Island Styles

5204 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key

Recent Reviews

Isitgoodbad

Beautiful gelato! Well worth several visits when you’re in Siesta Key! Right on the main street through. Best outside Italy! It’s the real deal! Sorry - no photos as we ate it so quickly!

jillcY2816BO

Always a favorite spot on our visits to Siesta Key. Super friendly staff and the gelato is delicious!

BobP47

There were 3 women working, it wasn't busy and I kept getting the "look" everytime I asked for something. And the prices here are outrageous! $4/per scoop! For 3 of us the cost was $27.35. I visited 5 other ice cream parlors in Bonita, Naples and Fort Myers and Orlando Disney and this was themes expensive for smaller scoops.

Laurel H

Both gelato and sorbet were delicious! The Italian ice was rather soft but tasty. Went there daily! Sometimes twice a day! Lol!

hockeygypsy

I saw the reviews and decided we needed to check this out. This was some of the best gelato I have tasted. The staff was friendly and the selection was expansive. When I first saw my dish I was thinking it wasn't very big. Oh no there is a lot there. It was dense but not overpowering. Total 10 on the yum scale.

Trip2019trip

Craving gelato? This did not disappoint!!! Great vegan options, I had the pistachio, AMAZING!!! Will definitely go back!

emilymX9493SY

Huge variety of flavors, allowed to try some before you buy. Tried their peanut butter and banana, my favorite combo! Super good!!

bkenny63

Like Being Back in Piazza Navona I am over the Luna having found Diane’s gelato shop yesterday while strolling downtown Siesta Key. This is the real Italian deal! Yesterday’s order was vegan peanut butter and chocolate. Today (Yes, I plan on going every day this week with no apologies) I had passion fruit per her recommendation. She is warm, full of information on how to spot quality gelato shops (avoid the ones displaying their wares. They should be in a deep freeze unless being scooped.) and just a woman with great energy. Do not miss this shop. It’s options are the best I’ve ever seen outside of Italy. You have a serious fan in me and our family! When can you open one in Denver?

beachcomber36

Ate here 3 nights in a row after dinner on the main strip in the Village. Its the real deal and all of their gelato is made fresh every day. I had the sugar free coconut and chocolate which both wee phenomenal! My daughter had the pistachio and coffee which were also so creamy and delicious! Every time we visited the owner was present. This was by far our favorite place for a healthy dessert!!!

bruceandmarys

Just the coolest palce! So authentic and soooo friendly! And the very best gelato !!!! Plus a treat of coffee there is out of this world good! Such a warm place!!!! Hard working people for sure!!

Kathy S

After dinner we always walked down to get a gelato to finish. I loved the vanilla and all the other flavors as well.

Zaza382000

Really creamy and tasty! Don't miss it or you will regret! My prefered flavour is a sccop chocolate with a waffle cornet

Christina C

Second year coming here. The gelato is exceptional, even better than most I have had in Italy. Great selection and so flavorful. The chocolate hazelnut cake is divine too. Service is friendly.

Malitz

If you like gelato, it doesn't get better than this --- as good as it is in Italy. It's clear that the owner is part of the operation because everything is proper. Compliments from our family.

Frank D

We were walking around and ran across this place and decided we could use a little something to cool off. I had coconut, my daughter had some sort of Dragon Fruit or something that was very red/purple, and her friend a chocolate. All of us loved what we got.

Load More