Fun retro atmosphere with an excellent selection of ice creams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark van deman
Great ice cream but overpriced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
T T
Per Mom, best ice cream I have ever tasted. (It’s fantastic!!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Betty W.
Great little ice cream shop! Friendly efficient service and wonderful ice cream! The shop is decorated with lots of cool memorabilia. We sat and visited and consumed our ice cream and never felt rushed. Will definitely go back!
Tammy P.
Infused ice cream available for Adult beverage lovers. You can even try samples prior to purchase. Service was great too.
Rohan D.
I have gone to mystic Ice Cream for 3 years to get ice cream and the ice cream is incredible. The atmosphere inside is very relaxed with movie posters and artists and very colorful. If you go frequently you can get a stamp card and if you get 10 punches, you can spin a wheel and get a free gift! The people who work there are very nice down to earth and make me want to come back
Rebecca Howard
Good milkshakes!
Luis A Marrero
Awesome the best ice cream in Florida also the service was awesome too
Chris F.
Great customer service and a great atmosphere. We stopped by and were able to try out several tasters to decide on what we wanted to get. Ended up going with the coffee ice cream. It was extremely potent in a good way and you could tell it was made with real coffee. The small was massive by itself and ended up being eaten over several days while snacking on it. We will defiantly be coming back to try on the rotating flavors when in the area.
Lennard Carter
If you love ice cream, especially ice cream for big kids, then Mystic Ice Cream is the best place.
Soooo yumtastic!!!! Will definitely be back..such a "peaceful" atmosphere as well
Bianca Villarini
I will give this spot a 5 star rating if the guy who attended us was actually friendly..he has a not so great attitude. On top of the “ttude” my husband wanted a milkshake and he said “I can’t do a milkshake right now” what surprised us about this was the fact that he JUST made not one but TWO milkshakes to the customers that went before us…like what? The ice cream is good but the lack of customer service took away from the experience.
Lisa Elder
You need to try this ice cream! I always go for their adult flavors, which change frequently. I've never been disappointed. All of their ice cream is handmade and is so good! Their employees are so friendly and the shop is fun and retro!
Michael O
This is an awesome little spot to get in out of the heat and cool off with an awesome dessert after a meal or afternoon snack. They have a great variety of flavors, both alcoholic and non-alcoholic. We have tried a variety of their ice creams and have yet to be disappointed by anything we have tried. If you're ever in the area this is a 'must try' experience.
Brian Hendricks
Very cool place, great vinyl music vibes from classic artists back in the day, the ice cream I had actually had whisky in it (Peanut Butter whiskey & Jam). The gentleman working behind the counter was very friendly and welcoming, peace vibes throughout! Highly recommend if you’re in the area, homemade ice cream with traditional and “adult” (alcohol) flavors! Very very cool!
Fun retro atmosphere with an excellent selection of ice creams.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great ice cream but overpriced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Per Mom, best ice cream I have ever tasted. (It’s fantastic!!!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little ice cream shop! Friendly efficient service and wonderful ice cream! The shop is decorated with lots of cool memorabilia. We sat and visited and consumed our ice cream and never felt rushed. Will definitely go back!
Infused ice cream available for Adult beverage lovers. You can even try samples prior to purchase. Service was great too.
I have gone to mystic Ice Cream for 3 years to get ice cream and the ice cream is incredible. The atmosphere inside is very relaxed with movie posters and artists and very colorful. If you go frequently you can get a stamp card and if you get 10 punches, you can spin a wheel and get a free gift! The people who work there are very nice down to earth and make me want to come back
Good milkshakes!
Awesome the best ice cream in Florida also the service was awesome too
Great customer service and a great atmosphere. We stopped by and were able to try out several tasters to decide on what we wanted to get. Ended up going with the coffee ice cream. It was extremely potent in a good way and you could tell it was made with real coffee. The small was massive by itself and ended up being eaten over several days while snacking on it. We will defiantly be coming back to try on the rotating flavors when in the area.
If you love ice cream, especially ice cream for big kids, then Mystic Ice Cream is the best place.
Restaurantji Recommends
Soooo yumtastic!!!! Will definitely be back..such a "peaceful" atmosphere as well
I will give this spot a 5 star rating if the guy who attended us was actually friendly..he has a not so great attitude. On top of the “ttude” my husband wanted a milkshake and he said “I can’t do a milkshake right now” what surprised us about this was the fact that he JUST made not one but TWO milkshakes to the customers that went before us…like what? The ice cream is good but the lack of customer service took away from the experience.
You need to try this ice cream! I always go for their adult flavors, which change frequently. I've never been disappointed. All of their ice cream is handmade and is so good! Their employees are so friendly and the shop is fun and retro!
This is an awesome little spot to get in out of the heat and cool off with an awesome dessert after a meal or afternoon snack. They have a great variety of flavors, both alcoholic and non-alcoholic. We have tried a variety of their ice creams and have yet to be disappointed by anything we have tried. If you're ever in the area this is a 'must try' experience.
Very cool place, great vinyl music vibes from classic artists back in the day, the ice cream I had actually had whisky in it (Peanut Butter whiskey & Jam). The gentleman working behind the counter was very friendly and welcoming, peace vibes throughout! Highly recommend if you’re in the area, homemade ice cream with traditional and “adult” (alcohol) flavors! Very very cool!