The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe

3324 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach
(941) 779-2253

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Raspberry and White Chocolate Cheesecake
Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake
Blueberry Lemon Cheesecake
Salted Caramel Cheesecake
Chicken Salad Sandwich
BBQ Turkey Bacon Ranch
Apple Pie Cheesecake
Key Lime Cheesecake
Breakfast Burrito
Oreo Cheesecake

Menu

Best Damn Eggs
Tom's New Yorker
Choice of toasted bagel. Scrambled eggs and choice of cheddar, feta, gouda, pepper jack, or swiss.
Morning Sunrise
3 Scrambled Eggs, and a Choice of Cheese.
Toast

BAGELS
Bagel & Cream Cheese
Basic Bagel
1/2 Bagels
Bagel & Nutella
Bagel with Butter
Bagel & Jelly
Bagel & Avocado
Bagel & Peanut Butter
Dozen Bagels

BREAKFAST FLAT BREAD
Cinnamon Delight
Cream Cheese, House Coffee Cake Crumble, Cinnamon, Sugar & Icing Drizzle.
Blueberry Thrill
Cream Cheese, House Coffee Cake Crumble, Cinnamon, Sugar, Fresh Blueberries & House Icing Drizzle.

OVERNIGHT OATS
Blueberry Coconut
Coconut Milk, Fresh Blueberries, Local Honey & Lemon Zest.
Honey Bee Oats
Organic Oat Milk, Local Honey & House Granola.

PARFAIT
Yogurt Parfait
Includes 1 Fruit & House Made Granola.

MUFFINS
Cutie Muffin
Made fresh in house. Variety and flavors rotate. Call to find out what the month's flavors are.
Gluten Free
Blueberry.

COFFEE
Cutie Iced Coffee
Mr. Hubbie's personal recipe! Hint of Chocolates & Espresso.
Cappuccino
European style Cappuccinos... Double shot Espresso and foam.
Coffee - Large
Mr. Hubbie's personal recipe! Hint of Chocolates & Espresso.
Latte
Lattes are available in both Hot & Cold.
Lavender Vanilla Latte
White Choc Rasp Latte
Cold Brew
Everything Cutie Crust!! Our Cold Brew has a hint of Graham Cracker flavors, makin' you say "OH Hot Graham!".
Espresso Single
Box Coffee
Great for morning meetings or large groups of people. 10 small cups of Cutie Coffee. Comes with variety sweeteners, half & half, cups and coffee sleeves.
Chai Latte
Espresso Double
Extra Shot
Hot Tea
Our loose leaf teas can be prepared both Cold or Hot. We offer a beautiful selection of flavors that will have you feeling great! Organic Sarasota Breakfast Tea - Promotes blood flow to the brain which lowers the risk of stroke & Heart disease. Organic Earl Grey - Fights anxiety & depression. Organic Sencha Green Tea - Offer a detoxifying effect on body while fighting inflammation. Goji Green - Gojiberries high in beta-carotene. Boosts immune system & protects eyes. ** Mote Beach Tea (Caffeine Free) - Proceeds of the bags we purchase are donated back to the Mote Aquarium in Sarasota. Organic Peppermint (Caffeine Free) - Excellent digestive aid.
Americano
Double Espresso with Piping hot water.

Cheesecakes
Half dozen
Dozen

SANDWICHES
The "Little" Joey Italian
Ham, Sweet Sopressata, Genoa Salami, Provolone, Oregano, Red Onion, Iceberg Lettuce, Lady's O's House Italian on a toasted Italian Hoagie.
Chicken Salad Sandwich
AMI Favorite! House Chicken Salad, Romaine Lettuce on an Italian Hoagie.
Cool As A Cucumber
Cream Cheese, Cucumber, Red Onion, Cheddar Cheese on Toasted Rye. Make it a "Suzy Q" and add Turkey for $4.00 additional.
Fat A** Prosciutto
Home of the Fat Ass! Prosciutto, Arugula, Garlic and Herb Goat Cheese on an Italian Hoagie.
BBQ Turkey Bacon Ranch
Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, BBQ Bacon Jam on a Pretzel Roll.
Horse Roast Beast
Seasoned Roast Beef, Pepper Jack Cheese, Red Onion, Tomato, Lettuce, House Horseradish Mayo on Ciabatta.
Cordon "Ramsey"
Rotisserie Chicken, Ham, Swiss, Arugula, House Dijon Mustard on a Pretzel Roll.
Caesar Pleaser
Romain Lettuce, Rotisserie Chicken, fresh Grated Parmesan, House Caesar.
Pita Plate
This dish is perfect for our Vegan/Vegetarian Friends! Pita wedges, Cucumbers, Tomato and Hummus.
Greek Hippie
Humus, Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion, Feta, Greek Olives on a Pita, House Greek Dressing. This could also be Vegan by removing Feta Cheese.
Knuckle Sandwich
Choice of Bread: White or Marble Rye Choice of Cheese: Cheddar, Gouda, Pepper Jack, Provolone or Swiss.
Classic BLT
It's a Biggin'! Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on toasted white bread.
Old Bay Shrimp Roll
Old Bay Shrimp Salad, Romaine & Italian Hoagie

GREEN SALAD
Cutie Salad
Romaine, Cucumber, Red Onion, Tomato, Greek Olives, Cheddar Cheese & House Croutons.
Caesar Salad
Romain Lettuce, Fresh Shaved Parmesan, House Caesar & House Croutons.

FLAT BREADS
Sweet & Savory
Brie, Bacon, Honey & Walnut.
Margherita
Fresh Mozzarella, Garlic, Tomato, Balsamic Glaze, Basil.
Backyard Garden
Spinach, Bell Peppers, Greek Olives, Red Onion, Tomato, Goat Cheese, Mozzarella, Salt & Pepper.

SALADS BY THE CONTAINER
Sm Caesar Pleaser
Rotisserie Chicken, House Caesar.
Sm Chicken Salad
Our Chicken is freshly with herbs (at time right from our onsite garden). An AMI Favorite for sure!
Lg Old Bay Shrimp Salad
With the taste of Maryland, we have created the most delicious Shrimp Salad. Fresh, light and simply like no other around. An AMI favorite!
Lg Chicken Salad
Our Chicken is freshly with herbs (at time right from our onsite garden). An AMI Favorite for sure!
Lg Caesar Pleaser
Rotisserie Chicken, House Caesar.
Sm Old Bay Shrimp Salad
With the taste of Maryland, we have created the most delicious Shrimp Salad. Fresh, light and simply like no other around. An AMI favorite!

DRINKS
Bottled Water
Fresh Unsweet Brewed Tea
Sweet Bottled Iced Tea
Perrier
Bottled Coke
Bottled Sprite
Bottled Root Beer
Orange Juice
Lemonade
Pink Rose
Diet Coke
Apple Juice
Chocolate Milk
Milk

DIRTY CHIPS
Salt & Vinegar
BBQ
Sea Salt

COOKIES
Dog Cookies
Cutie Crust Cookie
Our Original Crust Cookie. (2 per pack).
Flavored Crust Cookies
Chocolate Chip (2 per pack).
GF Macaroon
Coconut Macaroons.

COFFEE
Cutie Iced Coffee
Mr. Hubbie's personal recipe! Hint of Chocolates & Espresso.
Cappuccino
European style Cappuccinos... Double shot Espresso and foam.
Coffee - Large
Mr. Hubbie's personal recipe! Hint of Chocolates & Espresso.
Latte
Lattes are available in both Hot & Cold.
Lavender Vanilla Latte
White Choc Rasp Latte
Cold Brew
Everything Cutie Crust!! Our Cold Brew has a hint of Graham Cracker flavors, makin' you say "OH Hot Graham!".
Espresso Single
Box Coffee
Great for morning meetings or large groups of people. 10 small cups of Cutie Coffee. Comes with variety sweeteners, half & half, cups and coffee sleeves.
Chai Latte
Espresso Double
Extra Shot
Hot Tea
Our loose leaf teas can be prepared both Cold or Hot. We offer a beautiful selection of flavors that will have you feeling great! Organic Sarasota Breakfast Tea - Promotes blood flow to the brain which lowers the risk of stroke & Heart disease. Organic Earl Grey - Fights anxiety & depression. Organic Sencha Green Tea - Offer a detoxifying effect on body while fighting inflammation. Goji Green - Gojiberries high in beta-carotene. Boosts immune system & protects eyes. ** Mote Beach Tea (Caffeine Free) - Proceeds of the bags we purchase are donated back to the Mote Aquarium in Sarasota. Organic Peppermint (Caffeine Free) - Excellent digestive aid.
Americano
Double Espresso with Piping hot water.

BAGELS
Bagel & Cream Cheese
Basic Bagel
1/2 Bagels
Bagel & Nutella
Bagel with Butter
Bagel & Jelly
Bagel & Avocado
Bagel & Peanut Butter
Dozen Bagels

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+44 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Food is delicious and they can accommodate for various allergies or eating preferences. Staff is so kind.
It is pricy but again the food is really good!
I need to remember to call and order ahead, orders take a while in person.
October 2025
Just got the small cheesecakes today for the first time ever while visiting Anna Maria and omg they are so good! Got the toasted coconut and the lemon blueberry. Nice thick cheesecake and love the small size options they have. Hope I can stop in one more time before I head back to dreary Ohio
October 2025
This is a must stop! Unfortunately we didn’t find it until our second to last day on the island but I have not stopped thinking about their cheesecake since leaving the island. They were so friendly when I emailed them about if I could get some shipped to me (because it’s that good). Might have to make a day trip just to have it again!
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dunkin' - 3302 E Bay Dr
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
Baskin-Robbins - 3302 E Bay Dr
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream
Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff - 3234 E Bay Dr
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe

3324 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217
(941) 779-2253