Nic’s New York pizza

2104 NE 123rd St, North Miami
(305) 942-0352

Recent Reviews

Kelly Tolbert

The best and the biggest slice of pizza ever and you are missing out if you don't come

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jerrry m

Excellent pizza and wonderful service from the owner. Very reasonable prices. We heard everyone in there complimenting the owner on the great food. Very small and not fancy but well worth it for the food and service.

Elizabeth W.

Not sure why Yelp shows this business when it's closed down. I decided to go there to try their pizza but to my surprise the company is no longer there. So if your trying to get their giant slice pizza your out of luck. Not sure if they moved because there was nothing on the door stating that they did.

Ari Mutchnik

They know their pizza amazing taste, and quality everything on the menu is delicious the meatballs, the lasagna, the pepperoni roll do yourself a favor and try this place

Kate G.

Meatballs and calzone for dinner tonight. Italian news on the radio is a bonus Please come out and support local small hardworking business owners.

Adela B.

It's very disturbing to have bad customer service when your pizza is great. Your pizza need to match your attitude which Nico and his Wife don't have. No one was trying to get a free pizza, there is thing called "dispute a charge" at any banks. Nico's pizza need to stop advertising a website they no longer take orders from and receive money from people that are just trying to have a good pizza night, and when confronted they want to tell us "kick rocks". Very unprofessional. We call people like you guys "aspirante". Never going to order food from this restaurant again, also please remove your dogs from your kitchen. I believe that's a violation code.

Adanesne M.

NEGATIVE STARS IF POSSIBLE! Beware. They have a new yelp account only to cover there old yelp account WITH 2 stars. I Ordered a pizza via an app called menufy for a good evening, when I showed up to pick up my pie, nick and his devious wife claimed to have terminated the contract and it was not there business weather or not the money was collected as it didn't seem valid. I tried to reason with them only for them to reach a volcanic temper. They are not fit to be business owners. I got treated like scum. I'm reporting them to the better business Bureau!

Jackie L.

I heard so much great things about this mom and pop pizza shop and wanted to support them. I don't have pictures, however; my first order was a 4 cheese pizza which was okay but not great. Let's just say I've had better. The second pizza I ordered was the Manhattan Pizza with extra cheese. The pizza is supposed to come with basil yet it had none. I was craving basil so it was bummer to not see it on the pizza. I'm a cheese lover and paid for extra cheese and it wasn't added. As for service, they clearly have shown that they don't fully provide what the customer paid for and ordered. They're known for 2 foot pizzas but after my experiences, I don't know if I'll even try it. Perhaps their dine in experience is better. I ordered my meals through Uber Eats. I find at times dining in is always better. Venture here at your own risk.

alejandra guardado

So delicious! Solid pizza in the area! Must try.

Kenny V

This was very tasty!!! And good customer service. Thank you so much, guys!!!???

Scott C.

w o w this is the real deal!!! i drive there from ft lauderdale that's how good it is !!! the meatballs the best i ever had.this guy is from italy and i give nic 5 stars !!! i am from boston and i know pizza

Yasmine Osta

100% recommend!!! Amazing pizza and great service. We came here based on the reviews and it was worth it. The pizzas are delicious and the cannolis are amazing. Lovely people! Definitely recommend!

Walé F.

Quality pizza here! The Hawaiian was especially good and if you eat there they have a hot pepper infused olive oil that you can put on your pie ...I would like to try other things but the Hawaiian is so good I do not dare stray!

Garreth S.

We had this pizza a few weeks ago and it was the best we have had in Miami. We also got the meatballs and garlic croissants. Everything was fresh and absolutely delicious!!! We are ordering again this evening. Great food!!!

Kodiak Fields

We've found the pizza to be a little dry, not enough sauce. We were also disappointed in the stingy application of toppings, especially based upon the price to add, or in our case, build your own. The flavors were on point, but we've had better pizza in the area for less. Next time we'll try one of their pre-designed specialty pies and will update the review accordingly. The Nutella calzone, on the other hand, was spot on delicious!

Load More