Caddy's Indian Shores

When we first walked in, we were hit with a strong, unpleasant odor that made us hesitate about staying. Thankfully, our table was outside, which made the experience much more enjoyable. Our server was an absolute rockstar—friendly, attentive, and quick to help us relax after our flight. Drinks were just okay (a little on the watered-down side), but the food was good and arrived quickly. Overall, the service and outdoor seating saved the visit, though the smell inside was hard to overlook.

Service was not good. We ordered the 12 ounce drinks and the waiter brought us the 20 ounce drinks charging us an extra $14 without notifying. Granted, he did fix it after we notified him but was awkward about it. He never seemed interested in checking on our table or very attentive. Lastly, he said he would bring out a desert for a birthday with understanding it was for no charge. we then found out it was charged on our bill without notice, and his excuse was they can't give anything away free anymore - again, no notification that it was an additional charge. Overall, food was great but service was very disappinting.

Horrible Management felt bad for the employees..Will not recommend till they change that.

I didn't ask how much the grouper sandwich was and that was a mistake. $32, before tax or tip! It was just a sandwich with potato chips. I had a grouper sandwich and fries the evening before at Palm Place on the beach and it was only $20. Way over priced!

McGuire was awesome! So attentive.

The food was good for what it was. Seafood pub fare. Sitting outside on the water was great.

The one surprise we didn't like was the 3.5% added surcharge to the bill at the end. Maybe we missed it, but any surcharge is supposed to be indicated on the menu or website. It wasn't. We asked our waitress about it, and she said it wasn't an added tip.

McGuire was a great server! Excellent personality and service

McGuire was a great server. Drinks were and food came out quickly!

McGuire was an amazing server! Shared lots of laughs and had a great time.

AMAZING seafood! Love the atmosphere! McGuire was THE BEST server! Super friendly and attentive. Need more like him out there! 💯

McGuire was an awesome server.

Food was delicious and service was fast, Caleb took great care of us.

Our family came here for dinner, we had 10 people of varying ages and everyone found something they enjoyed! The service was amazing 5/5 ⭐️

Used to be great but they took great things off the menu and now it’s just like a lot of other places. No grouper Rueben which had been their staple, no more black and blue salads which was amazing. No more peanut butter pie, no more visits from us. 🥲

Had a wonderful time tonight while we were there. We were greeted with a smile and taken to a table almost immediately. The atmosphere was great and a bowl of water for our dogs was brought to the table. Our severs name was Kenny and she was fantastic. She recommended a drink called The Painkiller. Totally loved that drink. I ordered the oysters and was surprised by the size of them. Very good and filling. Kenny was fun to talk to and happy to be around. She definitely made our first stop in the area a pleasant and memorable one. Thank you Kenny.