Thank you Andres for such an amazing experience all the time. Give this place a chance. Don’t focus on the few negatives reviews. We are humans, so we are not perfect. If something is not right, give the chance to make it better by speaking to the staff directly and giving the opportunity to fix it. I’ve been coming to this place for the past year and I always feel like I am home. Great authentic food. Please support this local business. Thank you for such an amazing service all the time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Adam Ackerman
Very classy. Pizza was great! Ordered during the parade and was ready before it started!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
April Schuldt
EAT HERE!!! The food is Amazing!!!!! & pleeeease stop& talk to the owner! He's awesome, thru&thru, & its evident in the food, ambiance, honesty, friendliness, and posititvity that you get& feel as soon as you walk through the door!!Thk u for feeding me & being Family, to me, for my visit. P.S.to the staff: I did pay my 2nd bill before I left!
Dawn Richards
The best pizza in Central Florida! So happy to have discovered this place. Quality ingredients, the best handmade crust I’ve Eve had, outside of Italy. I cannot even tell you how great it is. Do your taste buds a favor and order pizza here!
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Hot Honey Pizza, Tiramisu, Pizza Bianca
Angie Resendes
Amazing restaurant to get delicious food! We were visiting friends in the area and noone wanted to cook. Lol We were a group of 6 and sat at our table quickly. I ordered the personal size meat lovers pizza...which can easily feed 2! I loved the all natural ingredients, the pizza dough was so light and my stomach didn't leave with a heavy feeling...like when I eat most pizzas. The owner came around and was friendly with all the customers. He chatted with my brother and friends for a while, bringing on lots of laughter....remember us?! If you have never tried this restaurant, in Lake Alfred, you are missing out on great Italian food! Go see for yourself!💜
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fernando Alonso
Great pizza place near Winter Haven. Traditional Italian style with a real wood oven, and every pizza is made from scratch, starting with the dough you can see them preparing. Staff is friendly, service is excellent, and the pizzas are truly outstanding. Totally recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ALENA ABDRAKHMANOVA
Real thin crust Italian pizza and homemade Italian deserts. My entire family enjoys it so much that we don’t mind driving here 20-25 minutes from the Legoland resort!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oksana Orda
I don’t usually leave reviews, but this was such a disappointing experience that I actually created a Google account just to warn others. This was my first—and definitely my last—time ordering from here through Uber Eats.
I ordered two pizzas: • Funghi Pizza — advertised as having “wild mushrooms,” but it came with basic, plain mushrooms of only one type. • NY Cheese Pizza with added pepperoni — I paid an extra $2 for pepperoni, but the pizza arrived as a plain cheese pie.
Both pizzas arrived cold (possibly Uber Eats’ fault, but still part of the overall bad experience). The real issue was the quality. Both pizzas were bland, barely had cheese, and whatever flavor might have been there was completely overpowered by the awful burnt taste of the crust. The entire bottom was black and charred, and when you take a bite, you can’t taste anything except that harsh, bitter burnt flavor. No cheese, no sauce, no toppings—just burnt crust.
We ended up eating it anyway because we had nothing else planned for dinner and were hungry, but honestly, we felt like we’d end up with a stomach ache afterward. It was just that bad.
Overall, it was gross, disappointing, and a complete waste of money. It ruined dinner, and I won’t be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Tara Nesbihal
Someone made a recommendation for this pizza on next-door and having had many recommendations that were awful Pizza, I was not very optimistic. The pizza however, was Delicious! The place is a tiny hole in the wall in a very quiet area of Lake Alfred. The pizza is very thin, stone-fired with loads of flavor. If you want delicious pizza with a crust that you won’t want to leave on the plate definitely try this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Brown
Genuinely the best and most authentic people I have EVER had! So glad I found this place because I’ve traveled the world, and this is BY far top of my pizza ranking list. You MUST go here!!!
All they have is 12” pizzas. Keep that in mind when ordering for a group.
Kate Dietz
Huge shout-out to Calogero Pizzeria in Lake Alfred, the owners and staff! My husband and I ordered a pizza about 30 mins before closing on Door dash, and when we showed up they had not received the order. (Highly recommend that you just call or order on Slice) Even though we told them not to worry, that we would order again on a different day, the younger gentleman said he wanted to make it for us! We spoke to the owner, and he showed us around, and everyone there is just so nice, real and down to earth. Just really nice people, and amazing pizza. Definitely get a pie sometime and support them! We'll be back soon 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill Crawford
Just love this place....They now have indoor dining. These pizzas are the bomb Hot honey today ...
Vero Perez
Delicious pizzas and paninis. Food was fresh and authentic. Looking forward to the next pie!
Thank you Andres for such an amazing experience all the time. Give this place a chance. Don’t focus on the few negatives reviews. We are humans, so we are not perfect. If something is not right, give the chance to make it better by speaking to the staff directly and giving the opportunity to fix it. I’ve been coming to this place for the past year and I always feel like I am home. Great authentic food. Please support this local business. Thank you for such an amazing service all the time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very classy. Pizza was great! Ordered during the parade and was ready before it started!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
EAT HERE!!! The food is Amazing!!!!! & pleeeease stop& talk to the owner! He's awesome, thru&thru, & its evident in the food, ambiance, honesty, friendliness, and posititvity that you get& feel as soon as you walk through the door!!Thk u for feeding me & being Family, to me, for my visit.
P.S.to the staff: I did pay my 2nd bill before I left!
The best pizza in Central Florida! So happy to have discovered this place. Quality ingredients, the best handmade crust I’ve Eve had, outside of Italy. I cannot even tell you how great it is. Do your taste buds a favor and order pizza here!
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Hot Honey Pizza, Tiramisu, Pizza Bianca
Amazing restaurant to get delicious food!
We were visiting friends in the area and noone wanted to cook. Lol
We were a group of 6 and sat at our table quickly. I ordered the personal size meat lovers pizza...which can easily feed 2!
I loved the all natural ingredients, the pizza dough was so light and my stomach didn't leave with a heavy feeling...like when I eat most pizzas.
The owner came around and was friendly with all the customers. He chatted with my brother and friends for a while, bringing on lots of laughter....remember us?!
If you have never tried this restaurant, in Lake Alfred, you are missing out on great Italian food! Go see for yourself!💜
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza place near Winter Haven. Traditional Italian style with a real wood oven, and every pizza is made from scratch, starting with the dough you can see them preparing. Staff is friendly, service is excellent, and the pizzas are truly outstanding. Totally recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Real thin crust Italian pizza and homemade Italian deserts. My entire family enjoys it so much that we don’t mind driving here 20-25 minutes from the Legoland resort!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don’t usually leave reviews, but this was such a disappointing experience that I actually created a Google account just to warn others. This was my first—and definitely my last—time ordering from here through Uber Eats.
I ordered two pizzas:
• Funghi Pizza — advertised as having “wild mushrooms,” but it came with basic, plain mushrooms of only one type.
• NY Cheese Pizza with added pepperoni — I paid an extra $2 for pepperoni, but the pizza arrived as a plain cheese pie.
Both pizzas arrived cold (possibly Uber Eats’ fault, but still part of the overall bad experience). The real issue was the quality. Both pizzas were bland, barely had cheese, and whatever flavor might have been there was completely overpowered by the awful burnt taste of the crust. The entire bottom was black and charred, and when you take a bite, you can’t taste anything except that harsh, bitter burnt flavor. No cheese, no sauce, no toppings—just burnt crust.
We ended up eating it anyway because we had nothing else planned for dinner and were hungry, but honestly, we felt like we’d end up with a stomach ache afterward. It was just that bad.
Overall, it was gross, disappointing, and a complete waste of money. It ruined dinner, and I won’t be ordering from here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Someone made a recommendation for this pizza on next-door and having had many recommendations that were awful Pizza, I was not very optimistic. The pizza however, was Delicious! The place is a tiny hole in the wall in a very quiet area of Lake Alfred. The pizza is very thin, stone-fired with loads of flavor. If you want delicious pizza with a crust that you won’t want to leave on the plate definitely try this place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Genuinely the best and most authentic people I have EVER had! So glad I found this place because I’ve traveled the world, and this is BY far top of my pizza ranking list. You MUST go here!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Too expensive and too salty.
Food: 3
All they have is 12” pizzas. Keep that in mind when ordering for a group.
Huge shout-out to Calogero Pizzeria in Lake Alfred, the owners and staff! My husband and I ordered a pizza about 30 mins before closing on Door dash, and when we showed up they had not received the order. (Highly recommend that you just call or order on Slice) Even though we told them not to worry, that we would order again on a different day, the younger gentleman said he wanted to make it for us! We spoke to the owner, and he showed us around, and everyone there is just so nice, real and down to earth. Just really nice people, and amazing pizza. Definitely get a pie sometime and support them! We'll be back soon 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just love this place....They now have indoor dining. These pizzas are the bomb Hot honey today ...
Delicious pizzas and paninis. Food was fresh and authentic. Looking forward to the next pie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...