her social media to place an order! Highly recommend!

William E. Lewis Jr.

As a frequent visitor to the Farmer’s Market on Ocean Drive in Vero Beach, I’ve made over a dozen purchases from Debbie at The Heavenly Pie. Carrot cake – moist with a cream cheese and walnut frosting – it’s a favorite of my youngest daughter. Deb's made from scratch chocolate cake is my personal favorite with just a hint of coffee chocolate frosting and tons of chocolate chunks on top. Pro Tip - be sure to purchase a full cake, rather than slices for the best value. Another personal favorite is the Blueberry Lemon Crumb coffee cake. Best served fresh and unrefrigerated, it’s packed with blueberries and is very tasty. Cookies, cake, cupcakes, along with pies – all freshly baked and delicious - I’ve purchased them all. No complaints from me and no complaints from my kids. And they are a picky bunch… Located in Fort Pierce, A Heavenly Pie is frequently seen at various Treasure Coast farmer’s markets. They also offer local curbside delivery, which is important during these uncertain times. William E. Lewis, Jr. Vero Beach, Florida.

Loading...