Best NY PIZZA on sunset maybe even this whole area. A hidden gem. Greta sauce to cheese ratio. No cheap cheese. Thing crispy slices. Awesome price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Herrera
Good old fashioned pizza joint..
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Melyssa Mateo
I had a very disappointing experience at this pizza place today. I placed my order online through their website, which directed me to Seamless. The confirmation said my order would be ready at a certain time, so I went to pick it up.
When I arrived, the restaurant had about 3 people waiting, I waited around but no one acknowledged me for several minutes. Eventually, one employee told me someone else was “taking care of me,” even though she had been standing at the counter the entire time without acknowledging me. I told the gentleman no no one is taking care of me yet he said yeah yeah she is. After more waiting, same employee finally said my pizza would be ready in five minutes.
I continued to wait, but nothing happened. Then, suddenly, they told me they never received my order at all and insisted I should have placed it directly with them. This was very frustrating because their own website had redirected me to Seamless. To make matters worse, I overheard the staff saying it would take another 30 minutes if they started the order now, and one of them even said, “If she doesn’t like it, refund her.” Umm excuse me?? How unprofessional is that ? Mind you this place is alright not even the best out there but I had promise my toddlers pizza and it was already 8pm! I said go ahead and refund me and I left. I know exactly what happened no one checked the iPad and didn’t see the order not to mention the gentleman was convinced the order came in through grub hub after I showed him PROOF on my email and text message! I had a text message that my order was ready. Either they gave my pizza to the wrong person or clearly these employees have no idea what they are doing. Another note this could have been avoided if I would have been addressed and welcomed from when i walked in. Truly a horrible experience!!! Definitely the new management neeeds a training
Overall, the lack of communication within employees, poor customer service, and complete disregard for my time was extremely disappointing. They didn’t even offer free garlic rolls or a free pizza!! I won’t be returning
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Nestor Cedeno
Very attentive staff - they had asked me if I was content with the bake of my pie and returned it for more time after I asked for it to cook a little longer… something I have never been asked from a mom and pop pizzeria. Pies are excellent - sauce and ingredients are top notch. Will return without question!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
edward hoff
Might be the best pizza joint in South FL. Loved their thin crust pizza, meatballs (excellent and not too heavy) and garlic rolls (light and fluffy).
hanna kira kramer
these guys are the best. great service. great vibes & great slice 10/10 recommend. love this pizza shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Felix show 1
Pizza lovers, take note: Pizza Johny’s is the real deal. 🍕✨ From the first bite, you can tell this isn’t your average slice. The dough has that perfect handmade chew, blistered just right from the oven. The sauce tastes fresh and balanced—bright tomatoes with a hint of sweetness and a subtle herb finish. The cheese? Creamy, stretchy, and generously layered. I tried a classic Margherita and a pepperoni—both were phenomenal. Everything felt crafted with care, not thrown together. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why pizza became a worldwide obsession. Will absolutely be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
LETICIA MEJIA
Tasty Pizza!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Carlos R
Good pizza, not NY taste but not bad. The wait its a little long.
Good comfort food at an equally good price. Got two satisfying cheese slices for under $8.
For the food quality, the slices were deliciously greasy. The tomato sauce is not noticeable in flavor, and the mozzarella cheese is soft in flavor. The best part of the pizza is the crust: perfect toast on the bottom crust and a fresh dough mouthfeel.
Definitely would come back to try out their other menu items in the future.
Rene Tarafa
Very good pizza. The crust is one of the best we have had.
Julio Del Valle
Horrible telephone service. Sandwiches cost me $20. So called Italian sub had 3 thin slices of meat, no provolone, barely any lettuce or tomato, no sauce or mayo. Just poorly done! Driver was 15 minutes late. $26.49 total for a crappy sandwich. No chips. Nada. No wonder Publix and other sub places are kicking your butts!!!
Best NY PIZZA on sunset maybe even this whole area. A hidden gem. Greta sauce to cheese ratio. No cheap cheese. Thing crispy slices. Awesome price
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good old fashioned pizza joint..
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I had a very disappointing experience at this pizza place today. I placed my order online through their website, which directed me to Seamless. The confirmation said my order would be ready at a certain time, so I went to pick it up.
When I arrived, the restaurant had about 3 people waiting, I waited around but no one acknowledged me for several minutes. Eventually, one employee told me someone else was “taking care of me,” even though she had been standing at the counter the entire time without acknowledging me. I told the gentleman no no one is taking care of me yet he said yeah yeah she is. After more waiting, same employee finally said my pizza would be ready in five minutes.
I continued to wait, but nothing happened. Then, suddenly, they told me they never received my order at all and insisted I should have placed it directly with them. This was very frustrating because their own website had redirected me to Seamless. To make matters worse, I overheard the staff saying it would take another 30 minutes if they started the order now, and one of them even said, “If she doesn’t like it, refund her.” Umm excuse me?? How unprofessional is that ? Mind you this place is alright not even the best out there but I had promise my toddlers pizza and it was already 8pm! I said go ahead and refund me and I left. I know exactly what happened no one checked the iPad and didn’t see the order not to mention the gentleman was convinced the order came in through grub hub after I showed him PROOF on my email and text message! I had a text message that my order was ready. Either they gave my pizza to the wrong person or clearly these employees have no idea what they are doing. Another note this could have been avoided if I would have been addressed and welcomed from when i walked in. Truly a horrible experience!!! Definitely the new management neeeds a training
Overall, the lack of communication within employees, poor customer service, and complete disregard for my time was extremely disappointing. They didn’t even offer free garlic rolls or a free pizza!! I won’t be returning
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Very attentive staff - they had asked me if I was content with the bake of my pie and returned it for more time after I asked for it to cook a little longer… something I have never been asked from a mom and pop pizzeria.
Pies are excellent - sauce and ingredients are top notch.
Will return without question!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Might be the best pizza joint in South FL. Loved their thin crust pizza, meatballs (excellent and not too heavy) and garlic rolls (light and fluffy).
these guys are the best. great service. great vibes & great slice 10/10 recommend. love this pizza shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza lovers, take note: Pizza Johny’s is the real deal. 🍕✨
From the first bite, you can tell this isn’t your average slice. The dough has that perfect handmade chew, blistered just right from the oven. The sauce tastes fresh and balanced—bright tomatoes with a hint of sweetness and a subtle herb finish. The cheese? Creamy, stretchy, and generously layered. I tried a classic Margherita and a pepperoni—both were phenomenal. Everything felt crafted with care, not thrown together. It’s the kind of place that reminds you why pizza became a worldwide obsession. Will absolutely be back for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Tasty Pizza!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizzas
Good pizza, not NY taste but not bad. The wait its a little long.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Just love Pizza Johnnys. Best pizzas in town.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good comfort food at an equally good price. Got two satisfying cheese slices for under $8.
For the food quality, the slices were deliciously greasy. The tomato sauce is not noticeable in flavor, and the mozzarella cheese is soft in flavor. The best part of the pizza is the crust: perfect toast on the bottom crust and a fresh dough mouthfeel.
Definitely would come back to try out their other menu items in the future.
Very good pizza. The crust is one of the best we have had.
Horrible telephone service. Sandwiches cost me $20. So called Italian sub had 3 thin slices of meat, no provolone, barely any lettuce or tomato, no sauce or mayo. Just poorly done! Driver was 15 minutes late. $26.49 total for a crappy sandwich. No chips. Nada. No wonder Publix and other sub places are kicking your butts!!!
Really good pizza and would try again.
Best pizza in miami 🔥
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls, Favorite Pizza, Regular Slice of Cheese Pizza, Pizzas
Loading...