FANTASIC LONG TIME ITALIAN FAMILY OPERATED. ITALIAN GREAT MENU. VISITED OVER THE YEARS WHEN VACATIONING IN FLORIDA EAST COAST. VERY CONSISTANT. KIDS LOVE THE 24 INCH PIZZA! AND THE VARIETY OF TOPPINGS IS GREAT. ITALIAN DISHES MADE FROM SCRATCH ARE EXCELLENT. CHEF COMES OUT TO VISIT.
V8688HYpeterd
Pizza is fantastic, Sausage Parm Sub was mediocre at best. Sausage cut way too thin and the Sub overall was way too salty !! Pappagallo’s Sausage is cut thick and has a nice snap bite also a lot less salty !! Will not be ordering a Sausage Parm Sub from Bizarro again but their Pizza is still top notch.
Teresa Rossi Firestone
great food, and the owner is very nice, he always prepared something for you if you have some special diets great person.
Dagwood Supreme
Fantastic service from Rose! Food came out fast and scrumptious with exceptional atmosphere. Rose made it feel like home, couldn’t help but to order the mozzarella sticks. Do recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bruce R
Absolutely amazing Pizza and family and Service. I like to add prosciutto and arugula to my tomato, basil garlic, and they do it every time with a big smile. The cannolis are so top-notch. The environment is very family oriented and friendly and you see the son and Dad proud of every slice. Top it all off the pizza ingredients and crust are absolutely amazing. This is legitimate Italian New York style pizza with a wonderful flare of the old country … The calamari is some of the best around hot crispy, and fresh every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Schwarzbach
If you like soggy crust on top, near burnt on the bottom, canned mushrooms, veggies not cooked on top and paying $60 for (2) 16" pies with a side Caesar ... This is your place !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
David Hundley
Not open. Sign says they’ll be back at 11, but they’re still closed hours later. Phone still not set up. No sign. No outgoing message. Nothing. Was looking forward to the new location being better run than they were up the road.
Jace Carson
Rose is the best waitress on the planet? Better at making me feel like a special big boy than michael Phelps is at winning gold medals?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
davideK1594RY
Me and my wife haven’t post review in 6 years, but we felt like had to write about this experience. We called in a take-out pizza at 6:29 pm and picked up at 6:45pm. The pizza we picked up was cold to the touch and not cooked to our order. We understand mistakes happen, so we called the shop to let them know. The woman on the phone denied what we were saying and told us we ordered at 4:30pm and to put the pizza in our home oven to warm it back up. Not only did they accuse of us of being liars, they told us to cook the pizza at home. Keep my $25, your 2 hour old pizza is going in the trash, and we’re never eating here again.
Enjoyed 2 slices , boneless wings and some knots was delicious and peaceful I used my debit card to pay
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
funxgoodx
Cash Only. Let's get that established as so many only have cards or smart payments on their person.Food: I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni and soda to eat near the beach, which is 100 yards away. Total came to $13 not counting any "tip".The pizza was okay, not the best NY style pizza in the area, or elsewhere I've had. Very average. Edible, but lacked flavor.Atmosphere: very cramped internal ordering and eating area, but ample room to eat outside under a covered awning.Food was ordered and served 3 minutes later, average for a pizza by slice operation.Overall, it's a convenient place to grab a bite, but nothing to rave about and not a "value" either. If you are serious about eating a meal, I'd suggest other options nearby. But for a convenient bite in a beachside location, go for it.
FANTASIC LONG TIME ITALIAN FAMILY OPERATED. ITALIAN GREAT MENU. VISITED OVER THE YEARS WHEN VACATIONING IN FLORIDA EAST COAST. VERY CONSISTANT. KIDS LOVE THE 24 INCH PIZZA! AND THE VARIETY OF TOPPINGS IS GREAT. ITALIAN DISHES MADE FROM SCRATCH ARE EXCELLENT. CHEF COMES OUT TO VISIT.
Pizza is fantastic, Sausage Parm Sub was mediocre at best. Sausage cut way too thin and the Sub overall was way too salty !! Pappagallo’s Sausage is cut thick and has a nice snap bite also a lot less salty !! Will not be ordering a Sausage Parm Sub from Bizarro again but their Pizza is still top notch.
great food, and the owner is very nice, he always prepared something for you if you have some special diets great person.
Fantastic service from Rose! Food came out fast and scrumptious with exceptional atmosphere. Rose made it feel like home, couldn’t help but to order the mozzarella sticks. Do recommend!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely amazing Pizza and family and Service. I like to add prosciutto and arugula to my tomato, basil garlic, and they do it every time with a big smile. The cannolis are so top-notch. The environment is very family oriented and friendly and you see the son and Dad proud of every slice. Top it all off the pizza ingredients and crust are absolutely amazing. This is legitimate Italian New York style pizza with a wonderful flare of the old country … The calamari is some of the best around hot crispy, and fresh every time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you like soggy crust on top, near burnt on the bottom, canned mushrooms, veggies not cooked on top and paying $60 for (2) 16" pies with a side Caesar ... This is your place !
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Not open. Sign says they’ll be back at 11, but they’re still closed hours later. Phone still not set up. No sign. No outgoing message. Nothing. Was looking forward to the new location being better run than they were up the road.
Rose is the best waitress on the planet? Better at making me feel like a special big boy than michael Phelps is at winning gold medals?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Me and my wife haven’t post review in 6 years, but we felt like had to write about this experience. We called in a take-out pizza at 6:29 pm and picked up at 6:45pm. The pizza we picked up was cold to the touch and not cooked to our order. We understand mistakes happen, so we called the shop to let them know. The woman on the phone denied what we were saying and told us we ordered at 4:30pm and to put the pizza in our home oven to warm it back up. Not only did they accuse of us of being liars, they told us to cook the pizza at home. Keep my $25, your 2 hour old pizza is going in the trash, and we’re never eating here again.
Awesome pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Enjoyed 2 slices , boneless wings and some knots was delicious and peaceful I used my debit card to pay
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cash Only. Let's get that established as so many only have cards or smart payments on their person.Food: I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni and soda to eat near the beach, which is 100 yards away. Total came to $13 not counting any "tip".The pizza was okay, not the best NY style pizza in the area, or elsewhere I've had. Very average. Edible, but lacked flavor.Atmosphere: very cramped internal ordering and eating area, but ample room to eat outside under a covered awning.Food was ordered and served 3 minutes later, average for a pizza by slice operation.Overall, it's a convenient place to grab a bite, but nothing to rave about and not a "value" either. If you are serious about eating a meal, I'd suggest other options nearby. But for a convenient bite in a beachside location, go for it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Beach setting, cash only, fantastic Norteast style pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Regular Signature Stromboli, Cheese Pizza
Love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get the Margherita Pizza! We definitely liked the thin crust. And, we can’t thank Veronica enough. She was so friendly and helpful.
Loading...