NYC Meatballs and Pizzeria

Can't say enough about this fantastic find. Great pizza and excellent dinners. Full bar on one side of the restaurant. The pizzas are exceptional and the NYC lasagna, which is incredible and my personal favorite, is like 2 meals in one order! Don't miss this one!

The food isn’t good and service is poor!
I am not coming back!

Unsanitary and bland food

NYC Meatball and Pizzaria is amazing. The food is to die for and the staff is sssssoooooo friendly and helpful. You need to try everything.

It was very good, but it was a little pricier than I expected. Definitely will be back,

Great food, friendly staff, good env. We go almost every week!

Ordered pizza and wings togo; quick and friendly service and great pizza and wings. Thnx! -michael

1st time here..ordered cheesesteak pizza and wings. first pizza was brought out burnt and they offered to make another one which they did. If you like bland food, this is the place for you. Absolutely zero flavor in the dough and not even salt of pepper seasoning on the wings. It looked really good but this was a big disappointment considering I had to wait even longer for a remake. Unfortunately I will not be back.

Visited: 24May25... super late on this review. I've been here a handful of times but I've never done a review. I think it switched ownership recently, so I've been when it's been under both. Good family atmosphere. Young staff. Service is always great! I recommend getting the garlic knots, fried. Which I didn't know there was another option which is baked, never had those before. Always come out hot with buttery and garlic goodness! Totally recommend!

We usually go the takeout route, and the service is always on point. Our food is hot, ready, and waiting the second we walk in—zero hassle, just grab and go. The staff is always super kind, which makes the whole experience even better.

Now let’s talk about that meatball pizza… dangerously delicious. I’m this close to making this a daily routine-- just for the meatballs. And whatever you do, do not skip the garlic knots... carb heaven. 🍕🔥

Not good service or food. Poor ownership

The best garlic knots ever!!

The bartenders and servers are very personable and awesome. The food is always fresh and delicious. Good prices and great drinks.

NYC is the best NY style pizza in all of Jax. It is thin, crispy and never floppy. I love dining in and my favorite is their white pizza. The staff is very friendly and attentive. I’m grateful for a nice sit down restaurant that is a small business in our area! #supportlocal

We have been here twice this year. Once we ate in and yesterday we ordered take out. When we ordered in, service was horrible, we kept having to get up and ask for refills. Food was mediocre. Yesterday we ordered bbq chicken pizza and chicken parm to go. The pizza had maybe 1/8 of a chicken breast on it, at most! It also tasted horrible, no flavor and the crust was burnt and chewy. We ordered a large pizza for $25+ and it barely had anything on it. Quite a rip off. The chicken parm was mostly noodles and barely any chicken. For $46 we still ended up cooking our own meal at home because the food was not good at all. 2 stars in hopes that the restaurant improves after seeing my feedback. I also noticed some other lower ratings in the past month on here so it seems to be a trend for the restaurant.