Sam's New York Pizza

Ordered our favorite order. It arrived on time. 5 minutes after deliver and before I opened the packages the delivery person called and notified us they had mixed up a portion of our order. She said they would bring it right back. Came within about 15 minutes. And the extra meatball parmesan sub I got was DELICIOUS! Thanks guys. Great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It was a few years since going here. Had a pizza place open closer to us. Went back to Sam's for our last couple of our pizza orders and glad we did. The Mozz Knots are so good! Cheese and garlic is so satisfying. Pizza has the same great cheese with the not overly thick crust. Will drive longer for their pizza from now on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered the eggplant parm... tasted like laundered polos. Yikes! Can't save this. Clean up the kitchen
Garlic knots were raw. Good thing I have an air frier. Spoke to manager and they admit to frozen food being used. Someone needs to do a deep clean... it's affecting the flavor in a very negative way

Pizza delicious.. definitely an awesome place 😀 Greek salad and eggplant parm hero..so good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’m in town from Texas visiting family. Every time I come they always say “We have to order Sam’s” We ordered tonight and picked it up! Extremely impressed by the clean lobby and restaurant. The staff was very friendly and watched them double check our order before giving it to me! Got home and food and portions were amazing! Definitely will order again!! Great value for our money and more!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Best pizza near me😛

I order a large half-cheese half-pepperoni pizza. The pizza was ready in about 10-15 minutes. No wait. The parking lot was pretty clear. The pizza was hot and fresh. Pretty close to NY pizza. My only complaint is that it should have been a little thinner. I definitely will return. Great place with great pizza.

Ordered a pizza as a first time customer they even said you are first time customer I said yes..Ordered it for my office.The delivery showed up missing all the sides we asked for and the pizza dough is extremely chewy..When I asked the driver were are missing stuff was he was no help.Nor did he apologize and say he would go get it..When I called the restaurant back the guy said he would send it but by that time the pizza would be cold...and it was already chewy and tough I would give zero stars if I could...

Didn't have pizza but the meatball sub was great!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Great pizza and garlic knots! Don't get those other "chain pizza places". Obviously the pizza is better in NY because of the water and the atmosphere the pizza is made in. I lived in NY most my life but this is the closest around. Frozen pizza...comon! LOL. Mushrooms seemed to be canned though. Just stick with pepperoni, meatball or cheese. Just like the other review, consistenty is the key. UPDATE: Last order the pizza was undercooked and doughy. It was a busy night and took 2 hours to get delivered. Please don't rush the cooking.

The wait time is always horrible. They stand around and talk about how someone’s mother got jumped at McDonalds, real professional.

Love the pizza and the staff was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza was dry. Had the Hawaiian, like cardboard no flavor at all. Also had sausage and mushrooms, canned mushrooms and barely any sausage. Florida has the most disappointing pizza! Terrible pizza, never again.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

SUPPORT LOCAL RESTAURANTS!!!
I've been ordering from here for 18+ years when they first opened, and their food is absolutely AMAZING!
The best part of my delivery tonight was that the owner Eric personally handed me my food, and thanked me for my business.
The pleasure is all mine sir and thank you!

Recommended dishes: Wings, Chicken Parm

Great pizza. Always got delivery took a bit longer than I'd like but worth the wait. Keep it up people!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5