Holey Moley Bagel Shop
$ • Bagels, American
Hours:
1177 Park Ave #14, Orange Park
(904) 375-0113
About Holey Moley Bagel Shop
Customers' Favorites
Holey Moley Bagel Shop Reviews
Share your opinion about Holey Moley Bagel Shop
I got the everything bagel with cream cheese and the Asiago bagel with cream cheese! They were delicious! Fresh bagels and great owners! Very friendly. I highly recommend coming here
The BEST bagels I’ve had in Florida yet! Store bagels are so hard to chew, but these ones are so soft, and the cream cheese is incredible! They have such good choices! We got several different kinds. Pizza Tuscan bagel with pesto cream cheese, jalapeño Asiago bagel with chives cream cheese, the rainbow with funfetti cream cheese, and the everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese, and EVERYTHING was absolutely delicious!! We will definitely be back!! 🫶🏻
The bagels are not displayed anywhere so you can’t see what you’re getting. I took my wife there for breakfast one day. She had a plain bagel with cream cheese and I had a bacon egg and cheese on a garlic bagel. The bagels were so small they look more like bialy’s. They were also very pricey. To say it was underwhelming is an understatement. I will never go back there. I would caution anybody that’s ever had a real New York bagel to not go to this place or I promise you...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 1PM |
People in Orange Park Also Viewed
.jpg)
Holey Moley Bagel Shop is a hidden gem with a constant stream of customers, even on weekday mornings. The bagels are amazing, fresh, big, and delicious, described as the best in Florida and the best in a long time. They are notably soft, not hard to chew, though one reviewer noted the entire bagel was soft with no crust, differing from a New York-style bagel.
The shop offers a great variety of specials and good choices. Specific bagels mentioned include the poppy seed, plain Asiago, jalapeño Asiago, everything, rainbow, Pizza Tuscan, Lox, and Giulia. Excellent bagel sandwiches include the steak egg and cheddar, praised as the best ever, and the poppy seed with sausage, egg & cheese. The cream cheese selections are incredible, with flavors like pesto, chives, funfetti, and jalapeño.
The customer service is lovely, friendly, and unbelievably kind. The owners take great pride in their food and ensuring an enjoyable experience. The staff is super friendly, smiling, and the inside is super clean. The Caramel Macchiato is also awesome. It is a good place with a nice display case and a highly recommended spot for breakfast bagel sandwiches or just bagels in general.