Grandma Penny's Pizza

$ • Pizza, Salad, Beer Bar

4353 Hancock Bridge Pkwy, North Fort Myers
(239) 217-0584


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Grandma Penny's Pizza

The pizzas here are great qualities. It is in the pricier side but good stuff usually isn't cheap to begin with. I get NY style pie and whenever I can I try to order feom here. They do have a holepunch card that after x amount of pizza you can one for free. The pies aren't greasy nor heavy. I actually don't feel terrible after eating from them which is good when you have a sensitive tummy.

We stopped in to try a different spot. Relatively a new business, opened in 2020. The thin crust pizza was perfectly cooked and tasted great. The steak and cheese supreme sub totally hit the spot. Fountain drinks as well. Our waitress Carole was on point and friendly. Nice place with relaxed feel. Nicely done ?Food: 5/5

I ordered pizza and got stuck working late. I showed up just as the restaurant was closing. They told me they gave my pizzas to line workers. I apologize over and they turned the oven back on and made me 2 more pizzas. They are the nicest, and friendliest pizza place I have ever been too. I have to say that the pizzas were amazing. Thank you so so much for doing that for me. You guys rock. I will definitely be coming back, hopefully next time I will be on time ?

More Reviews(152)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 3 - 8PM
Wednesday 3 - 8PM
Thursday 3 - 8PM
Friday 3 - 9PM
Saturday 3 - 8PM
Sunday 3 - 8PM