Just had our first pizza and wings from here , Finally Someone who knows how to make a NY stile pizza ! Ordered wings , Cooked just the way i asked . Will go back .
Eli B.
I've eaten twice at Zerillos. The first time we ate in the restaurant, we ordered Pizza and wings both were excellent. On March 24th we called in an order. We ordered a calzone with sauce on the inside and lasagna. We were told 30 min to pick up the order. We showed up in 30 minutes to pick up the order but it wasn't ready so had to wait an additional 15 minutes. Brought the food home and the lasagna was cold, the noodles were hard and there was so much cheese it made you gag. It was just awful. The calzone was not made with sauce in the inside and it also had way too much cheese and I love cheese. To top it off I noticed that I was charged 63.88 for both items. My husband went back and was told he had left a 32.00 tip for a pick up order. WHAT??? He was promised an adjustment and today we were charged the entire amount. Needless to say this was a horrible experience.
J Shanks
Great local restaurant. Pizza was huge. Awesome staff and food was quick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kristen scussel
I’ve eaten here more than a handful of times and the food is consistently great. Not the best pizza I’ve ever eaten but really freaking good and it stays consistent. Wings and mozz sticks are also awesome! Today recommend going here for pizza Friday!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
D Z
I had been hoping for a good pizzeria in the area. Seems like I am still hoping. The pizza went down the hatch and came out the other end.I was skeptical to order seeing that the slices for the lunch special comes from pizza that's been sitting out for lord knows how many hours.They have cooked dairy sitting out on a counter with no heat lamp to keep it warm. Just there. Out in the open where bugs can land on it and no heat to keep it food safe temperature.Within 30 minutes of eating I ran to the bathroom.I don't know if I should dare give it another try. Maybe if I order a fresh homemade pie instead of what's there for the pickings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Ed D
One of the best pizza joints in Tampa.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pietro M.
The food is great, so glad that the owner decided to come back to Tampa and open a restaurant. The pizza and calzones are very well made and full of cheese and your choice of toppings. Cannot wait until they open the other side so that there are more tables for you to eat there. Until then there are only a few tables so you may not be able to eat in.
Jake B.
Finally! A good NY style pizza place! We order here regularly and had been waiting months for them to finally open. Quaint little spot and gorgeous on the inside. Kitchen is open and you can watch them make your pie if you want. Pizza is top notch and true NY style pizza, only thing they're missing is the water! We've had most of their other things and haven't had any issues whatsoever. Stromboli and Calzones are both huge and nicely priced.
Amanda Alviani
I absolutely love this place. This was my 3rd visit. I've now had the Hawaiian and added jalapeños, the meat lovers with bacon instead of ham, a half cheese half pepperoni pizza, the garlic knots, and the mozzarella stick. All delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cristian Santos
Just stopped in for lunch with the work crew, from the outside it didn't look like much but wow was there a lot to offer. I got the Philly cheese steak with fries and the bread of the sandwich was fantastic! The meat and veggies and cheese were also very good and cooked well. The atmosphere was playful and fun, and the staff was very friendly. I noticed they are expanding to next door and I can't wait to see what else they have to offer in the future. Full Five Stars
Excellent food. Delicious!!! Tried the chicken parm sandwich one day and pizza the next. Both were amazing.
Bill Downey
It's great to have a superb NY style pizza in Oldsmar. My new go to. Welcome back Zerillo's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt S
It was OK. Little soggy overall. Garlic knots felt/tasted stale. Asked to pay a tip via machine so that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Robin M.
Maybe I'm being tooooo harsh and critical but I've been to a lot of pizzerias and this one needs a little work. I don't get why all these specialties pizza, like chicken bacon ranch where the base of the pizza is not sauce but ranch dressing. WTF. There every day slice special hardly has any sauce on it so they're making cheesy well maybe they'll get better.
Tyson Munson
What a great NY style pizza with a sauce that makes your mouth water! The Garlic knots fresh baked dough and the sauce ????
Just had our first pizza and wings from here , Finally Someone who knows how to make a NY stile pizza ! Ordered wings , Cooked just the way i asked . Will go back .
I've eaten twice at Zerillos. The first time we ate in the restaurant, we ordered Pizza and wings both were excellent. On March 24th we called in an order. We ordered a calzone with sauce on the inside and lasagna. We were told 30 min to pick up the order. We showed up in 30 minutes to pick up the order but it wasn't ready so had to wait an additional 15 minutes. Brought the food home and the lasagna was cold, the noodles were hard and there was so much cheese it made you gag. It was just awful. The calzone was not made with sauce in the inside and it also had way too much cheese and I love cheese. To top it off I noticed that I was charged 63.88 for both items. My husband went back and was told he had left a 32.00 tip for a pick up order. WHAT??? He was promised an adjustment and today we were charged the entire amount. Needless to say this was a horrible experience.
Great local restaurant. Pizza was huge. Awesome staff and food was quick.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve eaten here more than a handful of times and the food is consistently great. Not the best pizza I’ve ever eaten but really freaking good and it stays consistent. Wings and mozz sticks are also awesome! Today recommend going here for pizza Friday!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had been hoping for a good pizzeria in the area. Seems like I am still hoping. The pizza went down the hatch and came out the other end.I was skeptical to order seeing that the slices for the lunch special comes from pizza that's been sitting out for lord knows how many hours.They have cooked dairy sitting out on a counter with no heat lamp to keep it warm. Just there. Out in the open where bugs can land on it and no heat to keep it food safe temperature.Within 30 minutes of eating I ran to the bathroom.I don't know if I should dare give it another try. Maybe if I order a fresh homemade pie instead of what's there for the pickings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
One of the best pizza joints in Tampa.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The food is great, so glad that the owner decided to come back to Tampa and open a restaurant. The pizza and calzones are very well made and full of cheese and your choice of toppings. Cannot wait until they open the other side so that there are more tables for you to eat there. Until then there are only a few tables so you may not be able to eat in.
Finally! A good NY style pizza place! We order here regularly and had been waiting months for them to finally open. Quaint little spot and gorgeous on the inside. Kitchen is open and you can watch them make your pie if you want. Pizza is top notch and true NY style pizza, only thing they're missing is the water! We've had most of their other things and haven't had any issues whatsoever. Stromboli and Calzones are both huge and nicely priced.
I absolutely love this place. This was my 3rd visit. I've now had the Hawaiian and added jalapeños, the meat lovers with bacon instead of ham, a half cheese half pepperoni pizza, the garlic knots, and the mozzarella stick. All delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just stopped in for lunch with the work crew, from the outside it didn't look like much but wow was there a lot to offer. I got the Philly cheese steak with fries and the bread of the sandwich was fantastic! The meat and veggies and cheese were also very good and cooked well. The atmosphere was playful and fun, and the staff was very friendly. I noticed they are expanding to next door and I can't wait to see what else they have to offer in the future. Full Five Stars
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food. Delicious!!! Tried the chicken parm sandwich one day and pizza the next. Both were amazing.
It's great to have a superb NY style pizza in Oldsmar. My new go to. Welcome back Zerillo's!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It was OK. Little soggy overall. Garlic knots felt/tasted stale. Asked to pay a tip via machine so that
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Maybe I'm being tooooo harsh and critical but I've been to a lot of pizzerias and this one needs a little work. I don't get why all these specialties pizza, like chicken bacon ranch where the base of the pizza is not sauce but ranch dressing. WTF. There every day slice special hardly has any sauce on it so they're making cheesy well maybe they'll get better.
What a great NY style pizza with a sauce that makes your mouth water! The Garlic knots fresh baked dough and the sauce ????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Regular Cheese Pizza