Plaza Grill Restaurant,

5101 Overseas Hwy, Marathon
(305) 743-7874

Recent Reviews

Sort by
claudia

Best crab cakes anywhere, even better than Baltimore. Also excellent salads. Best restsurant un Marathon.

Renee

Excellent meal. Great cocktails- especially liked the old fashion- and wine selection. Enjoyed an abundant serving of fried calamari and a truly delicious pesto risotto with big fish. Risotto was the perfect texture and the hogfish broiled simply was very delicate and moist. The space is so inviting and cozy. We will be back!

Stan

Outstanding as usual! Great service from Norman and everyone's meals were delicious. Ice cold drinks and great atmosphere. Thanks Malva for the VIP treatment. We will be back. Cheers.

Nancy

Beautiful atmosphere. Lovely staff and hostess. Delicious wine. I should have had a conversation before dinner about vegan options. The salad I had was amazing, but a pasta dish would have been nice, too.

Susan

Plaza Grill's service and food are fantastic! The entire staff were friendly and made us feel welcome from the moment we stepped through the door. Our server Norman went above and beyond to make sure our anniversary celebration was so special! The fresh catch risotto was delicious! Definitely don't miss an opportunity to enjoy a meal at the Plaza Grill!

Sharon

This place was recommended by a friend and we gave it a try, the place is beautiful and the food looks good and drinks is amazing, we we’re enjoying our appetizer the lobster bites(very delicious) and saw cockroaches crawling on our table, our server is nice but he smells so bad, between cockroaches and over powering body odor we lose our appetite, I ask my husband if he smells it too and he said yes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 1

Cheryl

Norman took great care of us, great service and made for a very nice dinner and evening, food is always great and great cocktails too!

Yensi Heredia

This restaurant is the STAR of Marathon. Only the freshest and cleanest food is served here. The Owner Malva is very attentive and professional. Out waitress Daniella was super attentive as well providing amazing service. All of the food and cocktails we had were absolutely amazing. The number one restaurant in the Florida Keys for exceptional food and amazing service. ⭐️😍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Damon

This is one of the best restaurants on MarathonKey or easily in the Keys. They truly make you feel welcome from the minute you walk in. The food is amazing, they have white tablecloths and cloth napkins~ love, excellent service! And plenty of parking ;)

Cynthia

From the full bar to the main menu, everything was delicious. The special that night was hogfish piccata, it was very tasty. Hubby had the clams with linguine. He said it was one of the best he's ever had! You know the kind where you want to keep doing the Italian bread in the broth! We didn't have dessert because we were so full. The ambience is beauty and the staff Is professional. I had a delicious cosmo and hubby had an old fashioned. Both were perfect!

Robbie Jandik

Seriously one of the BEST Cheeseburgers I’ve EVER had around the world. It alone is a 9.5/10 …. but if they could get the fries even better it would be perfect!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbara

Wonderful restaurant, with the best of everything....food, ambiance, service and drinks. You don't always need to be on the water to enjoy dining in the Keys. Plaza Grill is always a great choice, their menu and specials are always good.

Becky Walton

Malva is the best and the place is beautiful with excellent drinks and food. A must visit in marathon

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Marks

What a dreadful meal! I had the Risotto - big mistake, imagine a huge bowl of overcooked rice pudding with 4 scallops floating on top. Wine was awful, could not hear each other as the large table was so noisy, killed the atmosphere. Definitely not going there again- oh and expensive! There are way better places to eat in Marathon.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Stormie Pruskauer

Fabulous dining experience! The staff was so welcoming, the dinner was immaculate, and the service from Michael was amazing! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...