Morty's Pizza

Ordered from here a couple of times had an issue with the order this time and just called and asked to replace the wings that they messed up and the pizza that was doey. I tried asking him just to cook the pizza a little bit longer and to send the right wings and he pretty much told me to not order from there again because they make the pizza that way and I won’t like it anyways because it will be the same way I told him at that paint I would like a refund then my kids ate a little over half the cheese pie and a two slices out of the pepp and I ate one wing(which was the wrong sauce) and simply asked to replace what they messed up and whoever was in the phone was very rude and hard to understand because he was being loud and kept beating around the bush and they wanted to charge $10 for extra cheese on the pizza so I said no thanks clearly because $10 bucks for extra cheese is ridiculous eventually gave me a refund and pretty much told me don’t call there again. Customer service sucks 10/10

They are always reliable and i genuinely love their pizza. I love the wings but they are not typically pizza wings so might not be for everyone

Started to order here it's better than Papa John's and Domino's

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots with Marinara Sauce

This is my first time trying Morty’s and I can unfortunately say I wont be returning, the other reviews talking about how they don’t care much about your time is unfortunately true, I showed up 5 minutes before my order was supposed to be done and ended up waiting an extra 20 minutes (keep in mind I came in when they first opened) with that being said the food was okay, not good but not terrible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

This first time there new to area ordered 18 inch pie was raw not cooked Told guy prices on website were wrong asked for menu they didn't have any . Who doesn't have menus oh my gosh. There was nobody eating inside waited about twenty to twenty-five min for pizza and had no calls in that time for a meal.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Always worth it. We almost always get the 18 inch meat lovers well done with garlic knots. Just over 30 bucks and it is so much food and so delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Best pizza around for the money!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Definitely will order again fresh veggies and meat on the pizza definitely will order again

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

My family has been ordering Morty’s 15 years(live in the neighborhood behind Morty’s) this will be our last order unfortunately the food has changed& not for the better. This last purchase cost $78 with tip $80&a$3 cash tip.I ordered a large cheese,large pepperoni,24 hot wings crispy with ranch &greek salad order comes no salad 20 wings blue cheese no ranch not extra crispy I call they said I didn’t order a salad so how did the order come out to $78? I’m looking at the menu online and it doesn’t add up to $78&informed me I didn’t have a Greek salad on my order but offered to place a new order for one & what wait another hour after everyone’s already finished eating?!? no apology no explanation i understand the online menu may be old then update it or inform your customers when placing orders because usually my mother orders& I’m wondering what she’s paid what’s she’s been charged after all the years I no longer trust ordering from Morty’s looking for new pizza restaurants any suggestions welcome!!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Been going to Morty’s since I was a kid. Pizzas are huge and delicious. They’re not “New York style” but they are delicious. If you want your pizza more well done like I do they will do that for you, or even less sauce or more. Staff is friendly but if you’re a rude person they are rude back, love it! Awesome folks and good pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Rude on the phone pizza had an old greasy taste to it as of it came from a dirty oven, not good at all. The person who attended the phone was rude at pick up they were alright no polite. Never again they need to clean up where they storage their supplies also the oven. Wouldn’t recommend

One of the best in the area. Plain cheese Pizza, perhaps a bit more seasoning but good. Try it.

Food was great but 25$ for a large 2 topping is pretty pricey, when they charge 23 for a supreme, it just doesn't make sense to me. The food was great though, just the expense was unjustified.

Pizza is delicious! .....and pizza portions are HUGE! Very nice employees and customer service as well 🙂

Pizza was all cheese very little pepperoni and very little sauce. I get things cost more but at $19 I would expect more. Maybe the other food is better but wouldn’t recommend the pizza