The Magic Oyster Bar

10999 S Ocean Dr, Jensen Beach
(772) 877-3139

Recent Reviews

Sort by
ftybr

This restaurant was highly recommended. They described food that was so delicious it took an hour to eat! We decided to try it. Went for happy hour. Sat at the bar at first but had to move. I’m all about having a good time but the patrons were loud. Screaming across the bar. No these were not 20 year olds but very retired people. As another person described, the coconut mahi sticks were rubbery disgusting Same with chicken fingers. Asked for sauce ( should have been offered when we ordered) Waitress brought one pack. Spinach and artichoke?!?! Looked amazing. Diced tomatoes. Shaved Parmesan. No flavor at all. Could not identify a single artichoke or leave. My goodness. Get some from Costco and call it your own !! I rarely leave a less than stellar review. But felt the need to.

Hannah Harrison

I’m out of town on a work trip and needed a GOOD meal and yall delivered!! From the moment I sat down-until the very end. Perfect service and delicious food. Sydney was the best waitress!! I will def be back. THANK YOU again for wonderful service and food tonight. 💗

JC Prats

Ordered the Ribeye ($45 bucks) 70% gristle and fat. Left it all on the plate for the server to say something, but completely dismissed it . Won't eat here ever again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 4

Golden J

I stop in to this place and order a fish sandwich(snapper&fries). The guy charged me $34 dollars.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Mike Noland

Waitress was on spot, food was delish. Will be back and recommend to friends

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Candy Tomlinson Tomlinson

Love the bartenders, Nick, Christina, and Amber, foid is wonderful and so is staff!
Wonderful

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

rogermZ8950ZH

We have been a few times when we stayed at the Lucie across the street. We went yesterday for happy hour. We ordered clams, oysters, shrimp, fish Everything was great. Fast and friendly service at the bar and the food was outstanding. Try it you wont be disappointed.

Paula Fischer

Little pricey, but what isn’t these days! Husband had grouper sandwich said it was perfect, I had the lobster ravioli and it was as delicious. Our server said she was new, but her service was very good! First time here, will put this one on our list!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alfredo Fernández Carpio

First and last time here. We are definitely not coming back, nor recommending this place.

We were sat at a high table that felt like being inside a freezer. I asked to switch tables three times and was about to leave when they finally offered an option. Later, I discovered five empty, much cozier tables on the other side of the restaurant.

Food took 35 minutes to arrive, and the restaurant wasn’t even half full. The waitress apologized multiple times, saying they were “a little behind” because of a new chef. I asked her—how complicated can it be to serve half a dozen raw oysters and fried calamari?

When the food finally came, it was a disaster. The oysters weren’t fresh, tasted terrible, and weren’t even the type we ordered. The calamari were chewy, cold, and tasteless. I asked for the manager. By then, my Fried Seafood Platter had arrived—greasy, cold, and barely edible. I only ate it because I was starving. To their credit, they removed those dishes from the bill.

Now, to be fair: not everything was bad. The Mac & Cheese with shrimp and calamari was excellent, and the scampi scallops & shrimp linguini was truly amazing. Those two dishes we actually recommend.

If we ever return, it will only be because of the atmosphere and the manager’s service—not the food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

Matt McKenna

Happy hour Oysters were great. Other food was jus ok.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Penni Hayes

We sat at the bar. All locals. Sometimes that can feel uncomfortable. Would have to try again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kim Durnett

Great seafood and drinks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lowell Moustakas

Great oysters

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Susan Marie

I've been all over the country and right in my backyard is this surprise of a good restaurant. All 3 of our meals were outstanding. I got the Horseradish Grouper, my boyfriend the Jambalaya, and his son, fish a chips. We all loved our dinners. Fast service, good beer and wine options. Will definitely add to our list of dinner spots.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wanda Love

The oysters were tiny. The food was just ok.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Loading...