Duffy's Tavern, Bar, and Grill
5808 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach
(941) 778-2501
Customers' Favorites
Blue Cheese Burger and a Cheeseburger All the Way
Fresh Jalapeno \u0026 Havarti Cheeseburger
Brie and Caramelized Onions Cheeseburger
Fresh Jalapeno & Havarti Cheeseburger
Stella Artois or Pacifico or Modela
Chili Cheese Dog and Tex Mex Burger
Brie and Caramelized Onion Burger
Caramelized Onion and Brie Burger
Cheese Burger and Potato Salad
Jalapeno Havarti Burger w Bacon
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We ordered dinner at Duffy’s for a large group of 12 after reading good reviews. The burgers were by far the best we’ve had on the island and the bean soup was absolutely amazing (it was the bartender’s grandmother’s family recipe)! The staff are all super friendly, the prices can’t be beat, and it has that authentic, family owned feel that you just can’t find in chain restaurant/bars. We will definitely be back before the end of our trip and we would highly recommend!
Duffy’s Tavern on Anna Maria Island is a true local gem with an old-Florida charm that’s hard to find these days. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making you feel like part of the community from the moment you walk in. Their burgers are the star of the menu juicy, perfectly cooked, and loaded with fresh toppings. The cold beer selection is just what you’d hope for in a laid-back beachside tavern, and the prices are refreshingly reasonable for the area. Service is...
Duffy’s Tavern serves up the best burger on AMI—no frills, just simple, delicious perfection. The menu is limited, and it’s cash-only, but that’s part of the charm. While it doesn’t have the same lively vibe as Skinny’s, it absolutely beats them on burger quality. And when it comes to ice-cold beer in frosted mugs, it’s a dead tie. A must-visit for classic burger lovers.
You May Also Like
Isola Bella italian eatery - 5904 Marina Dr
![]()
Italian, Mediterranean, Vegetarian
The Ugly Grouper - 5704 Marina Dr
![]()
Family, Bar, Seafood, Music Venues, Pet Friendly
Scott's Deli - 6000 Marina Dr
![]()
Deli, Food Trucks