Small Town Creamery

5404 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach
(941) 213-9107

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Purple Daze Ice Cream Cone

Mackinac Turtle Fudge

Chocolate Ice Cream

Butterscotch Bomb

Toasted Coconut

Cookie Dough

Waffle Cone

Mint Chip

Vegan

Oreo

Photos

+50 photos

+49 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We used to love going here, back when Dennis first opened. Once they re-opened after the hurricanes, we kept going back and urging friends to support this small business. They were more expensive than a few others on the island but they packed a lot of ice cream into each order. They don't do that any more. You get a lot less than the ice cream place by the post office in Anna Maria, for instance, and at a lot higher price. I'm sorry because the flavors were good and...

February 2026

Absolutely stellar ice cream spot on Anna Maria Island! The flavors are incredibly rich and varied — from classic favorites to unique seasonal choices — and there’s something for everyone (including vegan and dairy-free options). The staff are friendly, welcoming, and happy to help you sample before you decide. Great place for families, couples, or anyone with a sweet tooth. Highly recommend stopping by for a scoop (or two!) when you’re in the area.

January 2026

One of the few ice cream spots on the island that had accomodations for gluten free customers. They'll use a separate scoops and avoid areas of cross contamination risk if asked.
Every flavor we've tried is very tasty!

October 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Holmes Beach, FL

Small Town Creamery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Small Town Creamery