Our book club had a really lovely experience! It was a great place to meet for a group dinner and to chat. The hostess and server were absolutely outstanding. 5 stars!
Jim McGrady
This was easily one of the best Italian dining experiences. I’ve had in quite some time. I don’t mean to sound pretentious, but coming from the Chicagoland area I’ve certainly had my share of good Italian food. This is some of the best ever. Very friendly staff, attentive, kitchen, amazing food.
We started off asking if we could just have a serving of scallops à la cart served as an appetizer. Amanda came back from the kitchen and told us that chef had been working on something that hadn’t been on the menu yet. Scallops wrapped in a crispy prosciutto with a lemony butter sauce. They were excellent. The prosciutto’s crispy saltiness was a perfect compliment to the sweet and tender scallop.
We also had soup. A beefy rich, stuffed pepper and a cream of celery with datil pepper that knocked my socks off.
Both the risotto carbonara and buffalo chicken risotto were creamy and full of flavor. All of this plus some warm bread served with roasted garlic infused olive oil.
I’ll be looking for an excuse to make it back down this way.
Fiona Nash
I would go back for ambiance, service but not for food. Food was very very bland, minimal in flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Patty Murphy
We had my mom's 70th birthday party this past weekend and Jenn & her mom along with the staff was absolutely amazing right from the beginning. The price was right, the food was good, and they were extremely accommodating. I highly recommend using them for your events!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth
First time eating here and everything was wonderful. Food was delicious and service was great! Will definitely be coming back next time in the area.
Gary
The food here is excellent!! Service was a little slow and out of sorts but the overworked waitress/bartender did the best she could.
Rachelle Arthur
Just okay
Lucy A Sullivan
Get the Tomato Jam Jar! Four stars for the rest of the food - 10 stars for the Jam Jar! Service was awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Keith Early
The chicken marsala was excellent. The salad could have been slightly larger than a small side salad, but that may just be me.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina Harford
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Let me tell you… Amici isn’t just dinner — it’s a full-blown Italian love affair, and I’m still emotionally recovering. From the moment we walked in, Amanda greeted us like long-lost cousins who finally made it home for Sunday supper. She’s warm, hilarious, and the kind of server who makes the whole night feel like a family reunion you actually want to attend.
We broke bread (literally) with new friends, and let’s just say: by the end of the night, everyone was on cloud nine and plotting their return. 🥖✨
The food? Stellar. We’re talking Lionel Chicken so tender it could win a singing competition, a lasagna that should honestly come with its own fan club, Alfredo that was creamy perfection, sausage and meatballs that made the table collectively sigh, and scallops over pesto risotto so good I briefly considered proposing to the chef.
And then… the desserts. 🫠 The cannoli cheesecake and limoncello cake were downright swoon-worthy — light, fluffy, with just the right amount of sweetness. The pistachio dusting, chocolate chips, and drizzle on the cannoli made it feel like a celebration in every bite. 🍰🍋
Let’s not overlook the supporting cast: perfectly sweet iced tea, fluffy ricotta that melts on your tongue, the slow roasted garlic swimming in silky olive oil, and bread that should honestly be illegal it’s so good.
👉 Bottom line: Amici isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a must-visit staple. Whether you’re a local or just breezing through St. Augustine, make this your spot. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might just leave with a few new friends.
Well worth it. The food was excellent, and the prices were very reasonable. We had a great server.
Lee Clark
Definitely a place to return to. Great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jack Crow
The food and atmosphere is great! The server was not. When gratuity is 18% and you don’t inform people of the charge, you lose out on my tip of 25%. When ordering food you expect what is on the menu… if you are out of something don’t let us discover it when you bring out the dishes 1.5hrs after arrival. Be upfront and honest.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Peter
Thought we would give a Michi one more try, used to go there years ago, and it was very good, but has gone downhill. Fried Gail mod was rubbery, cappuccino was awful as was the cannoli which was half filled. Will not be returning.
Karah
Food was fantastic. Had the fettuccine Alfredo. It was excellent. It is a little heavy in the heavy cream but the taste was excellent. Spouse had the supreme pizza, it was also incredible. Ordered online with no hassle, picked up 20 mins later. Staff were very friendly and accommodating. 10/10. Would definitely eat here again
Our book club had a really lovely experience! It was a great place to meet for a group dinner and to chat. The hostess and server were absolutely outstanding. 5 stars!
This was easily one of the best Italian dining experiences. I’ve had in quite some time. I don’t mean to sound pretentious, but coming from the Chicagoland area I’ve certainly had my share of good Italian food. This is some of the best ever. Very friendly staff, attentive, kitchen, amazing food. We started off asking if we could just have a serving of scallops à la cart served as an appetizer. Amanda came back from the kitchen and told us that chef had been working on something that hadn’t been on the menu yet. Scallops wrapped in a crispy prosciutto with a lemony butter sauce. They were excellent. The prosciutto’s crispy saltiness was a perfect compliment to the sweet and tender scallop. We also had soup. A beefy rich, stuffed pepper and a cream of celery with datil pepper that knocked my socks off. Both the risotto carbonara and buffalo chicken risotto were creamy and full of flavor. All of this plus some warm bread served with roasted garlic infused olive oil. I’ll be looking for an excuse to make it back down this way.
I would go back for ambiance, service but not for food. Food was very very bland, minimal in flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
We had my mom's 70th birthday party this past weekend and Jenn & her mom along with the staff was absolutely amazing right from the beginning. The price was right, the food was good, and they were extremely accommodating. I highly recommend using them for your events!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time eating here and everything was wonderful. Food was delicious and service was great! Will definitely be coming back next time in the area.
The food here is excellent!! Service was a little slow and out of sorts but the overworked waitress/bartender did the best she could.
Just okay
Get the Tomato Jam Jar! Four stars for the rest of the food - 10 stars for the Jam Jar! Service was awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The chicken marsala was excellent.
The salad could have been slightly larger than a small side salad, but that may just be me.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Let me tell you… Amici isn’t just dinner — it’s a full-blown Italian love affair, and I’m still emotionally recovering. From the moment we walked in, Amanda greeted us like long-lost cousins who finally made it home for Sunday supper. She’s warm, hilarious, and the kind of server who makes the whole night feel like a family reunion you actually want to attend.
We broke bread (literally) with new friends, and let’s just say: by the end of the night, everyone was on cloud nine and plotting their return. 🥖✨
The food? Stellar. We’re talking Lionel Chicken so tender it could win a singing competition, a lasagna that should honestly come with its own fan club, Alfredo that was creamy perfection, sausage and meatballs that made the table collectively sigh, and scallops over pesto risotto so good I briefly considered proposing to the chef.
And then… the desserts. 🫠
The cannoli cheesecake and limoncello cake were downright swoon-worthy — light, fluffy, with just the right amount of sweetness. The pistachio dusting, chocolate chips, and drizzle on the cannoli made it feel like a celebration in every bite. 🍰🍋
Let’s not overlook the supporting cast: perfectly sweet iced tea, fluffy ricotta that melts on your tongue, the slow roasted garlic swimming in silky olive oil, and bread that should honestly be illegal it’s so good.
👉 Bottom line: Amici isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a must-visit staple. Whether you’re a local or just breezing through St. Augustine, make this your spot. Your taste buds will thank you, and you might just leave with a few new friends.
#eatthisnow #nomnomstaugi #antasiaislandtreasure #thefixnorthflorida #904 #staugieats
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Well worth it. The food was excellent, and the prices were very reasonable. We had a great server.
Definitely a place to return to. Great food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and atmosphere is great! The server was not. When gratuity is 18% and you don’t inform people of the charge, you lose out on my tip of 25%. When ordering food you expect what is on the menu… if you are out of something don’t let us discover it when you bring out the dishes 1.5hrs after arrival. Be upfront and honest.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Thought we would give a Michi one more try, used to go there years ago, and it was very good, but has gone downhill. Fried Gail mod was rubbery, cappuccino was awful as was the cannoli which was half filled. Will not be returning.
Food was fantastic. Had the fettuccine Alfredo. It was excellent. It is a little heavy in the heavy cream but the taste was excellent. Spouse had the supreme pizza, it was also incredible. Ordered online with no hassle, picked up 20 mins later. Staff were very friendly and accommodating. 10/10. Would definitely eat here again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...