Amish Creamery Co

211 150th Ave, Madeira Beach
(727) 397-8222

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Cailyn Starks

The best ice cream in the area! Creamy and rich!

Linda Felt

The staff was professional and ice cream yummy 😋.

Lloyd Muse

The richest, creamiest ice cream I’ve ever tasted. Lots of flavors to choose from. It was great! The older gentleman behind the counter was very friendly and great to my family. Highly recommend.

Lexi Bemann

COME HERE!
The ice cream is so rich and creamy, wow!
Got to talking to the owner, wow, can’t help but to feel for the people with all the endured down here from that hurricane! (Well the two hurricanes actually)
Please go support this small local business! You won’t regret it. We got the premium chocolate ice cream in a dish and my son was very impressed. Please guys come support this place! The people that work here are kind folks. Reminded me of the old folk back in Tn. ❤️

Eric Waller

Probably the best ice cream shop I have ever been to. The owner Clint was super friendly. So many options and hands down the best ice cream I have ever had. Absolutely going back!!

Martin K.

Great place, great owner. This is how ice cream should be made and the shakes are also great. We come here more often from now on.

Cody Pennell

Absolutely the whole experience here. Wonderful service and an outstanding product. I will be coming back to the area just to visit this shop for some delicious ice cream and shake Clint’s hand again with a smile.

Cassandra Cassandra

Every flavor I tried was THE ONE!! The decision was so hard. I settled on two, but it took every ounce of discipline I could muster up!
No seating available, but it was so good, I didn't care. The ice-cream flavors are amazingly creamy and rich, and I normally drive an hour for another Amish store, but not anymore! I am not a 5-star giver, but I would give the 10 if possible.
A server recommended it at lunch, and she was so convincing, I drove straight there. Thank you, Star!

K D

Ice cream: excellent
The way the owner treats the workers is insane! I went there about 1 month ago and the air conditioner was not working- the poor girl behind the counter was sweating. Fast forward a month and I went back in there: the air conditioner is still broken and it’s a unit mounted onto the wall which does not take rocket science to install a new one!! I cannot believe the owner is allowing this to go on. The workers could have a heatstroke in there!!

Wald Family

We normally try to go to a different ice cream shop each day on our vacations but we all agreed that we're coming back here tomorrow! The employees were friendly and the ice cream is amazing!

Michael Shandor

The ice cream was excellent! The employee was super friendly and very helpful. Will definitely come back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roxann Poceous

The ice cream is so delicious! The owner is the sweetest man! He has been at this location for 19 years! He sells homemade Amish butter, jams, pasta, and other items. It is worth stopping in to try his homemade icecream. I can't wait to visit again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Rizzo

I can't share a picture of the spumoni because I ate it too fast! Delicious ice cream (with small and large containers to go!), great staff- Clint is amazing! Support local ♡♡♡

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Coconut, Sorbet, Coconut Almond, Toasted Coconut Ice Cream

TO Family

Best rum and raisin. Had us dreaming about! Very friendly service, large portions. Absolutely delicious!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kasie Wade

I wish they were here in Polk county. The ice cream was delicious. I had the triple peanut butter and the chocolate chip cookies dough

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...