Have recently discovered this spot via a friend and it has been outstanding. The food and prices are consistently great bla bla bla boring typical review language albeit true. The real reason to come besides everything you would expect to find at your local pizza spot(which will be great) are the items that you wouldn’t but they will keep you coming back with something for everyone. Real hand cut in house mozzarella sticks Onion rings made from whole onions inhouse Zucchini Fries from whole zucchini inhouse Garlic mushrooms in a white wine savory sauce Unique flavor combinations on pizzas never seen before-the godfather is crazy good Loaded BLT best bacon sandwich ever Turkey Bacon Avacado Sub add siracha mayo Wagyu Cheeseburger(American Cheese & cooked to temp they way you want not the way they tell you) Potato Salad made from whole potatoes Fresh Cut Fries from whole potatoes Yes they have 9 classic pasta dishes , 7 subs, 6 salads, grain bowls, 12 prebuilt pizza combos, chicken wings, calzones, strombolis, chicken wings, meatballs, chicken parm, and garlic knots Yes if you just want dessert there are only 4 but all are home runs in order and better than going to the local ice cream shop for your sweet fix if you just want to come early or late for it. 1.) Rum Cake 2.) Zeppoles 3.) Cannoli 4.) Lemoncello But for all you beer and wine drinkers they have plenty of choices but every beer is poured in a frozen mug like god intended. Come with your friends with confidence that everyone will find something they will be happy with and that the owner will meet you and remember you on your second visit by name. OLD SCHOOL WITH PRIDE!
Winegirl52
We visited here again after more than 5 years. Don't know why we hadn't been back sooner. Pizza was great! Service by Amelia was wonderful. Such a great server. Great bottle of wine without being ripped of. Really enjoyed, and will be back more often. Keep visiting Seminole restaurants to support local, and this will be at the top of our list.
nick Scunge
I ordered a stromboli which was full of 80% onions( raw) and 15% peppers (also raw) some cheese and they describe it in their menu as having Italian sausage and mushrooms but I was hard pressed to find of taste any of it in the whole thing! Also since the veggies were raw the whole thing was soggy! Not worth the almost $16.00 it costs! The couple we were with ordered a small cheese pizza and it looked like the last frozen pizza I ate ! I believe they use prefrontal crusts that they thaw out and stretch out as if the were working with a great piece of dough! To prove it i dare you to find a industrial dough mixer they would need to create enough dough . I didn't see one! The pie my friends got looked like a huge Ritz cracker with sauce and cheese on it! I don't think anyone actually has been to Brooklyn much less eaten pizza or anything else there!
terrie elliott
Thin pizza crust. Gluten free crust. Can eat inside or out, MA and pa environment, maybe occupancy 40?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Airika
Nice pizza restaurant and food was good. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. Menu had great options to choose from. I do have to say the pizza was a little lacking in flavor, maybe will give it another try next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Tom Cook
Great people, great food, great prices. Check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Roegner
Got takeout and it was truly one of the worst dinners I’ve ever had. We got a wide variety of different items and none of it was good. Food was cold and seemed like it had been cooked hours before. Very disappointing experience
Food: 1
Lori
Perfection 🍕 nice and brown!!! Delivery by the nicest guy! Thanks to all! See ya next time! Once a week not enough🤣
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karl Leibensperger
We ordered two pizzas for pickup and, as promised, they were ready in 20 minutes after which we got home within 5 minutes more. The toppings were plentiful. The Mama's Meatball I actually couldn't taste much, but my wife said it was good to her so it must be my problem. It did need a couple minutes in the air fryer as I read suggested in another review's response because it was cool in the center. We agreed that the white pizza needed more garlic. The staff were very friendly, including the owner when I told them that I wouldn't return because of a 4% charge to pay with a credit card, more than they get charged for any card. And who uses cash since the pandemic? We had a pleasant discussion where I told him that I feel it is bad business to charge someone to pay you while he said his accountant told him he had to charge a fee to stay in business. The easy answer is to raise your prices to cover this expense like every other, but I can see how that is difficult when you are already charging $60 to pickup two pizzas.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
E E
Owner is always there & consistently makes an effort to make sure his patrons love the food & feel wwlcomed & appreciated.
Very good food. Very, very good sangria. Jovial hometown place.
Absolutely THE BEST NY STYLE PIZZA IN PINELLAS COUNTY!!!! I highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza Company in Seminole before you try any other location on Ulmerton Rd. The staff was amazing!!! I will definitely be recomending we always eat here to all of my out of town guest (and local friends). Thanks again for such a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Practical Applications
My kid was over the moon for this place. Gluten free , vegan options! Also the regular pizza was fantastic too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Angela Zourdos
Consistently great service and delicious pies! My 3-year-old grandson loves going here too, they always give him dough and cookie cutters so he can make shapes while we wait. Yes, they’re on delivery apps, but calling directly is quicker and saves you money.
Thanks for years of consistent service, Brooklyn Pizza Co!🍕👏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward Bogacki
I've always heard this place was the best and now we've tried it and it is the best in Tampa Bay! They told us that nothing's ever Frozen and everything is fresh and boy it is. We had bruschetta this was the best I've ever had in my life. You can tell the bread was very fresh. The mozzarella sticks were the best. Let me order a calzone which was awesome. I could tell everything was fresh and nothing was frozen. The place was very clean and the surface was excellent. I will 100% be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John O'Brien
As a New Yorker of 50 + years I was very happy crust , sauce to cheese ratio was perfect I did a take out pie so no service/ atmosphere
Have recently discovered this spot via a friend and it has been outstanding. The food and prices are consistently great bla bla bla boring typical review language albeit true. The real reason to come besides everything you would expect to find at your local pizza spot(which will be great) are the items that you wouldn’t but they will keep you coming back with something for everyone. Real hand cut in house mozzarella sticks Onion rings made from whole onions inhouse Zucchini Fries from whole zucchini inhouse Garlic mushrooms in a white wine savory sauce Unique flavor combinations on pizzas never seen before-the godfather is crazy good Loaded BLT best bacon sandwich ever Turkey Bacon Avacado Sub add siracha mayo Wagyu Cheeseburger(American Cheese & cooked to temp they way you want not the way they tell you) Potato Salad made from whole potatoes Fresh Cut Fries from whole potatoes Yes they have 9 classic pasta dishes , 7 subs, 6 salads, grain bowls, 12 prebuilt pizza combos, chicken wings, calzones, strombolis, chicken wings, meatballs, chicken parm, and garlic knots Yes if you just want dessert there are only 4 but all are home runs in order and better than going to the local ice cream shop for your sweet fix if you just want to come early or late for it. 1.) Rum Cake 2.) Zeppoles 3.) Cannoli 4.) Lemoncello But for all you beer and wine drinkers they have plenty of choices but every beer is poured in a frozen mug like god intended. Come with your friends with confidence that everyone will find something they will be happy with and that the owner will meet you and remember you on your second visit by name. OLD SCHOOL WITH PRIDE!
We visited here again after more than 5 years. Don't know why we hadn't been back sooner. Pizza was great! Service by Amelia was wonderful. Such a great server. Great bottle of wine without being ripped of. Really enjoyed, and will be back more often. Keep visiting Seminole restaurants to support local, and this will be at the top of our list.
I ordered a stromboli which was full of 80% onions( raw) and 15% peppers (also raw) some cheese and they describe it in their menu as having Italian sausage and mushrooms but I was hard pressed to find of taste any of it in the whole thing! Also since the veggies were raw the whole thing was soggy! Not worth the almost $16.00 it costs!
The couple we were with ordered a small cheese pizza and it looked like the last frozen pizza I ate ! I believe they use prefrontal crusts that they thaw out and stretch out as if the were working with a great piece of dough! To prove it i dare you to find a industrial dough mixer they would need to create enough dough . I didn't see one! The pie my friends got looked like a huge Ritz cracker with sauce and cheese on it! I don't think anyone actually has been to Brooklyn much less eaten pizza or anything else there!
Thin pizza crust. Gluten free crust. Can eat inside or out, MA and pa environment, maybe occupancy 40?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice pizza restaurant and food was good. Our
waitress was very friendly and attentive. Menu had great options to choose from.
I do have to say the pizza was a little lacking in flavor, maybe will give it another try next time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Great people, great food, great prices. Check them out!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got takeout and it was truly one of the worst dinners I’ve ever had. We got a wide variety of different items and none of it was good. Food was cold and seemed like it had been cooked hours before. Very disappointing experience
Food: 1
Perfection 🍕 nice and brown!!! Delivery by the nicest guy! Thanks to all! See ya next time! Once a week not enough🤣
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered two pizzas for pickup and, as promised, they were ready in 20 minutes after which we got home within 5 minutes more. The toppings were plentiful. The Mama's Meatball I actually couldn't taste much, but my wife said it was good to her so it must be my problem. It did need a couple minutes in the air fryer as I read suggested in another review's response because it was cool in the center. We agreed that the white pizza needed more garlic. The staff were very friendly, including the owner when I told them that I wouldn't return because of a 4% charge to pay with a credit card, more than they get charged for any card. And who uses cash since the pandemic? We had a pleasant discussion where I told him that I feel it is bad business to charge someone to pay you while he said his accountant told him he had to charge a fee to stay in business. The easy answer is to raise your prices to cover this expense like every other, but I can see how that is difficult when you are already charging $60 to pickup two pizzas.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 5
Owner is always there & consistently makes an effort to make sure his patrons love the food & feel wwlcomed & appreciated.
Very good food. Very, very good sangria. Jovial hometown place.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely THE BEST NY STYLE PIZZA IN PINELLAS COUNTY!!!!
I highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza Company in Seminole before you try any other location on Ulmerton Rd. The staff was amazing!!! I will definitely be recomending we always eat here to all of my out of town guest (and local friends). Thanks again for such a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My kid was over the moon for this place. Gluten free , vegan options! Also the regular pizza was fantastic too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Consistently great service and delicious pies! My 3-year-old grandson loves going here too, they always give him dough and cookie cutters so he can make shapes while we wait. Yes, they’re on delivery apps, but calling directly is quicker and saves you money.
Thanks for years of consistent service, Brooklyn Pizza Co!🍕👏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've always heard this place was the best and now we've tried it and it is the best in Tampa Bay! They told us that nothing's ever Frozen and everything is fresh and boy it is. We had bruschetta this was the best I've ever had in my life. You can tell the bread was very fresh. The mozzarella sticks were the best. Let me order a calzone which was awesome. I could tell everything was fresh and nothing was frozen. The place was very clean and the surface was excellent. I will 100% be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
As a New Yorker of 50 + years
I was very happy crust , sauce to cheese ratio was perfect
I did a take out pie so no service/ atmosphere
Food: 4
Loading...