We always enjoy! Our party enjoyed orange roughy, scallops and beef short ribs. All was delish!
Rita
We have enjoyed Mystic Fish since it opened, nearly 25 years ago. We've never had a bad meal or poor service. We go there for all our special occasions. Last night was no exception. Bonus was they had hogfish on the specials menu!
G. Matthew
This place is fabulous. We ate there two nights in a row. There are several fish choices and the preparations are amazing. But, it's not just fish. My father had a pork loin chop which I tasted. it was incredible. The value is astounding...... that's why the place was packed both nights. If you're a bleu cheese dressing fan, this is the place for you. They make their own. I cannot wait to go back.
David
Typically, we have Melissa as our server and she was out of pocket yesterday so we had John instead. Outstanding service, personality, plus, and we all laughed. It was great.
Marcie
Great food especially the Hog Fish. Very good service. I lovedt they had my favorite champagne in small flight bottle. Would return here again.
Michelle Spina
Incredible dining experience. The food and service was top notch!
LeeLee
I love this restaurant. We went last Christmas Eve, and again this year, with both being fantastic. The stand-out dishes were the stuffed artichoke heart, the bone-in pork chop, and the flourless chocolate cake. Tanya was our server and she was so pleasant and friendly and on her A-game. We plan to make this a yearly tradition - plus add in a few more visits through the year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eve Alman
Always an excellent meal and excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Willis-Lunsford
John, our waiter was absolutely the best!! He went above and beyond. It was my birthday 🎂 The Ahi Tuna that had was delicious. My husband had the Salmon dinner, which he really enjoyed. And a special birthday dessert Flan !!🎂 We will definitely go back and ask for John.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gary C
Upscale seafood experience. Well appointed, linen table cloths, selection of booths and tables. Interesting ambiance with moderate lighting and low lit fish aquariums throughout. Our service was excellent with dinners coming out well presented, well portioned and hot. For our table of five there were options for all. I enjoyed trying the pork chop to test the seafood alternate. It was cooked to perfection and accented with mashed potatoes and vegetables. There is patio service and although it borders the parking driveway, seems to be a nice set up.
A real find! The escargot in red wine are superb,as was the rest of the meals.
Anthony Aversa
The food is always amazing!!! This is our favorite restaurant!!! Angelina our server was fantastic also!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Meg
This is how you are supposed to dine. The duck was incredible. We travel here for trips every few months and we will be back. This trip was to celebrate our engagement and we were treated with dessert. I will take more photos when I get back into town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Zaino, RFC
Literally every bite I put in my mouth was incredible. I hate eating out because my wife is such an amazing chef, so when I'm pleasantly surprised, it deserves to be recognized. Great job! 👏🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dale Johnson
Sea bass was amazing! Shrimp and scallops was so delicious. Every visit is please and food is very good.
We always enjoy! Our party enjoyed orange roughy, scallops and beef short ribs. All was delish!
We have enjoyed Mystic Fish since it opened, nearly 25 years ago. We've never had a bad meal or poor service. We go there for all our special occasions. Last night was no exception. Bonus was they had hogfish on the specials menu!
This place is fabulous. We ate there two nights in a row. There are several fish choices and the preparations are amazing. But, it's not just fish. My father had a pork loin chop which I tasted. it was incredible. The value is astounding...... that's why the place was packed both nights. If you're a bleu cheese dressing fan, this is the place for you. They make their own. I cannot wait to go back.
Typically, we have Melissa as our server and she was out of pocket yesterday so we had John instead. Outstanding service, personality, plus, and we all laughed. It was great.
Great food especially the Hog Fish. Very good service. I lovedt they had my favorite champagne in small flight bottle. Would return here again.
Incredible dining experience. The food and service was top notch!
I love this restaurant. We went last Christmas Eve, and again this year, with both being fantastic. The stand-out dishes were the stuffed artichoke heart, the bone-in pork chop, and the flourless chocolate cake. Tanya was our server and she was so pleasant and friendly and on her A-game. We plan to make this a yearly tradition - plus add in a few more visits through the year.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always an excellent meal and excellent service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John, our waiter was absolutely the best!! He went above and beyond. It was my birthday 🎂 The Ahi Tuna that had was delicious. My husband had the Salmon dinner, which he really enjoyed. And a special birthday dessert Flan !!🎂 We will definitely go back and ask for John.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Upscale seafood experience. Well appointed, linen table cloths, selection of booths and tables. Interesting ambiance with moderate lighting and low lit fish aquariums throughout. Our service was excellent with dinners coming out well presented, well portioned and hot. For our table of five there were options for all. I enjoyed trying the pork chop to test the seafood alternate. It was cooked to perfection and accented with mashed potatoes and vegetables. There is patio service and although it borders the parking driveway, seems to be a nice set up.
Restaurantji Recommends
A real find! The escargot in red wine are superb,as was the rest of the meals.
The food is always amazing!!! This is our favorite restaurant!!! Angelina our server was fantastic also!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is how you are supposed to dine. The duck was incredible. We travel here for trips every few months and we will be back. This trip was to celebrate our engagement and we were treated with dessert. I will take more photos when I get back into town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Literally every bite I put in my mouth was incredible. I hate eating out because my wife is such an amazing chef, so when I'm pleasantly surprised, it deserves to be recognized. Great job! 👏🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sea bass was amazing! Shrimp and scallops was so delicious. Every visit is please and food is very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...