Best New York Pizza outside Brooklyn.Keep up the Exceptional job team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erik Pancake
Hands down the best local place. The pies are A+. Hogies are A+ wings A + Salads and everything else on the menu are A+. Service and friendliness are at a level that is not seen around here you have to try this place. It will be a go to. If I’m lying put it on my account I’ll refund you.Kind RegardsErik Pancake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
O.A Stamp
(Only took me 2 months to get to this review and others, but I gotchu Brent!)Pizza head South Florida Native living in the PSL area and working in Stuart at the time (I literally just moved to the middle of nowhere in New Mexico, but shoutout to FLAWDA)...I randomly try the pie wherever I go, but I only ever bother reviewing it if it's exceptional or terrible enough to be memorable (check my other reviews kid, oh there's some pizza in there ?)Stopped into Big Slice randomly one night during my wait time as a limo driver for a local company (gona leave them a 5 star also in a minute)...I saw their big bright and beautiful sign on the way to my clients drop off, and thought: "yea Ill hit that up" (even though I probably had Pizza like 5 dayz before...what can I say, at this point in my life a whole pie keeps for dayz...and in this economy ?)ANYWAYs, I remember that it was either the divisional or conference round of the NFL playoffs, that the modest but well setup sitting / order area was very well lit, with fresh looking decour including a couple tables as well as a bar for a few high stools...and that it was busy, with lots of people picking up. I was immediately pleased by the attentiveness and focus of one of the young staff members (can't remember his name just now, but it was 3 people total including the owner), and was even more impressed and re-assured about 15 mins later, striking up conversation with the fast moving and visblibly focused chef-owner, Brent...I barely had my head from out from under the steaming hood of my fresh out the oven XL pie, throwing on a little cheese and pepper, when I heard him say "so how's that thing lookin' man?" (it was at that moment that in addition to looking amazing, that this pizza was guaranteed to be tasty)Brent was friendly and knowledgeable in giving me the low-down on how he came to be the new owner of the one and only Big Slice pizza in Palm City, and his mission to not only maintain but streamline and expand the reputation and original New York recipe, and while I didn’t get a chance to ask him where he was from…I’m pretty sure the accent is a dead giveaway.Thanks, and good luck to you and your team Brent! I’ll be sure to grab another pie or two when I pass through again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
colby gillich
New owner who is taking on the task of rebuilding what the last owners destroyed. Brent is doing an awesome job at getting the big slice name back to what it used to stand for, great food at a great price from a great place. Keep it up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kara
Not as good as they use to be. That's an understatement. One year later pizza was luke warm and garlic knots were not cooked throughly
Christie Standt
My Subs were VERY DISAPPOINTED!NO CHEESE WAS ON IT!!!! VERY LITTLE MEAT..ON A "CHEESE STEAK SUB!! NOT HAPPY!! IM DONE !!!!??
Michael B
Great pizza. The service is friendly, welcoming and the food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Side Salad, Toppings
Matthew Spears
Food and service are excellent. I typically go for the 2 slice special at lunch and I haven't been disappointed yet. The staff are very attentive and dedicated to bringing you the best service possible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Garlic Knots, Wings
Rob Metcalf
813pm, will not deliver, unacceptable
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
AnnDee Bennett
Great place to stop for a couple slices of pizza and a drink. They'd just have some stools and some tables. Staff is always friendly. Food is always good. We also love them because they're the only ones who will deliver to us and Palm City farms.
VEry TASTYYUMMY AND DELICIOUSTHEK MAKE MY FAMILY HAPPY AFTER EAT THIER FOOD SUCH A AMAZING SUPPER TOPPING CHEESY AND JUICEY BURGAR FILLING TO MUCH GOOD ? THANK
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toppings
Kaneesha Allen
Originally we were going to order the lunch special which included two big slices of cheese pizza and a drink. Instead we ordered a whole pie. Our pizza had just the right amount of dough, sauce and cheese. Big slice never disappoints. Thanks for a great pie?P.S We almost ate our pizza without taking a pic , hence the slices with seasoning hahah.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Jennifer Hotaling
Never delivered my pizza. The employee who answered the phone was rude and hung up the phone when i asked for confirmation of a refund. Will not go here again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Donald Wickham
Not like it used to be.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Peter M
This review is just my opinion, I find this place to be the worst pizza I’ve ever tasted, it had absolutely no flavor to it, I ordered two slices with sausage on it when they brought out the slices. It look like the sausage was not even. Cooked . I ended up, throwing it in the garbage, it tasted like there was no oregano or anything inside the sauce, the cheese was absolutely awful, my opinion my worst, frozen pizza was better than this, on top of everything else. The tables in the place were filthy, not even wiped down.i Don’t understand how Give this establishment, good reviews unless they don’t know pizza or I just had a really bad pizza maker this day
Best New York Pizza outside Brooklyn.Keep up the Exceptional job team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best local place. The pies are A+. Hogies are A+ wings A + Salads and everything else on the menu are A+. Service and friendliness are at a level that is not seen around here you have to try this place. It will be a go to. If I’m lying put it on my account I’ll refund you.Kind RegardsErik Pancake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
(Only took me 2 months to get to this review and others, but I gotchu Brent!)Pizza head South Florida Native living in the PSL area and working in Stuart at the time (I literally just moved to the middle of nowhere in New Mexico, but shoutout to FLAWDA)...I randomly try the pie wherever I go, but I only ever bother reviewing it if it's exceptional or terrible enough to be memorable (check my other reviews kid, oh there's some pizza in there ?)Stopped into Big Slice randomly one night during my wait time as a limo driver for a local company (gona leave them a 5 star also in a minute)...I saw their big bright and beautiful sign on the way to my clients drop off, and thought: "yea Ill hit that up" (even though I probably had Pizza like 5 dayz before...what can I say, at this point in my life a whole pie keeps for dayz...and in this economy ?)ANYWAYs, I remember that it was either the divisional or conference round of the NFL playoffs, that the modest but well setup sitting / order area was very well lit, with fresh looking decour including a couple tables as well as a bar for a few high stools...and that it was busy, with lots of people picking up. I was immediately pleased by the attentiveness and focus of one of the young staff members (can't remember his name just now, but it was 3 people total including the owner), and was even more impressed and re-assured about 15 mins later, striking up conversation with the fast moving and visblibly focused chef-owner, Brent...I barely had my head from out from under the steaming hood of my fresh out the oven XL pie, throwing on a little cheese and pepper, when I heard him say "so how's that thing lookin' man?" (it was at that moment that in addition to looking amazing, that this pizza was guaranteed to be tasty)Brent was friendly and knowledgeable in giving me the low-down on how he came to be the new owner of the one and only Big Slice pizza in Palm City, and his mission to not only maintain but streamline and expand the reputation and original New York recipe, and while I didn’t get a chance to ask him where he was from…I’m pretty sure the accent is a dead giveaway.Thanks, and good luck to you and your team Brent! I’ll be sure to grab another pie or two when I pass through again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New owner who is taking on the task of rebuilding what the last owners destroyed. Brent is doing an awesome job at getting the big slice name back to what it used to stand for, great food at a great price from a great place. Keep it up!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not as good as they use to be. That's an understatement. One year later pizza was luke warm and garlic knots were not cooked throughly
My Subs were VERY DISAPPOINTED!NO CHEESE WAS ON IT!!!! VERY LITTLE MEAT..ON A "CHEESE STEAK SUB!! NOT HAPPY!! IM DONE !!!!??
Great pizza. The service is friendly, welcoming and the food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Side Salad, Toppings
Food and service are excellent. I typically go for the 2 slice special at lunch and I haven't been disappointed yet. The staff are very attentive and dedicated to bringing you the best service possible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Garlic Knots, Wings
813pm, will not deliver, unacceptable
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Great place to stop for a couple slices of pizza and a drink. They'd just have some stools and some tables. Staff is always friendly. Food is always good. We also love them because they're the only ones who will deliver to us and Palm City farms.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
VEry TASTYYUMMY AND DELICIOUSTHEK MAKE MY FAMILY HAPPY AFTER EAT THIER FOOD SUCH A AMAZING SUPPER TOPPING CHEESY AND JUICEY BURGAR FILLING TO MUCH GOOD ? THANK
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Toppings
Originally we were going to order the lunch special which included two big slices of cheese pizza and a drink. Instead we ordered a whole pie. Our pizza had just the right amount of dough, sauce and cheese. Big slice never disappoints. Thanks for a great pie?P.S We almost ate our pizza without taking a pic , hence the slices with seasoning hahah.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Never delivered my pizza. The employee who answered the phone was rude and hung up the phone when i asked for confirmation of a refund. Will not go here again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Not like it used to be.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
This review is just my opinion, I find this place to be the worst pizza I’ve ever tasted, it had absolutely no flavor to it, I ordered two slices with sausage on it when they brought out the slices. It look like the sausage was not even. Cooked . I ended up, throwing it in the garbage, it tasted like there was no oregano or anything inside the sauce, the cheese was absolutely awful, my opinion my worst, frozen pizza was better than this, on top of everything else. The tables in the place were filthy, not even wiped down.i Don’t understand how Give this establishment, good reviews unless they don’t know pizza or I just had a really bad pizza maker this day
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3