Highly recommend eating here. Pizza was great, cooked perfectly. Staff is very friendly. Very small dining room, but incredibly intimate. This is a must go if you’re craving pizza while in Marathon.
Charlotte L
Great restaurant , lovely welcome , fantastic service and excellent pizza . I’m vegetarian and unsurprisingly ordered the vegetarian pizza , fresh toppings , good quality cheese and tomato sauce and lovely crispy base . My husband ordered the Delux which was also excellent. Restaurant was filled with locals , families and some tourists and it has a good feel to it . We managed to demolish the Blueberry cobbler which was excellent as well , fresh and all made on the premises . Would highly recommend .
luismY6823XJ
My son says it's the best pizza he's ever eaten. Very rich in flavor and a size that corresponds to the photos. Very good service while we waited!
Stephanie Sumrall
Pizza was delicious!! Staff was very friendly! Highly highly recommend 🍕
columbiatraveller
Best pizza in Marathon and I always go there when in Marathon. A small seating area and a challenge to find off of Route 1. I guess that is all.
celinebZ4923TK
Pizza was sooooo delicious! My husband and I have high standards when it comes to pizza and the deluxe pizza we had is our new favorite.
B1426AJjoek
This place is absolutely amazing. The spaghetti with Bolognese and meatballs was out of this world and the homemade desserts and pizza are amazing Highly recommend
K751RZearlb
Great place to get great pizza. I also see a lot of ppl getting the pasta with garlic bread, one day I’ll have to try it too. I go as often as I can, can’t get enough of the Happy Unicorn (white sauce) it’s sooo good. I love this place.
lambdaUNC
The three of us shared a large salad and a medium deluxe pizza. The salad portion was generous enough. The pizza was delicious. It’s a thin crust that is very tasty and not soggy the way thin crust can be sometimes. We also had a slice of key lime pie that was very good with just the right amount of tartness.
Dale Radcliff Jr.
Pizza was great, I'd give that 5 stars. Price wise, Idk if I was overcharged or something but $88 for 2 large pizzas and a cheesey garlic bread is kind of wild
Pizza is excellent. Garlic bread is literally homemade texas toast and its 2 pieces. So, $4 for a big slice of texas toast....skip it and stick with pizza.
Vegetarian options: Crust and bread doughs are vegan. Told they use oil base butter for their garlic butter spreads
Dietary restrictions: Alpha-gal friendly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Jack Noteboom
Excellent Pizza, friendly service and a quaint pizzeria to dine in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
dawn cooley
So happy we chose this place, excellent food and service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe, Pepperoni Pizza
Rafa O
Been our goto in marathon for 12 years ! Best pizza o island
Highly recommend eating here. Pizza was great, cooked perfectly. Staff is very friendly. Very small dining room, but incredibly intimate. This is a must go if you’re craving pizza while in Marathon.
Great restaurant , lovely welcome , fantastic service and excellent pizza . I’m vegetarian and unsurprisingly ordered the vegetarian pizza , fresh toppings , good quality cheese and tomato sauce and lovely crispy base . My husband ordered the Delux which was also excellent. Restaurant was filled with locals , families and some tourists and it has a good feel to it . We managed to demolish the Blueberry cobbler which was excellent as well , fresh and all made on the premises . Would highly recommend .
My son says it's the best pizza he's ever eaten. Very rich in flavor and a size that corresponds to the photos. Very good service while we waited!
Pizza was delicious!! Staff was very friendly! Highly highly recommend 🍕
Best pizza in Marathon and I always go there when in Marathon. A small seating area and a challenge to find off of Route 1. I guess that is all.
Pizza was sooooo delicious! My husband and I have high standards when it comes to pizza and the deluxe pizza we had is our new favorite.
This place is absolutely amazing. The spaghetti with Bolognese and meatballs was out of this world and the homemade desserts and pizza are amazing Highly recommend
Great place to get great pizza. I also see a lot of ppl getting the pasta with garlic bread, one day I’ll have to try it too. I go as often as I can, can’t get enough of the Happy Unicorn (white sauce) it’s sooo good. I love this place.
The three of us shared a large salad and a medium deluxe pizza. The salad portion was generous enough. The pizza was delicious. It’s a thin crust that is very tasty and not soggy the way thin crust can be sometimes. We also had a slice of key lime pie that was very good with just the right amount of tartness.
Pizza was great, I'd give that 5 stars. Price wise, Idk if I was overcharged or something but $88 for 2 large pizzas and a cheesey garlic bread is kind of wild
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza is excellent. Garlic bread is literally homemade texas toast and its 2 pieces. So, $4 for a big slice of texas toast....skip it and stick with pizza.
Vegetarian options: Crust and bread doughs are vegan. Told they use oil base butter for their garlic butter spreads
Dietary restrictions: Alpha-gal friendly
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Excellent Pizza, friendly service and a quaint pizzeria to dine in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So happy we chose this place, excellent food and service!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Deluxe, Pepperoni Pizza
Been our goto in marathon for 12 years ! Best pizza o island
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delish!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Loading...