Deliciously creamy and a wide variety of flavors They serve Yoder's homemade out of Sarasota and regularly refresh the supply. The only downside could be the price - not the MOST expensive around, but high quality demands top dollar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sean S
Love this place!! We go back every year that we’re in the area for spring break. Our whole family looks forward to it. Best ice cream in the country! (And we’ve tried A LOT) Excellent service too, the owner of frequently there scooping.
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Amish Creamery Co., and I must say, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we stepped in, Clint's customer service was nothing short of exceptional – a solid 10 out of 10. Not only did he make us feel incredibly welcome, but he also took the time to share insights into his culture and the art of crafting their delicious ice cream.Clint's warmth and kindness truly shone through, making us feel like part of the family. Learning about the Amish culture added a unique and enriching layer to our visit, making it more than just a stop for ice cream.Speaking of ice cream, let me tell you, it was phenomenal. Finding both delicious and genuinely healthy treats can be challenging, but Amish Creamery Co. nailed it. Every scoop was a perfect balance of flavor and quality ingredients.But what truly sets this place apart is Clint himself. His genuine care for his customers and passion for his craft make Amish Creamery Co. a true hidden gem. I left with a full heart and an even fuller belly, eager to spread the word and support this wonderful business.Thank you, Clint, for an unforgettable experience. Your kindness and attention to detail truly made our visit special. I wholeheartedly recommend everyone to support Amish Creamery Co. – not just for the incredible ice cream, but for the outstanding service and warm hospitality.
If this place was on the beach or closer, I'm positive that there would be a line all day. The quality of the ice cream is top tier compared to the rest of the ice cream shops in the area. They also have more than just ice cream. This place is honestly a hidden gem. Don't let the strip mall scare you away!
Kitty Bergner
Ice cream is the best I've ever had. Ask for a receipt when paying with a credit card, the guy that works there is not the best with charging the correct amount.
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Banana Crunch, Peanut Butter Cup
Ben W.
10/5 stars. The woman working tonight was patient with my kids choosing flavors, offered them sprinkles, and didn't judge their excited behavior. The flavors are all fresh and the facility is both clean and organized. 10/5 stars
Morgan Lyon
Best ice cream ive ever had. The chocolate fudge brownie and peanut butter and jelly are so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reanna Capra
Ice cream is one thousand percent the best ice cream I’ve ever had (banana pudding flavor is TO DIE FOR). You can taste the authenticity in every bite. My husband and I love running into the owner Clint during our visits, he’s the nicest guy and really cares about every customer’s experience! One of a kind place for sure
What a hidden gem this place is. The blueberry cheese cake ice cream in a waffle cone was the best part of my day. They use fresh blueberries and big chucks of actual cheesecake. Truly fresh homemade ice cream. I’ll be returning many more times. Thank you!!
Stacey D.
The best most creamy ice cream I've ever had. They have Amish treats. The buttermilk cookies are the best. Must try this little gem.
lizcoury
Some of, if not the best ice cream I've ever had. I wish we hadn't waited until the last night of vacation to try so we could've gone back!
Dezzy
100/10 definitely recommend to anyone in the area!! me & my fiancé stopped in after the beach and was amazed by the many options you have in everything, the sodas are delicious as well! great quality
Elite ice cream and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deliciously creamy and a wide variety of flavors They serve Yoder's homemade out of Sarasota and regularly refresh the supply. The only downside could be the price - not the MOST expensive around, but high quality demands top dollar.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place!! We go back every year that we’re in the area for spring break. Our whole family looks forward to it. Best ice cream in the country! (And we’ve tried A LOT) Excellent service too, the owner of frequently there scooping.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Coffee Bean, Strawberry Cheesecake, Mocha Almond Fudge
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Amish Creamery Co., and I must say, it was an unforgettable experience. From the moment we stepped in, Clint's customer service was nothing short of exceptional – a solid 10 out of 10. Not only did he make us feel incredibly welcome, but he also took the time to share insights into his culture and the art of crafting their delicious ice cream.Clint's warmth and kindness truly shone through, making us feel like part of the family. Learning about the Amish culture added a unique and enriching layer to our visit, making it more than just a stop for ice cream.Speaking of ice cream, let me tell you, it was phenomenal. Finding both delicious and genuinely healthy treats can be challenging, but Amish Creamery Co. nailed it. Every scoop was a perfect balance of flavor and quality ingredients.But what truly sets this place apart is Clint himself. His genuine care for his customers and passion for his craft make Amish Creamery Co. a true hidden gem. I left with a full heart and an even fuller belly, eager to spread the word and support this wonderful business.Thank you, Clint, for an unforgettable experience. Your kindness and attention to detail truly made our visit special. I wholeheartedly recommend everyone to support Amish Creamery Co. – not just for the incredible ice cream, but for the outstanding service and warm hospitality.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toasted Coconut, Coconut Almond
If this place was on the beach or closer, I'm positive that there would be a line all day. The quality of the ice cream is top tier compared to the rest of the ice cream shops in the area. They also have more than just ice cream. This place is honestly a hidden gem. Don't let the strip mall scare you away!
Ice cream is the best I've ever had. Ask for a receipt when paying with a credit card, the guy that works there is not the best with charging the correct amount.
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Banana Crunch, Peanut Butter Cup
10/5 stars. The woman working tonight was patient with my kids choosing flavors, offered them sprinkles, and didn't judge their excited behavior. The flavors are all fresh and the facility is both clean and organized. 10/5 stars
Best ice cream ive ever had. The chocolate fudge brownie and peanut butter and jelly are so
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ice cream is one thousand percent the best ice cream I’ve ever had (banana pudding flavor is TO DIE FOR). You can taste the authenticity in every bite. My husband and I love running into the owner Clint during our visits, he’s the nicest guy and really cares about every customer’s experience! One of a kind place for sure
Wonderful real ice cream. Very friendly staff.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream I've ever had.
What a hidden gem this place is. The blueberry cheese cake ice cream in a waffle cone was the best part of my day. They use fresh blueberries and big chucks of actual cheesecake. Truly fresh homemade ice cream. I’ll be returning many more times. Thank you!!
The best most creamy ice cream I've ever had. They have Amish treats. The buttermilk cookies are the best. Must try this little gem.
Some of, if not the best ice cream I've ever had. I wish we hadn't waited until the last night of vacation to try so we could've gone back!
100/10 definitely recommend to anyone in the area!! me & my fiancé stopped in after the beach and was amazed by the many options you have in everything, the sodas are delicious as well! great quality