Place is closed permanently. Only gave it a one star for that reason. Good luck to whoever buys the place.
Bryce Hudson
Not a fun place at all! I'm joking! It can be as chill for a date or as fun as a dance party as you and your friends want it to be! The bartenders
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Emily Tripp
Going to miss this place! The owners are very nice, the environment is very chill, and the food/drinks are terrific. Highly recommend! Been coming here since it was OKW. Mixers is also awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Club Sandwich
Melissa N Tim
Both times we have been we have had great bartenders and service. Great atmosphere, will be back.
Victor Pibuldhanapatana
Had a Bleu Siracha burger with onion rings and some fried banana peppers. We sat at the outside bar. Alex served us with fast, friendly drinks and food. The mystery machine inside was a fun feature. Suggest stopping in if you're anywhere in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bonnie Poticny Realtor
The outdoor seating area was extremely relaxing and a great place for our group to sit together. I loved the Cajun wings!
Scoti “Scubi Doo” Scubi
Service was great and speedy. I came in and sat down and within a few minutes a server was there to take the drink order.
David Day
Not much going on here on a Saturday evening. The menu has a lot of variety. The buffalo chicken sandwich was spectacular, as was the chicken cheesesteak sandwich. If you like your nacho appetizer piled high, you're in the right place. It's a meal unto itself.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Alyssa Bailey
I LOVED the Totchos just as much as I loved our server Alex. He was over the top, 5 star services here. My boyfriend got a buffalo chicken sandwich, he also loved it. We want to come for brunch next time!
k o
I flew in from out of state to visit a friend and we stopped in for the $1 wing special. Our bartender Alex made me the best Key West sunrise! He kept checking on us and was super fun to chat with! I’ll make sure to visit again on my next vacation!
Went to this establishment on my vacation with my family and the food was so delicious and the atmosphere was very nice with live music. If you're LGBT+ inclusive & friendly, this is the place for you!Parking: The parking is similar to that of a busy downtown. You may have to look a little for a good spot, but it's worth it.
Steve C
Great service. Jessica knows how to make a great Cosmo. My omelet was very good. I definitely will go again.
Christine N.
My friends and I stopped at Old Key West Bar during a stop on our Pedal Pub. This was a fun dive bar with lawn games. Inside there was a big bar with decent drink prices. They even had one of those mystery gift vending machines that was fun to guess which items we would get. I opted to see what I would get from the vintage McDonalds toy and got a throwback gift! We had fun during our stop and this was a chill place to play some cornhole and hang out.
Jessica Jones
We found this gem off of Google and we were very pleased with the whole experience! Zach was our server/bartender and gave great service and hospitality! We had the tacho and they were so tasty! We did bring our baby, no high chairs BUT she still had a blast too! We highly recommend Mixers at Old Key West Bar & Grill and ask for Zach! Thanks again for the great food, drinks and service! They also have this fun mystery box #mysterybox vending machine that has so many funny and unique things!
Melanie Marie
Really fun local spot! They have lots of outdoor seating and they are pup friendly too. We had burgers, club sandwiches and blt’s which were all yummy and freshly made. Service was kind and quick and we’ll definitely be back to try the rest of the menu and daily specials.
Place is closed permanently. Only gave it a one star for that reason. Good luck to whoever buys the place.
Not a fun place at all! I'm joking! It can be as chill for a date or as fun as a dance party as you and your friends want it to be! The bartenders
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Going to miss this place! The owners are very nice, the environment is very chill, and the food/drinks are terrific. Highly recommend! Been coming here since it was OKW. Mixers is also awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Club Sandwich
Both times we have been we have had great bartenders and service. Great atmosphere, will be back.
Had a Bleu Siracha burger with onion rings and some fried banana peppers. We sat at the outside bar. Alex served us with fast, friendly drinks and food. The mystery machine inside was a fun feature. Suggest stopping in if you're anywhere in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The outdoor seating area was extremely relaxing and a great place for our group to sit together. I loved the Cajun wings!
Service was great and speedy. I came in and sat down and within a few minutes a server was there to take the drink order.
Not much going on here on a Saturday evening. The menu has a lot of variety. The buffalo chicken sandwich was spectacular, as was the chicken cheesesteak sandwich. If you like your nacho appetizer piled high, you're in the right place. It's a meal unto itself.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I LOVED the Totchos just as much as I loved our server Alex. He was over the top, 5 star services here. My boyfriend got a buffalo chicken sandwich, he also loved it. We want to come for brunch next time!
I flew in from out of state to visit a friend and we stopped in for the $1 wing special. Our bartender Alex made me the best Key West sunrise! He kept checking on us and was super fun to chat with! I’ll make sure to visit again on my next vacation!
Restaurantji Recommends
Went to this establishment on my vacation with my family and the food was so delicious and the atmosphere was very nice with live music. If you're LGBT+ inclusive & friendly, this is the place for you!Parking: The parking is similar to that of a busy downtown. You may have to look a little for a good spot, but it's worth it.
Great service. Jessica knows how to make a great Cosmo. My omelet was very good. I definitely will go again.
My friends and I stopped at Old Key West Bar during a stop on our Pedal Pub. This was a fun dive bar with lawn games. Inside there was a big bar with decent drink prices. They even had one of those mystery gift vending machines that was fun to guess which items we would get. I opted to see what I would get from the vintage McDonalds toy and got a throwback gift! We had fun during our stop and this was a chill place to play some cornhole and hang out.
We found this gem off of Google and we were very pleased with the whole experience! Zach was our server/bartender and gave great service and hospitality! We had the tacho and they were so tasty! We did bring our baby, no high chairs BUT she still had a blast too! We highly recommend Mixers at Old Key West Bar & Grill and ask for Zach! Thanks again for the great food, drinks and service! They also have this fun mystery box #mysterybox vending machine that has so many funny and unique things!
Really fun local spot! They have lots of outdoor seating and they are pup friendly too. We had burgers, club sandwiches and blt’s which were all yummy and freshly made. Service was kind and quick and we’ll definitely be back to try the rest of the menu and daily specials.