Yummy pizza, bright sauce, and nice proportion of sauce to the cheese, a little greasy, but didn't bother us. We popped in for a nice, quiet lunch and then dinner another time. We got slices of cheese for lunch (and then had seconds it was so good), and a large cheese another night for dinner. Our 1y/o loved the pizza so much she danced in the high chair as she ate it lol we picked up a large cheese and brought it to the beach one evening and had it there on a park bench for an easy, inexpensive weeknight date with daddy :) a solid go-to for good pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Schwartz
We got take out from Goodfellas for dinner. The menu on line is accurate. We had cheese slices, cheese calzone with bacon, Bronx bomber sub, and NJ French fries. Good food and reasonable prices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
James Smith
Great service and food! Charming mom and pop. The owner, Joe, is an awesome guy!
Shaun Spadafora
There are TONS of pizza places that are adorned with pictures of NYC, and this place is no different. However, Goodfellas Pizza actually tastes like authentic NY pizza. It’s uncanny. I had two slices of pepperoni and it felt like I was sitting in Manhattan. They also have bottled beer for sale which is a plus. Would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Juan Gomez
The cashier at this establishment was highly aggressive and demonstrated a complete lack of customer service skills. This isn't an isolated incident; I've noticed several other reviews mentioning the same issue. I strongly recommend the owner address this immediately, as this individual's behavior is significantly detracting from the customer experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Christopher Thomson
Nice sub and pizza place in the plaza corner. Brooklyn vibes. Great subs and salads. Everything cooked to order
luciana pontes
The pizza was actually pretty good, but it was by far the worst service we've experienced in the area. We're tourists and we understand that our English may not be perfect, but the cashier made unpleasant faces at our family the entire time, and the man making the pizzas was consistently rude and disrespectful. Unfortunately, the pizza was not worth the poor treatment we received. I do not recommend this place.
Non Accessible
Unfortunately this place went downhill. The cashiers are rude to the very few customers they rarely have and the pizza and other food are just okay. To highlight how terrible the workers are here, they don’t even have any delivery drivers! I mean how embarrassing. With all the great pizza places around town, I don’t see myself ever trying here again. Dominos even sounds better than here, especially since they can actually afford drivers.
Jeff Miller
New York style pizza with pepperoni was burnt, no sauce, no taste and dry. First time, last time.
Joe Maresca
Best Italian food ever Pizza was good Sausage sub was GREAT Grilled Chicken salad was awesome
Ordered from ubereats. Paid over $40. Claimed they lost the order. Never answered my 5 phone calls. This business sucks.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Eliz Mez
The pizza is so good but the guy with the beard is racist. They don’t even acknowledge Spanish people only white. If you’re a different race don’t go here…..
Yummy pizza, bright sauce, and nice proportion of sauce to the cheese, a little greasy, but didn't bother us. We popped in for a nice, quiet lunch and then dinner another time. We got slices of cheese for lunch (and then had seconds it was so good), and a large cheese another night for dinner. Our 1y/o loved the pizza so much she danced in the high chair as she ate it lol we picked up a large cheese and brought it to the beach one evening and had it there on a park bench for an easy, inexpensive weeknight date with daddy :) a solid go-to for good pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We got take out from Goodfellas for dinner. The menu on line is accurate. We had cheese slices, cheese calzone with bacon, Bronx bomber sub, and NJ French fries. Good food and reasonable prices.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great service and food! Charming mom and pop. The owner, Joe, is an awesome guy!
There are TONS of pizza places that are adorned with pictures of NYC, and this place is no different. However, Goodfellas Pizza actually tastes like authentic NY pizza. It’s uncanny. I had two slices of pepperoni and it felt like I was sitting in Manhattan. They also have bottled beer for sale which is a plus. Would highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cashier at this establishment was highly aggressive and demonstrated a complete lack of customer service skills. This isn't an isolated incident; I've noticed several other reviews mentioning the same issue. I strongly recommend the owner address this immediately, as this individual's behavior is significantly detracting from the customer experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Nice sub and pizza place in the plaza corner. Brooklyn vibes. Great subs and salads. Everything cooked to order
The pizza was actually pretty good, but it was by far the worst service we've experienced in the area.
We're tourists and we understand that our English may not be perfect, but the cashier made unpleasant faces at our family the entire time, and the man making the pizzas was consistently rude and disrespectful.
Unfortunately, the pizza was not worth the poor treatment we received. I do not recommend this place.
Unfortunately this place went downhill. The cashiers are rude to the very few customers they rarely have and the pizza and other food are just okay. To highlight how terrible the workers are here, they don’t even have any delivery drivers! I mean how embarrassing. With all the great pizza places around town, I don’t see myself ever trying here again. Dominos even sounds better than here, especially since they can actually afford drivers.
New York style pizza with pepperoni was burnt, no sauce, no taste and dry.
First time, last time.
Best Italian food ever
Pizza was good
Sausage sub was GREAT
Grilled Chicken salad was awesome
Restaurantji Recommends
0.0 rating
Ordered from ubereats. Paid over $40. Claimed they lost the order. Never answered my 5 phone calls. This business sucks.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza is so good but the guy with the beard is racist. They don’t even acknowledge Spanish people only white. If you’re a different race don’t go here…..
Good pizza and salad.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great pizza
Great service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...