Used to love this place and order all the time. Last time we tried to order delivery the said they don’t accept orders the last hour. We have it another shot today & this time I’ve been called since 7:15 and they just don’t answer the take out phone!
Erica Pepitone
Excellent food very sweet waitress, and wonderful family, family owned and operated. Very welcoming ?
Carol S.
We have not been here for a while. We went on a Saturday evening, dinner time. The place was empty. We were told that they were out of eggplant and lasagna rolls. Ok no ...eggplant parmigiana at a place like this!! So nothing for me to eat !! Instead I ordered a Cesar salad and pasta fragioli soup. The Cesar was ok. Nothing special and my soup was dish water!!! I sent it back. Ordered the Italian wedding soup which was better. Not great. Really disappointing. My husband chicken parm was ok. The plate was too small. Things were squished together. The other couple had a pizza. They said it was good. Not good time for all. And no buns to the table. !! No crackers with my soup. Come on!!! We will not go back. Too many other restaurants to choose for Italian.
Donna Hynes
Food was great, can't wait to eat the rest tomorrow. Portion size was excellent. Garlic knots delicious. Our waitress did great handling an unexpected full dining room on a Monday night. Her grandparents started the restaurant, is a family place.
Pete Szelwach Sr.
Born on Long Island, first time at Panariello's for early Mother's Day and we were VERY impressed and happy to find this restaurant in PSL. The garlic knots - served hot with crisp crust and soft inside were the best I've had...ever! The chicken parm and lasagna were top notch on quality and flavor and as good as any in NY or Philly. Michael the owner, Miranda and Lauren were very friendly. Got a large calzone to go for this week and it's massive...can't wait. Highly recommend you disregard the low reviews and give them a try!
frank spinner
Excellent food, excellent service, great atmosphere. If you are in the area I would highly space recommend you stop in for a bite to eat.
Palmer Mittelsteadt
My friend & I were in the mood for a traditional pizza pie and boy did we get it!! We got a cheese pizza with fresh mozzarella and pepperoni, garlic knots and hot wings. The wings are delicious and crispy with just the right amount of sauce, the pizza was FANTASTIC and the garlic knots were THE BEST I have ever eaten in my life
Kim M.
I remember I used to get pizzas from here a few years back I think the reason I stopped was it was just a little bit out of the way from my house. I decided yesterday that coming home from work if I took the turnpike it would be close by to pick up a pizza. I called to get two of their cheese specials Monday and Tuesday I believe it's $9 and change I ordered extra cheese and extra sauce so I think it was 22 and change for both pies. I have to say they were delicious the best pizza I've had in a very very long time I will now come back even if it is out of my way.
Richard Petrella
ordered the ono everything pizza, absolutely no sauce, thin crust was still raw uncooked at half of pizza, very little pepperoni, saw no sausage, meatball slices were not sauced but dry, like a burger meat with lots of filler. cheese not high quality. added sauce on top, vegetables red peppers and onions were raw barely cooked. and long pieces, one of the worst pizzas for 22.00 i ever had.sad will not go back.
J R.
I placed an online order for the special which was a large cheese pie with a order of chicken wings, I also order a second order of wings. After I placed my order a young girl call me and told me that they run out of chicken wings on the bone, therefore I asked her to cancel the second order of wings. She told me in order to cancel and get reimburse I would have to call slice and cancel with them. So I decided to keep my original order, the wings that I have order was 1 order spicy and 1 garlic permassan. When I picked up my order I didn't realize that the pie I have gotten was regular and not large and both orders of wings where spicy and not exactly what I have order. When I got home and notice that my order was wrong I called the pizzeria and the young lady that answer said they only carry large pie and therefore they couldn't had giving me a regular size. I told her that I have oder from there several times and the pie was the wrong size. After that she asked me to hold for a min but instead she hung up on me and I called back twice but she didn't answer.
Mozzarella sticks were okay but hard to mess those up. The Faggiola soup and garlic knots were good. The French fries were soggy, the stuffed shells were not tasty at all and were drenched in sauce and the sausages were mushy. Very bad with no taste.
Angela Artura
I didn’t get my extra sauce when I asked for it..but the boneless chicken wings are uck frozen..and the Sicilian pizza is not crispy at all..but the regular pizza is pretty good for Florida the anti pasta wow nice you get mozzarella balls Artichokes all the meat olives onions peppers Delicious
Paige Roberts
My husband and I were on the way to eat at Pho Deli when we looked over and saw this place and decided to try it out. It was clean and quiet and the service was great.Zero wait time for seating which was great for the time of day we went.Friendly staff and worth every penny.Their food was fresh and hot and very flavorful!After our appetizer (garlic knots) my husband said “do you ever wish you could try something again for the first time.” They were perfect.Our food was amazing! We highly recommend this place and it’s worth every penny.
Bill Ray
Ordered two pizzas tonight for delivery, and asked for them well done. You knocked it out of the park. Both pies were done PERFECTLY! My husband told me that the pizzas were “very north” which in my book is one of the greatest compliments anyone can say about Florida pizza since I am from the New Haven area of Connecticut where they’re known for their pizza.
Antonio Bassolino
Best Italian food I have had in the St. Lucie and Martin County area in a very long time! Worth every penny!
Used to love this place and order all the time. Last time we tried to order delivery the said they don’t accept orders the last hour. We have it another shot today & this time I’ve been called since 7:15 and they just don’t answer the take out phone!
Excellent food very sweet waitress, and wonderful family, family owned and operated. Very welcoming ?
We have not been here for a while. We went on a Saturday evening, dinner time. The place was empty. We were told that they were out of eggplant and lasagna rolls. Ok no ...eggplant parmigiana at a place like this!! So nothing for me to eat !! Instead I ordered a Cesar salad and pasta fragioli soup. The Cesar was ok. Nothing special and my soup was dish water!!! I sent it back. Ordered the Italian wedding soup which was better. Not great. Really disappointing. My husband chicken parm was ok. The plate was too small. Things were squished together. The other couple had a pizza. They said it was good. Not good time for all. And no buns to the table. !! No crackers with my soup. Come on!!! We will not go back. Too many other restaurants to choose for Italian.
Food was great, can't wait to eat the rest tomorrow. Portion size was excellent. Garlic knots delicious. Our waitress did great handling an unexpected full dining room on a Monday night. Her grandparents started the restaurant, is a family place.
Born on Long Island, first time at Panariello's for early Mother's Day and we were VERY impressed and happy to find this restaurant in PSL. The garlic knots - served hot with crisp crust and soft inside were the best I've had...ever! The chicken parm and lasagna were top notch on quality and flavor and as good as any in NY or Philly. Michael the owner, Miranda and Lauren were very friendly. Got a large calzone to go for this week and it's massive...can't wait. Highly recommend you disregard the low reviews and give them a try!
Excellent food, excellent service, great atmosphere. If you are in the area I would highly space recommend you stop in for a bite to eat.
My friend & I were in the mood for a traditional pizza pie and boy did we get it!! We got a cheese pizza with fresh mozzarella and pepperoni, garlic knots and hot wings. The wings are delicious and crispy with just the right amount of sauce, the pizza was FANTASTIC and the garlic knots were THE BEST I have ever eaten in my life
I remember I used to get pizzas from here a few years back I think the reason I stopped was it was just a little bit out of the way from my house. I decided yesterday that coming home from work if I took the turnpike it would be close by to pick up a pizza. I called to get two of their cheese specials Monday and Tuesday I believe it's $9 and change I ordered extra cheese and extra sauce so I think it was 22 and change for both pies. I have to say they were delicious the best pizza I've had in a very very long time I will now come back even if it is out of my way.
ordered the ono everything pizza, absolutely no sauce, thin crust was still raw uncooked at half of pizza, very little pepperoni, saw no sausage, meatball slices were not sauced but dry, like a burger meat with lots of filler. cheese not high quality. added sauce on top, vegetables red peppers and onions were raw barely cooked. and long pieces, one of the worst pizzas for 22.00 i ever had.sad will not go back.
I placed an online order for the special which was a large cheese pie with a order of chicken wings, I also order a second order of wings. After I placed my order a young girl call me and told me that they run out of chicken wings on the bone, therefore I asked her to cancel the second order of wings. She told me in order to cancel and get reimburse I would have to call slice and cancel with them. So I decided to keep my original order, the wings that I have order was 1 order spicy and 1 garlic permassan. When I picked up my order I didn't realize that the pie I have gotten was regular and not large and both orders of wings where spicy and not exactly what I have order. When I got home and notice that my order was wrong I called the pizzeria and the young lady that answer said they only carry large pie and therefore they couldn't had giving me a regular size. I told her that I have oder from there several times and the pie was the wrong size. After that she asked me to hold for a min but instead she hung up on me and I called back twice but she didn't answer.
Restaurantji Recommends
Mozzarella sticks were okay but hard to mess those up. The Faggiola soup and garlic knots were good. The French fries were soggy, the stuffed shells were not tasty at all and were drenched in sauce and the sausages were mushy. Very bad with no taste.
I didn’t get my extra sauce when I asked for it..but the boneless chicken wings are uck frozen..and the Sicilian pizza is not crispy at all..but the regular pizza is pretty good for Florida the anti pasta wow nice you get mozzarella balls Artichokes all the meat olives onions peppers Delicious
My husband and I were on the way to eat at Pho Deli when we looked over and saw this place and decided to try it out. It was clean and quiet and the service was great.Zero wait time for seating which was great for the time of day we went.Friendly staff and worth every penny.Their food was fresh and hot and very flavorful!After our appetizer (garlic knots) my husband said “do you ever wish you could try something again for the first time.” They were perfect.Our food was amazing! We highly recommend this place and it’s worth every penny.
Ordered two pizzas tonight for delivery, and asked for them well done. You knocked it out of the park. Both pies were done PERFECTLY! My husband told me that the pizzas were “very north” which in my book is one of the greatest compliments anyone can say about Florida pizza since I am from the New Haven area of Connecticut where they’re known for their pizza.
Best Italian food I have had in the St. Lucie and Martin County area in a very long time! Worth every penny!