Palermo Pizza And Italian Restaurant

24929 Co Rd 42, Paisley
(352) 771-0012

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Gary Moran

Only restaurant in paisley.was decent

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 4

JG

I truly hate leaving a bad review but holy cow this is the first and last time I’ll ever come here. The service was the absolute worst. The lady must have forgotten like 25 things at a minimum. Drinks, lids, to go boxes etc etc. anything you asked for she said she’d get and then never get it. The server wasn’t rude by any means but wasn’t friendly either. She just couldn’t remember anything. It was like having Dory as a server. Multiple times I had to get up and walk to the counter for things I asked for because she forgot to bring them. My friend and I ordered slices, I ordered mine crispy. They came out the same and neither were hot. Literally slightly warmer than room temp. The pepperoni was uncooked on them as if they just placed it on the slices then stuck it in the oven for 10 seconds. The fries were nice and crispy which was nice but the oil they were cooked in tasted very old. We ordered garlic knots with extra garlic. They cane out with no garlic them. I couldn’t believe how dry they were. I told her I asked for extra garlic and she said “I thought I put it on there.” Literally where??? She takes it back to add garlic to it and it still comes out with almost nothing on it. I had to walk to the main counter and ask for garlic powder to try and salvage them. We all had to bring our slips up there to return them as she never came back for them. My buddy kept commenting how she kept hanging out with her boyfriend who was there instead of working. I hear this place was amazing before the owners husband Tony passed away. Sadly I never got to try it before it went down hill. Not a chance in the world I’d ever come back. Prices seemed high here as well for what you got. Update to my review 1 day after eating there. I got a phone call that one of the people in my group got food poisoning after eating there last night. Everyone got pizza except that person who got something with shrimp in it and got food poisoning. Be warned everyone!

BYRON WERNER

Very Good Food

Kris P

Staff is nice have not ate there yet but have gotten take out pizza was good but not crazy about the cheese bread may try the rolls next time

Mona Corbett

The food is so good. Nice drive out to this establishment.

Robert Pepin

A very nice restaurant, Nice little place to take a date. Food is okay but portions are small.

robert skeel

Food ain't what it used to be, the old guy that owned it passed away and the food or substitutions ain't the same, the wife don't compromise

Casey Snyder

It's okay. Just don't order the garlic rolls or the Margherita pizza. The garlic rolls were dry as could be and had a scant amount of garlic. The Margherita pizza had canned tomatoes on top which was weird because I know they had fresh tomatoes as they were in the garden salad I got. It also had regular pizza cheese, not the mozzarella you usually get on a Margherita pizza. Stick to the regular cheese pizza if you go here.

sheri helterbrand

As a well known food critic I rated this restaurant.(friendly restaurant!) I ordered a steak stromboli and it was excellent! The garden salad was fresh that I ordered and the lemonade was good. The price was affordable and got nice size portions. I rated it a 10 out of 10 to the owner. The only difference that would draw more people is that I would put a brush off garlic butter on top of the stromboli which gives it a true Italian taste..... Excent place to eat!

Courtney Doss

This was our first time here we just moved right down the road. We will definitely be regulars! Cameron is amazing and personable. Our food was amazing pizza taste like up north so good!!! Thank you.

Richard Kozol

Ordered xtra sauce and got their usual transparent thin coat of sauce . Save a penny lose a dollar

Brad Evans

My son gets the pepperoni and bacon every week.... I get 1 slice if I'm lucky! Love it

Luis Mendez

Food was fabulous, service was great and atmosphere was good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristin Figueroa

A hidden gem, this place has excellent pizza, and even better calzones. The staff is friendly, the service superior.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Rolls, Meat Lovers, F Family Meat Lovers Calzone

Mary Semento

My husband had eaten here in the past but it had been quite some time so I wanted to check it out. Although I felt like the food was a little pricey I didn't feel that way after we got home and had eaten it. It was absolutely amazing!! It was pretty dead when we picked our food up, but the dining area was super cute and clean. Even has a little bar you can eat at and I'm pretty sure they serve beer and wine. 10/10 Recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

Palermo Pizza And Italian Restaurant

24929 Co Rd 42, Paisley, FL 32767
(352) 771-0012