Jeremiah's Italian Ice

17297 Tamiami Trail, North Port
(941) 426-5333

Recent Reviews

Sort by
K Cazzo

Very good. A lot of flavors to choose from. Definitely a different ice cream experience but good none the less.

Jen Danforth

Perfect treat on a hot day, best Italian ice in town!

Bill Foley

Italian ice layered with gelato. What more could you ask for? Root beer Italian ice with vanilla gelato is a unique and special root beer float. All sorts of variations. If you see a Jeremiah's...stop. if you are an ice cream, gelato, Italian ice addict ya gotta go here.

Luis A

Pretty good ice cream my kids got a free ice cream coupon from school and decided to give it a try I was impressed on how good it was we will be coming back.

Tony Fischer

Tried multiple times for a door dash order. I don't think the staff knew what they were doing. Never processed the order after an hour each time. Owners should train their staff better

Shayla Nguyen

Just visit first time and only one customer they’re serving but we have to waited 20 minutes. Went to restroom and unacceptable for ice cream shop. My kids begged for leave

regina reichert

Just got to Jeremiah’s at 9pm, was told they only have the Italian ice available as they close soon… at 10pm. So why even be open if you can’t get literally what the store sells. Chairs were already put away inside and outside. No where to sit. Off to scoops we go. Zero stars if I could.

Paul Prelle

My family loves this place. Such delicious Italian ice and soft serve! The service at this location is hit or miss but it’s definitely still worth the trip! We recommend the cotton candy or one of the mint chocolate combinations.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Ray Delfa

Great value for your money, super clean and delicious!!! Plenty of clean space to sit and enjoy it! Highly recommend... finally an ice cream shop that smokes sweet scoops with only 1 boot seating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Garry Williams

I always enjoy everything I order here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amelia P.

Love this place!! Definitely a core memory of having ice cream at this place with my friend. The Italian ice isn’t too bad, but the flavor combos are AWESOME!!

Parking: Plenty of parking, no need to worry about not being able to get a spot

Kid-friendliness: Kids love this place, it’s an ice cream store, after all haha!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream

Adrianna Wojcik

Great catering experience. inexpensive and so worth the cost!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mary Ulmer

Overall clean place. Located in a busy shopping center. I only gave 3 stars for service because after I ordered a small and medium they made the small and we're handling another person's order. I was still standing there after they finished with the other few people then they asked me if I was still waiting for something then asked what it was. The ice-cream water ice mix was pretty good if u like those combinations.

Parking: Located in a shopping center. Plenty of parking.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Ann Marie Gubbiotti

Went there today 7/14 For just a simple chocolate come with chocolate sprinklesv in the past they always layered the sprinkles by putting some in the bottom and all around outside of cone
Was told by the girl working there they cannot do that?? They aren’t allowed?? But every time I get the cone I’ve never had to ask for it always came that way
Needless to say we ended up leaving won’t be back
the girl was rude

Service: 1

Hannah

I know it's basic, but I got the vanilla soft serve icecream (M) with sprinkles. And wow! The icecream was very creamy and delicious, a place I'd definitely check out again. They had a variety of other options like Italian ice with multiple combos. The portions size are reasonable for the price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...