Awesome Pizza very tasty and fresh always anytime I've ever ordered. Friendly and helpful staff. They have specialty pizzas that are really great and a whole menu of other yummy items. NYPD is located off of Melaleuca and Jog. They are not affiliated with NYPD II Or any other NYPDs in the area... This location is far superior and puts out really great pizzas and other food items like mentioned above definitely recommend. Enjoy!
Blaine Collier
Walked in on a whim looking for a hot slice of pep after looking for single slice options in the area and was not disappointed! This was the only one after lunchtime still offering my favorite metro snack. Pizza was hot, fresh, & had city size slices! Customer service was awesome and made me want to go back just to say hey very soon. Also was informed of a very important detail that they are not affiliated with the DoorDash restaurant NYPD II at all, like I thought! They are in fact The Original NYPD pizza of the area, so come on by and try a local legend on your next hunt for some Za.
Kaley R
Absolutely Disgraceful – Never Coming Back
I don’t usually write reviews, but this experience was so bad I feel obligated to warn others. Let’s start with the food: The pizza was a soggy, lukewarm disappointment—like someone microwaved sadness and sprinkled it with regret. But honestly, the terrible pizza would’ve been forgivable… if the owner hadn’t treated me like garbage.
I’ve never been spoken to with such blatant disrespect in my life. I asked a simple question about my order, and the owner came at me with an attitude like I’d personally insulted his ancestors. He was rude, dismissive, and downright aggressive—for NO reason. It was clear he didn’t care about his customers or his business.
If you enjoy overpriced, undercooked pizza served with a side of hostility and ego, this is the place for you. Otherwise, do yourself a favor and take your appetite (and your dignity) elsewhere
Editing to add: owner called me today to try to rectify things, and the phone call was even worse screaming over me talking. Just don’t even go or call this place. The owner is absolutely insane for calling me and yelling at me the next day about this review.
Nadeige Martelly
Exceptional service with the warmest hospitality. Benny and the entire team are fantastic—always kind, attentive, and welcoming. And the pizza? Absolutely delicious and consistently perfect. Can’t wait to return! Thanks guys! Nadeige and Sebastiaan
Dara Thorne
Absolutely stellar experience with NY Pizza! We placed a large order for a family gathering, and they delivered with absolute precision. Every single item was correct, hot, and perfectly prepared. The pizzas were delicious with a crispy crust, melty cheese, and generous toppings. What really stood out was the service. They were timely, courteous, and genuinely appreciative of our business. It’s not easy to get a big order right, but they nailed it. Highly recommend NY Pizza for both quality and professionalism. Five stars all the way! 🍕👏
Semra Shabani
Everything is delicious👏🏻
Victoria
Pizza was average at best. This is not like the other location that i've been to. Nypd pizza 2 is much better. When I asked the gentlemen, if it was still affiliated with another location, he answered very rudely and said, no than proceeded to ignore me I was like, okay, I actually wound up getting a stomach ache after eating one slice, I threw the other one in the garbage. Definitely, will not be going back to this location.
Lisa Durda
Benny and the staff are very friendly. Love the pizza and the Chicken Parm with penne alla vodka, antipasto salad is a winner!!
Kenneth Hughes
I ordered from them on Grubhub and live really nearby to their location. After calling the restaurant and waiting outside my front door for their delivery driver for over 40 minutes past their delivery estimate I got a refund from grubhub.
Then NYPD pizza called me and angrily told me they saw we canceled the order, and that we aren’t welcome to order from them again and that they already got their money from grubhub.
That’s fine I won’t order from a place that isn’t even going to bring me my food and try to take my money anyways. Horrible service, and makes it worse that they called me to retaliate. Do not do business with these people if you want to be treated well.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
J- Blaze
Dude reheats his old pizza, and then comes out yelling at you if you don't want it.
I’m old school Italian and from up north so if you do relocate or have been raised here please it’s a must do to order from this establishment.By the way so consistent and great customer service and the food speaks for itself. Mr.C
aaron trujillo
Pizza was the best employees ate the best around wonderful people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adriana Gonzalez
I ordered a full pan and a half of penne alla vodka with chicken and garlic rolls, for a family celebration. I went in during the week to discuss amounts and prices. They were so helpful and worked with me every step of the way. Saturday came and everyone loved the food! The chicken was tender and the pasta perfectly cooked and very tasty. There was plenty if food and e drying was happy. Thank you for such quality food and great customer service. You will definitely see me again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ellania1990
Affordable. Great Food , not greasy. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Tres Wilson
The pizza is top notch! The staff… incredible! Tara (sometimes Benny) is so efficient on the phone and it’s easy to order! They remember my voice and ask if it’s the usual! Which it is always a meat lovers with extra cheese and extra sauce. Benny and Ryan make the best pizzas! I highly recommend
Awesome Pizza very tasty and fresh always anytime I've ever ordered. Friendly and helpful staff. They have specialty pizzas that are really great and a whole menu of other yummy items. NYPD is located off of Melaleuca and Jog. They are not affiliated with NYPD II Or any other NYPDs in the area... This location is far superior and puts out really great pizzas and other food items like mentioned above definitely recommend. Enjoy!
Walked in on a whim looking for a hot slice of pep after looking for single slice options in the area and was not disappointed! This was the only one after lunchtime still offering my favorite metro snack. Pizza was hot, fresh, & had city size slices! Customer service was awesome and made me want to go back just to say hey very soon. Also was informed of a very important detail that they are not affiliated with the DoorDash restaurant NYPD II at all, like I thought! They are in fact The Original NYPD pizza of the area, so come on by and try a local legend on your next hunt for some Za.
Absolutely Disgraceful – Never Coming Back
I don’t usually write reviews, but this experience was so bad I feel obligated to warn others.
Let’s start with the food: The pizza was a soggy, lukewarm disappointment—like someone microwaved sadness and sprinkled it with regret. But honestly, the terrible pizza would’ve been forgivable… if the owner hadn’t treated me like garbage.
I’ve never been spoken to with such blatant disrespect in my life. I asked a simple question about my order, and the owner came at me with an attitude like I’d personally insulted his ancestors. He was rude, dismissive, and downright aggressive—for NO reason. It was clear he didn’t care about his customers or his business.
If you enjoy overpriced, undercooked pizza served with a side of hostility and ego, this is the place for you. Otherwise, do yourself a favor and take your appetite (and your dignity) elsewhere
Editing to add: owner called me today to try to rectify things, and the phone call was even worse screaming over me talking. Just don’t even go or call this place. The owner is absolutely insane for calling me and yelling at me the next day about this review.
Exceptional service with the warmest hospitality. Benny and the entire team are fantastic—always kind, attentive, and welcoming. And the pizza? Absolutely delicious and consistently perfect. Can’t wait to return! Thanks guys! Nadeige and Sebastiaan
Absolutely stellar experience with NY Pizza! We placed a large order for a family gathering, and they delivered with absolute precision. Every single item was correct, hot, and perfectly prepared. The pizzas were delicious with a crispy crust, melty cheese, and generous toppings. What really stood out was the service. They were timely, courteous, and genuinely appreciative of our business. It’s not easy to get a big order right, but they nailed it. Highly recommend NY Pizza for both quality and professionalism. Five stars all the way! 🍕👏
Everything is delicious👏🏻
Pizza was average at best. This is not like the other location that i've been to.
Nypd pizza 2 is much better. When I asked the gentlemen, if it was still affiliated with another location, he answered very rudely and said, no than proceeded to ignore me I was like, okay,
I actually wound up getting a stomach ache after eating one slice, I threw the other one in the garbage. Definitely, will not be going back to this location.
Benny and the staff are very friendly. Love the pizza and the Chicken Parm with penne alla vodka, antipasto salad is a winner!!
I ordered from them on Grubhub and live really nearby to their location.
After calling the restaurant and waiting outside my front door for their delivery driver for over 40 minutes past their delivery estimate I got a refund from grubhub.
Then NYPD pizza called me and angrily told me they saw we canceled the order, and that we aren’t welcome to order from them again and that they already got their money from grubhub.
That’s fine I won’t order from a place that isn’t even going to bring me my food and try to take my money anyways. Horrible service, and makes it worse that they called me to retaliate.
Do not do business with these people if you want to be treated well.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dude reheats his old pizza, and then comes out yelling at you if you don't want it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I’m old school Italian and from up north so if you do relocate or have been raised here please it’s a must do to order from this establishment.By the way so consistent and great customer service and the food speaks for itself.
Mr.C
Pizza was the best employees ate the best around wonderful people
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a full pan and a half of penne alla vodka with chicken and garlic rolls, for a family celebration. I went in during the week to discuss amounts and prices. They were so helpful and worked with me every step of the way. Saturday came and everyone loved the food! The chicken was tender and the pasta perfectly cooked and very tasty. There was plenty if food and e drying was happy. Thank you for such quality food and great customer service. You will definitely see me again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Affordable. Great Food , not greasy. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The pizza is top notch! The staff… incredible! Tara (sometimes Benny) is so efficient on the phone and it’s easy to order! They remember my voice and ask if it’s the usual! Which it is always a meat lovers with extra cheese and extra sauce. Benny and Ryan make the best pizzas! I highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Loading...