Polk City Ice Cream Company

213 Commonwealth Ave N, Polk City
(863) 874-4740

Recent Reviews

Desiree Pelletier

Can’t brag enough! Love love love this little ice cream shop in Polk City. We take the family here all the time. You can get a “passport” to make all of the flavors you’ve tried. Every time we stop in they have new ice cream flavors to try. They have your normal flavors and tons of fun ones. One of my favorites is the key lime pie. They also have sugar free ice cream, and freeze dried candy which the kids are loving now. Locals love this spot!Dietary restrictions: They have sugar free and sorbet

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brad Card

Awesome

Michael Besaw

If I drive to purchase products from a store front I’m not gonna go chase down someone to sell it to me if you can’t keep help to run your business the by all means close the damn door

Huzzah Joe

friendly people with great ice cream!

Karl Labe (Karl)

Excellent ice cream, many choices and very friendly service.....

Nichole Barber

De-lic-ious ❤️ pork sandwich was tinder and juicy. Ribs were perfectly cooked. Excellent food, excellent service.

angela abbott

The next time someone sends a message asking about if u have a purple ice cream with choc chips in it and a price. Your response it varies and I asked for a low and high price. Then don't respond. I wouldn't have wasted my time & gas had I known the ice cream I was going for wasn't there. You could have told me that much.

Maria T.

Update the hours to 8 or 8:30. We just left there and the person in there wiping down said they were closed and wouldn't open the door. It was a little passed 8 and your doors say 9 as well as your yelp and google business.

Jacob Summers

This place is awesome. Great ice cream & a friendly staff.

Janet Davis

Over $7.00 for a 16oz milkshake. Very expensive! I will drive back to Winter Haven to support another local family owned restaurant where a larger milkshake is under $3.00. I really wanted to support this local place but not at these prices.

Angel Martinez

Love the ice cream here it’s fire ???Vanilla ice cream is the best flavor ever ?

Jessica Christian

Isaac makes the best milk shakes in Polk County.If you haven’t tried Polk City Ice cream run don’t walk.

September C.

Amazing icecream and staff! Best place to get icecream in town. Would 10/10 recommend!

Daniel C.

Isaac makes the best milk shake in Polk county. If you haven't tried Polk City Ice cream run don't walk.

Bree S.

This is a cute little, no frills ice cream shop attached to a BBQ restaurant in town. Sometimes the door is locked but they leave a sign telling you to go through the BBQ restaurant and they will get someone to unlock it for you. The prices are reasonable and the portions are generous. We try and stop by every time we are in town. A fun, low key place for some ice cream!

Load More