Ice Cream Theory

4058 Tampa Rd, Oldsmar
(813) 749-6463

Recent Reviews

Delaware Chimney Services

Super delicious milkshake and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Connie Petrantoni

Kids cup was $7seems to be a lot just for one small

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy

Never open. Drive by there every week and at different times and doors are locked, lights off. 12pm, 2pm, 4pm….

Nisy N.

This is our families favorite it's one of the best ice cream places we've ever been to. It has a variety of flavors and different types of cones such as Cookie Monster and mermaid. Whoever we take a trip to Clearwater we make sure to stop by.

Patrick Stacy

Awesome variety of ice cream & gelato…Kayla’s the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paula Mevorah

Heard good things abt this place . Had family with kids drive 25 minutes to join me for ice cream only to find out they closed. Website said they were opened and not even a note on the door.

Ann D.

The prices were not posted anywhere. Our server said we could only get one flavor of ice cream in the $7 small size bowls. Even the spoons weee too flimsy to scoop up the ice cream. I would suggest a self service water dispenser and cups at an ice cream place. Even if under construction please post menu and prices.

RV Traveler

Excellent ice cream. Reasonably priced. I had Blueberry Cheesecake & Wife had Strawberry Cheesecake. Ruby loved it.Lots of choices. We recommend it. It’s a stop while in Tampa.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephanie Perry

Had some chocolatey gelato concoction that I'm thinking about weeks later. It was so good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mister T.

Mediocre Ice Cream shop. The ice cream and Italian Ice are high quality. The cones are also pretty great. The problem is a lack of flavors, they had no chocolate the night we went which is insane for any Ice Cream shop. The prices are a bit high and the lack of options and toppings are a bit light.

Lina Dawod

Their business hours are a theory.We arrived here at 1:30 on Saturday and it was closed. Supposedly they’re open at 12.

Service: 1

Caitlin Goede

The employee seemed annoyed when we walked in and the prices were ridiculous. I was with my three children and after we received our food she went to sit in the back area and was on her phone the whole time we were in there. The ice cream itself was good but definitely would not return.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Kæla Rāe Hovland

Ice cream is just amazing .. and they have Yerba Mate SODA in a can❣️ as well as two different root beer brands? the cookie dough and coconut are my favorites as well as the French vanilla, absolutely exceptional? she described it as “icy” which is what really got me, and it did not fail me ❄️ ? my new regular spot??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pagan Squad

We came at 8:38pm on Sunday Oct 15 and they where sitting down and was laughing and told us that there closing in 5 mins when online it say at 9:00pm. Very bad customer service

Carolyn S.

Very cute shop that offers a wide array of gelato, ice cream, and sorbet in a rather vast selection of flavors. They also offer specialty desserts, cake cones, bubbles waffles, etc. (including something that's wrapped in a cloud of cotton candy!!??), but I notice that as I get older, I need more simplicity in my life, so I forgo the elaborate get up and stick to basics. After all, it's an ice cream shop, so their ice cream needs to be good anyway regardless of creative ways to present it. The shop was clean, cute, and very welcoming. I was greeted immediately by a very nice worker who offered to let me sample some of the flavors that are offered. I was feeling like some coffee inspired sweets (though HONESTLY when am I not???) and chose the Caramel Macchiato flavored gelato and paired that with Tiramisu. Now...to get the two flavors, you HAVE to get no smaller than a medium cup, which is rather large, but I was game, so medium it is!!! I thought my flavors went great together in harmony along with the coffee theme. Caramel Macchiato is a flavor I've never seen ANYBODY else do before, so I knew I had to get that. It even had chunks of caramel chips in it, so I knew I had a winner. The flavor did overpower the tiramisu a little, but once I got to the bottom, I was able to really appreciate the mascarpone flavor of the gelato and indulge in the actual chunks of lady fingers that were mixed in. I love that I finally gave this place a chance after passing it by so many times. I'll be sure to check out their actual ice cream or MAYBE go with another gelato flavor. Would I go with the crazy concoctions they offer??? If I'm in the mood.

Load More