Made In Rome Organic Gelato

Im giving this a 1 star because I ordered a chi latte and got a cup with hot water and a chi tea bag for $6.99. The person was nice making it but definitely dissapointed.

The pistachio gelato is not a gelato at all but ice cream. Be aware.

Best gelato I have ever had! The owner was the nicest person, and she gave us a lot of history about how the gelato is made and where she gets her products from (all imported from Italy), so you get a taste of Italy in the US! My family and I could not stay away and got gelato every day while we were down in Florida for vacation! 100000/10 recommend!

This is one of the best gelato’s i have ever had, i have to say this is a game changer for me. I really suggest you should try this place!

I used to like this place, but it seems to have gone downhill.
The gelato used to be more solid, but now is very soft. I think the taste has changed, too. It's not a flavorful as it used to be. Not that it was a strong flavor before, but it used to taste exactly like the description. Not anymore.
A bathroom or sink to wash hands would be nice, but I guess we'll just settle for napkins.

I always have a great experience when I come here for a sweet treat. Their gelato is so good, and the employees are so polite and provide great service. I would give it 6 stars if I could!

Ice cream is good. But not sure if you guys realize that putting skeletons, bats, making a hell is not really friendly. Not to adults or children. When are you guys offering a place to rest, and enjoy, why can’t you offer a restroom. Usually hands are dirty after or when ice cream drop, especially with kids. Prices went up at least double in the last few years, but service not. Hope you see this and a change comes soon. Ice cream and no restrooms, that’s is a joke. No coming in October.

Went twice in one week, the first time we went the gelato was absolutely delicious, creamy and tasted just like gelato in Europe. The second time we went there was a notable difference, less creamy and more icey. I am giving 5 stars because the first day was delicious but they need to work on consistency.

Kiana and Gwen are the best salespeople and gelato scoopers out there!! so nice and helpful

Heavenly ice cream spot! I got the pistachio on a sugar cone. Apparently, it is made with Sicilian pistachios! This ice cream spot is my new fave!

We came here while we were staying in Siesta Key. I looked up dessert places in Siesta Key and this establishment had the best reviews. The reviews don’t lie; I tried the Hazelnut gelato and it was great. Definitely recommend trying this place out.

Spectacular Ice cream!! They are very high quality and rich in flavor. Would go again.

Simply the best Gelato!

Great selection. Vegan options. Busy location. Parking is difficult. There is plenty of outdoor seating.

Fresh, great variety of flavors, great service! We loved it :)