Mamma Mia Pizzeria

My boys absolutely loved their pizza - down to the very last bite! Thank you for supporting families when it’s needed most! 🍕❤️

I would like to start off by saying that this business donated food to those who needed it during last years storms which I truly think is such a special way of saying thank you and giving back to the community that supports their business. Decent pizza when the dough is consistent however we have had several issues with delivery quality and receiving pizzas crushed or shifted cheese from poor driving. Also, some of the younger employees answering phones often ignore you when you walk in and continue on their phones or with their conversations like you’re not there. To finalize this review, the owners wife Kim cannot accept any form of criticism from customers even in the most respectful manner. A recent post on a local platform shows an interaction between Kim and others giving positive and neutral (no negative) feedback about their products. Kim is laugh reacting at customers that did not write an outright positive review, boasting about the location of origin (NY & Sicilian) in attempt to defend the quality of their food. This is a bad look for a business owner and if you’re going to conduct yourself as so, especially during the age of all things internet… then you should probably consider your actions seeing as you are the face of your business. I hope this review helps your business correct the things that no longer make us customers.

I am absolutely Appalled by the way I was treated tonight. I order an on line order. It says 20 minutes. I go there. After 40 minutes I ask about my order. They said the pizza is done and calzone was coming out of the oven. Then almost 10 more minutes go by before they give me my food. Pizza is now cool. I get home just as the called me to tell me they gave me a pice of BBQ pizza instead of the calzone. So now I have to go back to get the calzone which was NOT ready. After waiting another 15 minutes I finally get the calzone. Mindo you my pizza is cold now. I ask to speak to a manager and was told none was available. When I mentioned that my pizza was now cold the girl up front shrugged her shoulders like she could care less. The other girl told me that she told me on the phone it wasn't ready yet and she never did. I have been using you all since I moved here a year ago. The food is great but after tonight I WILL NOT be using you again. I can't believe I was treated this way. As a former business owner I would have fired them on the spot. ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE SERVICE

I ate there twice now, and I really like there pizza, its delicious 😋 and very filling as well, big slices.yummy yummy. I'm broke right now ,or I would order again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

I recently tried the EBA pizza at Mamma Mia’s, and it was excellent. The crust was baked just right and it held up perfectly under all the generous toppings. The balance of meats, veggies, and cheese made every bite flavorful and satisfying. You can really taste the freshness of the ingredients, and it’s clear they don’t cut corners. If you’re looking for a hearty, loaded pizza, the EBA at Mamma Mia’s is a must-try. Great food, great value, and always consistent quality.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots, Standard Calzone, 10 Wings

Bronx chic in the house.. Let's just start by saying Mamma Mia's food is so good!!! been in FL since 2017 couldn't find a single place that the pizza was good or decent.. Mamma Mia pizza is 20/20 5⭐️+ highly recommend the pizza so freaking good and cheesy and I can fold it. The crust is crusting if you know you know... It's like being home, and the staff is so nice always have peaceful, pleasant time good conversation when eating in, when I do get delivery the food is always fresh and hot. Ohh and they sell by the slice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Photo worthy YUMMM

Fantastic pizza. Great service. On time. Polite. We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Two Slices and a Drink

Honestly disappointed.
Whoever made the pizza has no idea what they’re doing as half of the pizza was missing sauce. The cheese fries were super soggy, gross and mostly cold. It was really difficult getting the French fries out from behind the behemoth pile of cheese that was just thrown on there.
Would not recommend.

Food: 2

this pizza shop is seriously the cutest. I came once last week and wanted to try it again before I left a review and it’s really really good and the service is always good as well. I can’t wait to take my girls in to dine in. We’ve always done takeout! I just seen they had a DIY pizza so I’ll definitely be bringing them in for that!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

When it comes to pizza to me it always starts with the flavor of the sauce... Best sauce I've tasted here in FL. Staff are all great also and are very fast with the service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered 2 Phillies and they were delicious 🤤 they even put cute writing on the boxes, that was a nice surprise 😆 5 stars!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Love the cheese pies.
And the garlic knots (bread bites) delicious

The pizza itself is decent, nothing to complain about there. But where this place really stands out (unfortunately) is in how slow they are. I’ve never experienced such consistently long waits nearly every time, I end up waiting over 30 minutes past the quoted pickup time. It’s become the norm rather than the exception. If you’re in a rush or value punctual service, this probably isn’t the place for you.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Order over the phone for three slices of pizza usually and every time they say 10-15 minutes and always wait there for an extra 15 minutes at least for just three slices of pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1