If I were cooking this pizza and pulled it out of the oven and saw that I had left it in too long, say an hour and a half. I would have immediately starting making a new one to replace it, instead, they threw it the box and bam!, Hosed me for $23! No sir, won’t do that again!
Michael Ervin
The pizza is very inconsistent which causes the taste to be good to great. It's not a huge deal since most of the time it's better than most. I only tried the pizza items, so I can speak to the rest, but if the pizza is inconsistent then the others are probably also. The service is great, the atmosphere on the bar side is great, the pizza joint side, not so much, it's pretty run down.
David Gill
Sometimes spot on, and sometimes terrible. Completely inconsistent delivery. We have many times ordered pizza delivered. About 40% of the time, it is great. Tonight, we got a pizza that was like cardboard (and cold), even though we live 6 minutes away. Once we got a pizza delivered upside-down (in the box) and ruined, sometimes not even the toppings that we have ordered. Many times we have had to wait nearly an hour for this inconsistent food. I have not even mentioned the crazy price for food that is often such low quality that you would expect better at a street fair. To be clear, most of our problem is with their delivery, and that you can't just send it back. We have had a little better luck dining in. Think we are about done with Kelseys delivery, just not a lot of other options around North Merritt.
abby Gamble
everything was cold. this is supposed to be pulled pork
Chloe
Greek salad is made with the cheapest iceberg lettuce that provides no nutritional value and will only make your gut upset. The meat on the same salad was as pale as a farmers chest. ALSO not real feta cheese, basically American cheese crumbles. Just get pizza.
Patrick Wikstrom
Kelsey’s Pizza/Jack n’ Harry’s- Merritt Island Fla. 1/25/25 - While on an exploratory mission of the area around the Kennedy Space Center we picked this little Pizzeria and were perfectly satisfied. First off they had the least expensive Long Island Iced Tea ($8) I’d had all vacation. It was actually mixed at the immediately adjacent Jack & Harry’s Famous Food & Brews which was a popular bar/restaurant which had a pretty full menu of standard American food. It’s was a little cold in Jack’s when we came in and were about to be seated by the well used front door so we asked to be seated in the quieter and less hectic Pizza side of the place. Sitting where I was I saw a steady supply of Italian orders and pizzas leaving Kelsey’s and being carried into Jacks. It obviously is a well oiled symbiotic relationship. My wife ordered a large pie with black olives & peppers ($17.99) and I ordered a #5 Calzone with mushrooms and sausage, hold the pepperoni ($15.49). We over ordered so we could bring baked back to the motel and heat the leftovers up in the microwave. We enjoyed our meal that evening and it reheated well in the microwave the next day. 4****
Tammy Vargo
Filthy tables and floor. Very poor service . Sad to see it like this after years of going here .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Laura F
Nice neighborhood bar/restaurant. would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Greek Salad, Pizza
Arend Smits
Delicious pizzas, also gluten-free! Juliana, who served us, was extremely nice and helpful.
Phil Sargeant
Not even close to what it should be. Dirty and bad food. Used to be a nice place, but has gone way down hill.
Used to love this place, but new owners have utterly ruined it. They have taken wonderful dishes with good portions and turned them into a shell of what they used to be. WASTE OF MONEY!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Mark Carlson
Pizza has been burnt the last 2 times I’ve ordered from here. I’m losing faith.
Food: 2
Tammie Bentley
Pizza wasn't what I have become accustom to compared to the other locations, my crust was to thin and very soggy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Tony Linkkila
I'm from out of town. We ordered a Deluxe pizza and wings. Absolutely the WORST pizza I've eaten. Waited an hour for a luke warm large pizza with a small pizzas worth of toppings. 2" of empty crust around the outside and basically no sauce or cheese. What a rip off!!! Chicken wings sucked just as much... Don't waste your money!!!!!
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nicole Roberson-Rodríguez
We stopped here for dinner to celebrate a big accomplishment in our family. The atmosphere was cozy and our server was wonderful. The pizza was delicious and the Greek salad was a generous size. Everything was so fresh! Definitely recommend this restaurant for a family outing!
If I were cooking this pizza and pulled it out of the oven and saw that I had left it in too long, say an hour and a half. I would have immediately starting making a new one to replace it, instead, they threw it the box and bam!, Hosed me for $23! No sir, won’t do that again!
The pizza is very inconsistent which causes the taste to be good to great. It's not a huge deal since most of the time it's better than most. I only tried the pizza items, so I can speak to the rest, but if the pizza is inconsistent then the others are probably also. The service is great, the atmosphere on the bar side is great, the pizza joint side, not so much, it's pretty run down.
Sometimes spot on, and sometimes terrible. Completely inconsistent delivery. We have many times ordered pizza delivered. About 40% of the time, it is great. Tonight, we got a pizza that was like cardboard (and cold), even though we live 6 minutes away. Once we got a pizza delivered upside-down (in the box) and ruined, sometimes not even the toppings that we have ordered. Many times we have had to wait nearly an hour for this inconsistent food. I have not even mentioned the crazy price for food that is often such low quality that you would expect better at a street fair. To be clear, most of our problem is with their delivery, and that you can't just send it back. We have had a little better luck dining in. Think we are about done with Kelseys delivery, just not a lot of other options around North Merritt.
everything was cold. this is supposed to be pulled pork
Greek salad is made with the cheapest iceberg lettuce that provides no nutritional value and will only make your gut upset. The meat on the same salad was as pale as a farmers chest. ALSO not real feta cheese, basically American cheese crumbles.
Just get pizza.
Kelsey’s Pizza/Jack n’ Harry’s- Merritt Island Fla. 1/25/25 - While on an exploratory mission of the area around the Kennedy Space Center we picked this little Pizzeria and were perfectly satisfied. First off they had the least expensive Long Island Iced Tea ($8) I’d had all vacation. It was actually mixed at the immediately adjacent Jack & Harry’s Famous Food & Brews which was a popular bar/restaurant which had a pretty full menu of standard American food. It’s was a little cold in Jack’s when we came in and were about to be seated by the well used front door so we asked to be seated in the quieter and less hectic Pizza side of the place. Sitting where I was I saw a steady supply of Italian orders and pizzas leaving Kelsey’s and being carried into Jacks. It obviously is a well oiled symbiotic relationship.
My wife ordered a large pie with black olives & peppers ($17.99) and I ordered a #5 Calzone with mushrooms and sausage, hold the pepperoni ($15.49). We over ordered so we could bring baked back to the motel and heat the leftovers up in the microwave. We enjoyed our meal that evening and it reheated well in the microwave the next day.
4****
Filthy tables and floor. Very poor service . Sad to see it like this after years of going here .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Nice neighborhood bar/restaurant. would recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza and Greek Salad, Pizza
Delicious pizzas, also gluten-free! Juliana, who served us, was extremely nice and helpful.
Not even close to what it should be. Dirty and bad food. Used to be a nice place, but has gone way down hill.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Used to love this place, but new owners have utterly ruined it. They have taken wonderful dishes with good portions and turned them into a shell of what they used to be. WASTE OF MONEY!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Pizza has been burnt the last 2 times I’ve ordered from here. I’m losing faith.
Food: 2
Pizza wasn't what I have become accustom to compared to the other locations, my crust was to thin and very soggy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
I'm from out of town. We ordered a Deluxe pizza and wings. Absolutely the WORST pizza I've eaten. Waited an hour for a luke warm large pizza with a small pizzas worth of toppings. 2" of empty crust around the outside and basically no sauce or cheese. What a rip off!!! Chicken wings sucked just as much... Don't waste your money!!!!!
Food: 1
Service: 1
We stopped here for dinner to celebrate a big accomplishment in our family. The atmosphere was cozy and our server was wonderful. The pizza was delicious and the Greek salad was a generous size. Everything was so fresh! Definitely recommend this restaurant for a family outing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...