The Proper Pie Company

Purchased chicken & mushroom/steak & kidney pies from y'all at the farmer's market in Winter Haven. They were delicious, perfect pastry, really filled like an old fashioned pie!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🇺🇸🇬🇧

Excellent service from a lovely lady named Charlotte, who also makes the pies. I wasn't expecting to see a place like this in Haines City, but it's really here, and it's really good.

Every year we come to Hains city and didn’t know about this place. The owner is so friendly and knowledgeable about the city. And the pies are amazing. Honestly. I know the English chocolate and other things are
expensive to what we pay at home, but to get it shipped out and try to make something on it is expected. Highly recommended a visit

I just went with my fiance and ordered the curry and buffalo pies, flavor was amazing and the fries were perfect..customer service and ambiance was tranquil and nice. Id deff go again.

We didn't even get in the door. A note on the door said they were closing at 5 today and it was 4:53 (sign said regular close at 6). There was a lady mopping, and she saw us, but made no effort to get a last minute sale.

Poor business ethic, no customer service. Probably won't try again.

Bought meat pies at Solivita market,my wife had chicken pot pie,I had pulled pork pot pie,they were both excellent.We bought steak pies and will be having them later.The pies we filling and tasted great compliments to the chefs.Would highly reccommend to family and friends.

They never have a stock of pies in the refrigerator and now they clear out the refrigerator on Thursday and save the pies for market for the weekend. This place has either declined or I just always hit it at the wrong time. I miss the old owners.

They've moved!!! Caught me out but I found them, bigger place in Haines City. Still good food.

We got the steak and potato and chicken broccoli cheddar pies frozen from the Clermont farmers market last week and loved them! After following the cooking directions the crust and temperature were perfect. We also got some scones which were delicious. Was a super easy meal on a busy day for us and can’t wait to grab some more!

So this place microwaves what is in their refrigerators. The lady was nice enough, but the food isn't fresh and is overpriced and in a refrigerator. The pies we got were really salty and honestly a 99 cent Walmart pot pie was less salty and tastes better. Kinda overpriced

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Purchased an 8oz Steak, Potato, Onion & Cheese Pie at a farmer's market. While the tast was good, there was not much to this $8.00 pot pie. Excessive amount of dough, not enough of the ingredients.

Food: 3

After discovering The Proper Pie Company at the Winter Haven Farmers Market we had to try them in person. If you’re looking for great service and food this is the place to go! I wholeheartedly believe they are the home of the best fish and chips in Polk County FL. The British pies and Scottish eggs are also extremely flavorful, if you’re ever in the area stop in for a steak pie. You will not regret it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Steak, Banger Rolls

First time having the chicken, leak, and potatoe pie it was delicious. Have bought fish and chips often the best fish and chips in Haines City.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips, Pie

Good food at a good price

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, Steak, Pie

This place is worth the trip. Great variety. Even more chocolates to choose from. People are so nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5