Another Broken Egg Cafe

140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key
(941) 552-8320

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Another Broken Egg Bloody Mary Mix
Another Broken Egg Pepper Sauce
Broken Egg Biscuit Sandwich
Apple Fritter French Toast
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Order of Biscuit Beignets
Eggs Blackstone Benedict
Bourbon Street Pancakes
Biscuits and Gravy
Key West Pancakes

Menu

Featured items
Belgian Waffle
Light and golden waffle topped with powdered sugar
Sunrise Spinach Scrambler
Scrambled eggs filled with fresh spinach, bacon and onions, topped with Jack cheese.
Southwest Scrambler
Scrambled eggs filled with chorizo, onions, tomatoes and green chilies, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese. Sides of guacamole and salsa. Served with flour tortillas instead of an English muffin.
The Floridian™ Omelette
Cream cheese-filled omelette topped with garlic butter sautéed crab meat, Jack cheese and green onions
Buttermilk Pancakes
Three house-recipe buttermilk cakes.
Traditional Day Starter
Two eggs any style with your choice of baked bacon, house-made sausage patties, andouille sausage, maple apple chicken sausage or sweet ham. Served with an English muffin.
The Supreme Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Filled with sausage, bacon, onions and mushrooms, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin. Served with grits.
Crab Cake Benedict
Jumbo lump crab cakes on an English muffin, topped with poached eggs, andouille-infused hollandaise, red peppers and green onions.
Eggs Benedict
Grilled breakfast ham on an English muffin, topped with poached eggs, hollandaise and green onions.
The Supreme Omelette
Filled with sausage, bacon, onions and mushrooms, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese.

Seasonal Selections
Tiramisu French Toast
French toast filled with cream cheese, topped with espresso whipped cream and dusted with cocoa. (910 cal) Served with two eggs any style (+120-220 cal) and choice of baked bacon or house-made sausage patties (+180/250 cal).
Lobster Hash Benedict
Cheddar and ham-filled potato hash, poached eggs, sautéed lobster, truffle seasoned mushrooms, red pepper hollandaise, topped with fried onions. (910 cal) Served with grits or fresh country potatoes. (+180/320 cal)
Chilaquiles
Tortillas with guajillo sauce, chorizo, Jack cheese, two over-medium eggs, red onions, radishes, goat cheese, cilantro and a lime. Sides of sour cream and house-made guacamole. (1310 cal) Served with grits or fresh country potatoes. (+180/320 cal)
Fresh Fruit & Honey Waffle
Belgian waffle topped with fresh blueberries, strawberries and powdered sugar, served with a side of cherry honey butter sauce. (850 cal) Served with two eggs any style (+120-220 cal) and choice of baked bacon or house-made sausage patties (+180/250 cal).

Brunch Specialties
Country Power Bowl
Scrambled eggs filled with country ham, onions and tomatoes over Cheddar Jack cheese grits. Topped with country sausage gravy. Served with baked bacon and an over-sized biscuit. (1370 cal)Pair with an Abita® Amber Lager (130 cal) and Rwanda Single-Origin Coffee (0 cal).
Hash Brown Benedict
Ham and cheese stuffed crispy hash brown croquettes, topped with poached eggs, mushroom herbed hollandaise and red peppers. Served with grits or fresh country potatoes
Shrimp 'N Grits
Gulf shrimp and andouille sausage sauteed with red peppers and onions in a spicy low country reduction, over creamy cheese grits. Served with garlic bread and a lemon.
Smoked Salmon Benedict
Toasted bagel, cream cheese, smoked salmon and poached eggs, topped with red onions, capers and green onions.
Eggs Blackstone Benedict
Grilled red tomato slices on an English muffin, topped with poached eggs, hollandaise, chopped bacon and green onions.
Cinnamon Roll French Toast
Thick-sliced, house-baked French-toast style cinnamon rolls topped with cream cheese icing, rum butter sauce drizzle, fresh seasonal berries and whipped cream.
Crab Cake Benedict
Jumbo lump crab cakes on an English muffin, topped with poached eggs, andouille-infused hollandaise, red peppers and green onions.
Mardi Gras Omelette
Filled with Louisiana crawfish, gulf shrimp, andouille and red peppers, topped with tomato hollandaise, tomatoes and green onions.
Chicken & Waffles
Crispy fried chicken tenders on a Belgian waffle, drizzled with house-made chipotle honey.

Traditional Classics
Biscuit & Gravy
House-recipe country sausage over an over-sized biscuit, two eggs any style, and two house-made sausage patties.
Traditional Day Starter
Two eggs any style with your choice of baked bacon, house-made sausage patties, andouille sausage, maple apple chicken sausage or sweet ham. Served with an English muffin.
Huevos Rancheros
Crispy flour tortillas, black beans, green chilies, onions and two over-medium eggs with Cheddar Jack cheese and cilantro. Sides of salsa and sour cream.
Eggs Benedict
Grilled breakfast ham on an English muffin, topped with poached eggs, hollandaise and green onions.
BROKEN EGG® Biscuit Sandwich
Fried chicken tender and a BROKEN EGG® topped with country sausage gravy on an over-sized biscuit.

Indulgences
Buttermilk Pancakes
Three house-recipe buttermilk cakes.
Gluten-Friendly Pancakes
Three house-recipe gluten-friendly cakes.
Belgian Waffle
Light and golden waffle topped with powdered sugar
Strawberry Pound Cake French Toast
French toast-style pound cake topped with fresh strawberries, fresh whipped cream and crème brûlée sugar
Apple Fritter French Toast
French-toast style fritters layered with fried apples, a bourbon cream sauce and topped with fresh blueberries and powdered sugar. (1380 cal)
Cookie Dough Waffle
Freshly-baked cookie dough Belgian waffle topped with cookie dough bites, fresh whipped cream, chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar. Served with two eggs any style and baked bacon or house-made sausage patties.
Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese Pancakes
Three house-recipe cakes with fresh blueberries and goat cheese, topped with lemon zest and fresh whipped cream.
Classic French Toast
Thick-sliced bread battered and grilled, topped with powdered sugar
Bourbon Street Pancakes
Three house-recipe cakes topped bananas, pecans, rum butter sauce drizzle and whipped cream.
Pumpkin Waffle
Pumpkin-infused Belgian waffle topped with pecans, cinnamon spiced compound butter and powdered sugar. (670 cal)

Omelettes and Scramblers
Southwest Scrambler
Scrambled eggs filled with chorizo, onions, tomatoes and green chilies, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese. Sides of guacamole and salsa. Served with flour tortillas instead of an English muffin.
Sunrise Spinach Scrambler
Scrambled eggs filled with fresh spinach, bacon and onions, topped with Jack cheese.
The Supreme Omelette
Filled with sausage, bacon, onions and mushrooms, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese.
The Floridian™ Omelette
Cream cheese-filled omelette topped with garlic butter sautéed crab meat, Jack cheese and green onions
Hey Lucy!® Omelette
Chorizo, onions and green chilies omelette, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese and avocado. Sides of salsa and sour cream.
Lobster & Brie Omelette
Cream cheese-filled omelette topped with Brie cheese and champagne butter sauce sautéed lobster meat, tomatoes and green onions. Served with an English muffin.
Bacquezo® Omelette
Cream cheese-filled omelette with bacon, topped with garlic butter sautéed chorizo, Jack cheese and green onions.
Veggie Delight Omelette
Goat cheese-filled omelette with fresh spinach, tomatoes and sautéed mushrooms. Served with an English muffin and grits or fresh country potatoes.

Sensible Creations
Skinny Omelette
Goat cheese-filled egg white omelette with asparagus, roasted red peppers and roasted garlic cloves. Topped with fresh herbs and green onions. Served with an English muffin and fresh seasonal fruit.
Shrimp Benedict
Poached eggs on grilled focaccia with sautéed mushrooms, roasted peppers, onions and arugula. Topped with Gulf shrimp in a creamy velouté sauce and sliced green onions. Served with fresh seasonal fruit.
Monterey Power Omelette
Egg white omelette with chicken, onions, green chilies and tomatoes. Topped with guajillo sauce, Jack cheese and avocado. Side of sour cream. Served with an English muffin and fresh seasonal fruit.

Sandwiches & Salads
BROKEN EGG® Biscuit Sandwich
Fried chicken tender and a BROKEN EGG® topped with country sausage gravy on an over-sized biscuit.
Bacon Lover's BLT&A
Thick-cut baked bacon strips, lettuce, avocado, tomatoes and Cheddar Jack cheese with garlic aioli on nine-grain bread.
Sonoma Club Sandwich
Ham, turkey, baked bacon, guacamole, Cheddar Jack cheese, tomato and pickled red onions on your choice of white or nine-grain bread.
Classic Bacon Burger
Two hand-pressed beef patties, baked bacon, Cheddar Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and red onion on a brioche bun. Served with a pickle and fresh country potatoes.
Southwest Chop Salad
Romaine, spinach, mushrooms, red onion, black beans, chopped bacon and turkey tossed in a chipotle ranch. Served with crispy tortilla strips, avocado and tomato slices. Substitute chicken at no additional cost.
Southern Chicken Sandwich
Choice of grilled or fried chicken, baked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and pickled red onions with ranch dressing on a brioche bun.
Benedict Burger
Hand-pressed beef patty, grilled ham, over-medium fried egg, hollandaise and green onions on a brioche bun.

Kid's Menu
Kids' Little Rooster
Scrambled egg, fresh seasonal fruit, English muffin and baked bacon.
Kids' Dollar Pancakes
Three kid-size house-recipe cakes. Served with scrambled egg and baked bacon.
Kids' Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Three kid-size house-recipe cakes filled with chocolate chips and topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate syrup. Served with scrambled egg and bacon.
Kids' Waffle Sampler
Kid-sized waffle topped with powdered sugar. Served with scrambled egg and baked bacon.
Kids' French Toast Sampler
One thick-sliced French toast topped with powdered sugar. Served with scrambled egg and baked bacon.

Bloody Mary & Mimosa Kits
Make-It-Yourself Mimosa Kit
2 Bottles of Bubbles, 1 bottle of your choice juice (Apple, Cranberry Cocktail or Orange), strawberry garnishes and 4 to-go cups. Food purchase required.

Cocktails To-Go
Lemon Blueberry Mimosa
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Orange Mimosa
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Spiked Caramel Cold Brew
Coffee liqueur*, Irish cream* and cold brew coffee with a salted caramel rim.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
ABE Famous Infused Mary
Spicy pepper-infused vodka* with our house-recipebloody mary mix.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Spiked Vanilla Cold Brew
Vanilla-infused vodka*, cold brew coffee, Finest Call Espresso and Irish cream* topping.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Strawberry Nectar Mimosa
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Black Cherry Mimosa
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Apple Mimosa
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Cranberry Mimosa
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®

Cocktail Pitchers To-Go
Orange Mimosa Pitcher
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
ABE Famous Infused Mary Pitcher
Spicy pepper-infused vodka* with our house-recipebloody mary mix.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Lemon Blueberry Mimosa Pitcher
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Strawberry Nectar Mimosa Pitcher
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Black Cherry Mimosa Pitcher
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Apple Mimosa Pitcher
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Cranberry Mimosa
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®

Bloody Mary & Mimosa Kits
Make-It-Yourself Mimosa Kit with Wycliffe, 750ml champagne (9.5%25 ABV)
2 Bottles of Bubbles, 1 bottle of your choice juice (Apple, Cranberry Cocktail or Orange), strawberry garnishes and 4 to-go cups. Food purchase required.
Make-It-Yourself Bloody Mary Kit with Soboloff, 1L wine-based vodka (20%25 ABV)
2 Bottles of ABE Bloody Mary Mix, 1 bottle of Soboloff Wine-Based Vodka, 4 garnish skewers, and 4 to-go cups. Food purchase required

Cocktails To-Go
Spiked Vanilla Cold Brew, 7.25oz (4%25)
Vanilla-infused vodka*, cold brew coffee, Finest Call Espresso and Irish cream* topping.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
ABE Famous Infused Mary, 6.25oz (5%25)
Spicy pepper-infused vodka* with our house-recipebloody mary mix.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Lemon Blueberry Mimosa Pitcher, 8oz (9%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Orange Mimosa Pitcher, 8oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Spiked Caramel Cold Brew, 5.99oz (4%25)
Coffee liqueur*, Irish cream* and cold brew coffee with a salted caramel rim.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Strawberry Nectar Mimosa Pitcher, 8oz (8%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Black Cherry Mimosa Pitcher, 8oz (8%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Apple Mimosa Pitcher, 8oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Cranberry Mimosa, 8oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®

Cocktail Pitchers To-Go
ABE Famous Infused Mary Pitcher, 25oz (5%25)
Spicy pepper-infused vodka* with our house-recipebloody mary mix.*All drinks are prepared with wine-based 24% alcohol by volume.
Lemon Blueberry Mimosa Pitcher, 32oz (9%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Orange Mimosa Pitcher, 32oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Strawberry Nectar Mimosa Pitcher, 32oz (8%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Black Cherry Mimosa Pitcher, 32oz (8%25)
Wycliff® California Champagne infused with fresh fruit flavors and spirits.
Apple Mimosa Pitcher, 32oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®
Cranberry Mimosa, 32oz (8%25)
Wycliff ® California Champagne and Simply Beverages ®

Sides
1/2 Order of Biscuit Beignets
Southern-style beignets with powdered sugar and honey marmalade.
Biscuit Beignets
Southern-style beignets with powdered sugar and honey marmalade.
Baked Bacon
Naturally smoked, thick-sliced crispy backed bacon.
Fresh Seasonal Fruit
2-Stack Indulgences Pancakes
City Grits
Grits with cheese and topped with baked bacon, green onions and tomatoes.
House-Made Sweet & Savory Sausage
Side of French Toast
Grits
1 Waffle
Fresh Country Potatoes

Beverages
Colombian Blend Coffee
French Roast Cold Brew
100%25 Pure Squeezed Orange Juice
2%25 Milk
Soft Drink
Sweet Tea
Cranberry Cocktail Juice
100%25 Pure Pressed Apple Juice
Unsweet Tea
Raspberry Tea
Chocolate Milk with Fresh Whipped Cream

Retail Items
Barista House Blend Coffee
One bag of our Barista House Blend Coffee to brew at home!
Another Broken Egg Pepper Sauce
Another Broken Egg Bloody Mary Mix
Single-Origin Coffee
One bag of our Single-Origin Coffee for you to brew at home!

Gluten Friendly Options
The Supreme Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Filled with sausage, bacon, onions and mushrooms, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin. Served with grits.
Hey Lucy!® Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Chorizo, onions and green chilies omelette, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese and avocado. Sides of salsa and sour cream. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin. Served with a side of grits.
Bacquezo® Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Cream cheese-filled omelette with bacon, topped with garlic butter sautéed chorizo, Jack cheese and green onions. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin. Served with a side of grits.
Traditional Day Starter - Gluten Friendly
Two eggs any style with your choice of baked bacon, house-made sausage patties, andouille sausage, maple apple chicken sausage or sweet ham. Served with grits. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin.
Southern Chicken Sandwich - Gluten Friendly
Grilled chicken, baked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato and pickled red onions with ranch dressing. Substitute gluten friendly bread for focaccia. Served with a pickle and grits.
Bacon Lover's BLT&A - Gluten Friendly - Revel
Thick-cut baked bacon strips, lettuce, avocado, tomatoes and Cheddar Jack cheese with garlic aioli. Substitute gluten-friendly bread for nine-rain bread. Served with pickle and grits.
Gluten-Friendly Pancakes
Two house-recipe gluten-friendly cakes. You can choose a fun flavor for an additional price.
The Floridian™ Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Cream cheese-filled omelette topped with garlic butter sautéed crab meat, Jack cheese and green onions Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin. Served with a side of grits.
Skinny Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Goat cheese-filled egg white omelette with asparagus, roasted red peppers and roasted garlic cloves. Topped with fresh herbs and green onions. Served with fresh seasonal fruit. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin.
Sunrise Spinach Scrambler - Gluten Friendly
Scrambled eggs filled with fresh spinach, bacon and onions, topped with Jack cheese. Substitute one slice of gluten friendly bread for the English Muffin.
Sonoma Club Sandwich - Gluten Friendly
Ham, turkey, baked bacon, guacamole, Cheddar Jack cheese, tomato and pickled red onions Substitute gluten friendly bread. Served with a pickle and grits.
Classic Bacon Burger - Gluten Friendly
Two hand-pressed beef patties, baked bacon, Cheddar Jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and red onion on. Substitute gluten friendly bread for brioche bun. Served with a pickle and grits.
Kids' Dollar Gluten Friendly Pancakes
Three kid-size house-recipe cakes. Served with scrambled egg and baked bacon.
Veggie Delight Omelette - Gluten Friendly
Goat cheese-filled omelette with fresh spinach, tomatoes and sautéed mushrooms. Served with gluten friendly bread and fresh seasonal fruit.
Kids' Little Rooster Gluten Friendly
Scrambled egg, fresh seasonal fruit, English muffin and baked bacon.
Kids' Chocolate Chip Gluten Friendly Pancakes
Three kid-size house-recipe cakes filled with chocolate chips and topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate syrup. Served with scrambled egg and bacon.

Vegetarian Options
Bourbon Street Pancakes - Vegetarian Option
Two house-recipe cakes topped bananas, pecans, rum butter drizzle sauce and whipped cream. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fresh seasonal fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for the bacon sausage or ham.
Buttermilk Pancakes - Vegetarian Option
Two house-recipe buttermilk cakes.
Gluten-Friendly Pancakes - Vegetarian Option
Two house-recipe gluten-friendly cakes. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fresh seasonal fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for the bacon sausage or ham.
Cinnamon Roll French Toast - Vegetarian Option
Thick-sliced, house-baked French-toast style cinnamon rolls topped with cream cheese icing, Foster sauce, fresh seasonal berries and whipped cream. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fresh seasonal fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for the bacon sausage or ham.
Classic French Toast - Vegetarian Option
Thick-sliced bread battered and grilled, topped with powdered sugar. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fresh seasonal fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for the bacon sausage or ham.
Huevos Rancheros- Vegetarian Option
Crispy flour tortillas, black beans, green chilies, onions and two over-medium eggs with Cheddar Jack cheese and cilantro. Sides of salsa and sour cream.
Hey Lucy!® Omelette - Vegetarian Option
Asparagus (substituted for Chorizo), onions and green chilies omelette, topped with Cheddar Jack cheese and avocado. Sides of salsa and sour cream.
Veggie Delight Omelette - Vegetarian Option
Goat cheese-filled omelette with fresh spinach, tomatoes and sautéed mushrooms. Served with an English muffin and fresh seasonal fruit.
Lemon Blueberry Goat Cheese Pancakes - Vegetarian Option
Two house-recipe cakes filled with fresh blueberries and goat cheese, topped with lemon zest and fresh whipped cream. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fresh seasonal fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for the bacon sausage or ham.
Skinny Omelette - Vegetarian Option
Goat cheese-filled egg white omelette with asparagus, roasted red peppers and roasted garlic cloves. Topped with fresh herbs and green onions. Served with an English muffin and fresh seasonal fruit.
Vegetarian Southwest Chop Salad
Romaine, spinach, mushrooms, red onion, black beans, tossed in a chipotle ranch. Served with crispy tortilla strips, avocado and tomato slices. Substitute the bacon and turkey with two additional vegetables including mushrooms, red onion, black beans, avocado or tomatoes.
Strawberry Pound Cake French Toast - Vegetarian
French toast-style pound cake topped with fresh strawberries, fresh whipped cream and crème brûlée sugar. Served with two eggs any style and your choice of grits, fresh country potatoes, fruit or tomatoes as a substitution for bacon, sausage or ham.
Sunrise Spinach Scrambler - Vegetarian Option - Revel
Scrambled eggs filled with fresh spinach and onions, topped with Jack cheese. Substitute the bacon with any one of our vegetables including tomatoes, asparagus, roasted peppers or mushrooms. Served with an English muffin and grits or fresh country potatoes.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+97 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+96 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Our server, Anna L. was one of the best I have had on the island! Very knowledgeable and her personality is above and beyond. It is a must go place in Siesta Key and ask for Anna L.
October 2025
We waited a few minutes to sit, as well for the food, but the food was definitely worth it!! The place was super busy but we luckily got the best server, Kenna. You need a couple more of her! She was wonderful. We are looking forward to the next few days in Siesta Key.
October 2025
Me and my husband came here on the last day of our honeymoon for brunch and it was amazing! I told him this may have been the best restaurant we have ate at our entire trip! The food was amazing and I loved all the options the menu had! The atmosphere was beautiful, being that it was so close to the beach and all the cute shops! And our server Anna L was so nice and friendly! 10/10 recommend!
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

MVP - My Village Pub - 5200 Ocean Blvd
American, Pubs, Sports Bar, New American
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood - 149 Avenida Messina
Seafood, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
The Cottage - 153 Avenida Messina
Fine Dining, American, Peruvian, Tapas/Small Plates

Another Broken Egg Cafe

140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
(941) 552-8320