Teddy's After Dark

125 N Tamiami Trail, Osprey
(941) 468-2231

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Tony Baratta

Yep, the owner is rude but it's a riot to go there. Enjoyed the experience.

The Sandman

This place is "interesting" and I'll stop there. We won't be going back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Graham

A great experience in a truly one-or-a-kind bar. Teddy was holding fort and telling great tales - some may have been partly

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Marquis Tate

Simply amazing and a unique experience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Eric Moore

Do not come here unless you are a regular of this bar. We came to Teddys after hearing from a local that this would be a relaxing place on our anniversary. My wife and I are easy going but had an absolutely trash experience. A previous reviewer references the Big Lebowski. The owner is a Jeffrey..not a good Dude at all. We really wanted to enjoy this place, as it is unique, but it is not at all worth the time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Patrick Lyons

First things first, wear a collared shirt and be respectful. I understand it’s a bizarre place and system but that’s what makes it a gem. You really just make yourself at home. I could only imagine the people “kicked out” are not the type of crowd that you would want around. Coming from someone in their mid 20s, if you are a respectable person you will have a great time. Also Jolene, the German Shepard is an absolute sweetheart <3

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dawn DeMarco

He use to be nice !!! It use to be a great place !!! Now he is mentally rearranged and no one should ever be treated like he treats customers !!! He is a sick man !!!!

Adam Santella

Ozzy Osbourne owns a bar in florida and his singing has only improved with age.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matthew Mattson

I hated every second.

joe pop

TYPICAL Poser to the MAX! VENICE deserves better

M Williams

I post reputable reviews and have the stats to prove it! We love quirky and we heard this guy was train wreck by reading other reviews. We went there with our party of 5 ages 46 to 78. We actually made bets with each other on when we would be thrown out. We just had a great dinner down the street and we were all dressed nicely. We walked in said hello to what seemed like a nice bunch of seniors and then it happened. Yep, thrown out! I’m almost 70, split a gut I laughed so hard. Proudly left. I’ve never been thrown out of an establishment so I got to cross that off my bucket list. We went to the Zebra Lounge around the corner and had a truly fun evening!

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 1

Linda Krone

We stopped in briefly, and I mean BRIEFY! Teddy was black out drunk and yelling at a lovely elderly woman. It was shocking.

Al K.

Heard about this place and thought we'd stop by. Went in about three steps and knew right away we didn't want to take a seat. People were so crowded together it was like being in an elevator. Maybe they all knew each other? A couple invited us to sit with them. Where, on their laps? Five stars for friendliness.

Mary Bolts

Great fun. Teddy is a super host . We left with smiles and will be back

Kierstin W

We LOVED stopping by Teddys and always had a great time. We’ve been there 4 times and always had a great experience until we went to stop in there tonight. Teddy said we weren’t appropriate to the dress code, however, we were wearing clothing like we have on every other visit. Also everyone in the establishment at the time was wearing t-shirts so not sure how we weren’t meeting the “requirements”. We will no longer recommend our friends or family to stop by and we will not be back.

Loading...