Molly's Seafood Shack

1580 E Merritt Island Causeway, Merritt Island
(321) 453-1288

Recent Reviews

Kathy And Larry H.

They are closed down. Went for lunch on 1/19/23 and no one there, no signs, nothing. Another Merritt island restaurant down.

783donnav

We were disappointed. Service was lackluster and uninformed. Special advertised on line not available. Given a menu from which we ordered then later waitress returned and said it was the wrong menu and we had to choose from another. No early bird dinner specials as advertised, and though the menu clearly states that seniors get a 15% discount all day, every day - no discount on our bill and when we asked for it, we were only given a 10% military discount off one item. I liked my poke bowl which is the only reason I give it two stars. My husband's mahi was barely average but priced as high as in better restaurants. There are lots of good places to eat in Cocoa Beach so just pass this one by.

Larry W

This place was absolutely horrible. From the moment we walked in. I knew we should’ve worked out. Service was terrible. The food was some of the worst seafood I’ve ever had in my life I am amazed. I am not sick. The place is a junkyard! Do not go!!!

Jamaal M.

Food - The chicken Alfredo was good. No complaints. However, my wife didn't care for the calamari appetizer that she received. It also didn't help that she requested the mango marmalade to try with it. Apparently, they didn't have it made. As they were discussing this issue from the food pickup area, the hostess blurted out "Okay, I will just tell her we don't have it." For this reason, not impressed at all. Ambiance - Great Service - Great Miscellaneous - This business is in need of updating. Great potential and a few tweaks would bring people to this establishment.

x2ReCreate

Wasn't too sure what to expect. The ambiance is dated. Reminds me of an older outback/Bahama breeze. Got there about 5ish and it was empty. We were greeted immediately and sat. The wait staff looked in and made sure we had what we needed. The food was ok. The steam boil was ordered but the crab was tuff. Took away from the experience. The drinks were tasty.

norcrossmom

We ate here twice - in March 2021, once while discussing with our real estate agent the house we ultimately bought in Merritt Island. Since then, Molly’s is always being closed by the health department for visible rodents, droppings, roaches - basically all the things you DON’T want to see in a restaurant!! Every time we drive down 520, I shudder to think we ate there. Luckily, we did not get sick. If the current owners can’t keep the place clean, I can’t imagine that anyone new could rid that large building of it’s vermin, roaches; and lets not even start about the water logged carpeting well outside of the bathrooms! How the health department has not permanently closed this place is beyond me. It’s not even like a new owner could get that place cleaned - it needs to be torn down.

Cathy C.

We have been going to Mollys for over 4 years, it has always been good.. Our last visit was horrible. They had many things on the menu they just did not have in stock to serve. The food we did have was mediocre at best, which was surprising. While we were there we were informed that the restaurant had been bought out by another chain of restaurants. My advice to the new owners either update the menu or make sure whatever is on the menu you have on hand to serve or At least let us know when we arrive that you are out of something it would have gave us a choice to go somewhere else. Our bill was over $100 without tip. I have to give big kudos to our waitress because she was great about the entire situation and tried to make us as happy as possible!

RJ Moore

This was a very enjoyable experience. The staff here is friendly and attentive. They make sure to check on you and make sure you are alright. The food here is beyond delicious. The atmosphere here is enjoyable.

Susan Woods

The food was ok, but not really worth the price you paid for it. I was not expecting my Ceasars salad to come put brown. We did get to try some sushi for free since the cook had some time to play around in the kitchen on a Friday night. My advice skip it and go to red Lobster. The best part of the meal was the rolls with the cinnamon honey butter.

Kelly C.

Grilled Sweet Whites New owners and new cook/chef! Awesome service and food! Come on locals and visitors, let's support or local businesses!

Billy Pau

Had their new weekend special sushi! Not too fancy just gets to the point and very delicious! 2 for 1 draft beer is an amazing deal too!

Dustin Burnham

My son loved the shrimp and scallops! The Po’boy is delicious, and the fish tanks kept my little man entertained!

Diana S.

So disappointed with our dinner tonight. Our friend ordered steak and shrimp, the steak was not cooked nor cooked to the temperature and the shrimp/bacon was very dry. Our Molly Steam Pot was good but the potatoes looked like they were days old and cold. Been here, tried it, not again.

Craig M.

4:30 PM on a Wednesday. Locked up tight. I guess this place is closed down. Was looking forward to a crab leg special. Oh well.

Babaraheeb

This is a place my husband and I occasionally go to because we like their sweet whites (shrimp - light and moist) and their spuds (potato skins). With BOGO beers any time of day, it makes a great stop for a snack, and it's pretty cheap. Today was an exception. We went at 3.00 PM. No other customers in the place. We ordered the usual. While we waited, I took a trip to the women's rest room - 3 toilets, none worked! I reported it, but no one seemed too concerned about it. We waited and waited for much longer than we should have, and the food finally came. Remember: there were no other customers! It was nothing like the food other times we were there. It was terrible: the potatoes were not cooked through, and the shrimp were dried out. We sent the spuds back and ate the shrimp. The bartender said she would see about the spuds. After about 10 minutes, she back to say they were the last order! Seriously? There was a whole evening of orders ahead! We ordered a side of fries. They came in a very small bowl. Pathetic. I had to go get the bartender to order a refill on our beers. Doubtful we will ever go back. Too bad.

Load More