Ann O'Malley's

23 Orange St, St. Augustine
(904) 825-4040

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Caden Goyette

This place is complete dog brang my families food after an hour and food was mediocre

Brad Tillman

I didn't have anything to drink..... because I gave them my card to open a tab and they never brought me anything. Go elsewhere....

Lisa Darby

Stopped in for drinks and an appetizer after walking and touring the area. Server was friendly but stretched thin so we had one cider apiece when we would have ordered another round. Limited menu with only two appetizer options. We had the nachos.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

David Kinney

Slow service, got a hot shoe leather sandwich on toast, thought sure it was microwaved. Pasta salad was a soup of vinegrette liquid with some noodles.
Disgusting. Don't bother.

Dona Corbett

We enjoyed an overall pleasant experience, highlighted by attentive service and delicious food. The staff members were extremely polite and attentive. The atmosphere was vibrant, with patrons around us visibly enjoying their meals and drinks and the overall ambiance of the restaurant.

Although our food took a bit longer to arrive than expected (an hour), this seems to be an isolated incident, as other reviews were so positive. In light of the excellent quality of the food we received, particularly the Reuben sandwich, the wait was worthwhile. The sandwich was exceptional, easily one of the best I've had.

One minor point to note was the noticeable scent of cleaner, which may not bother most guests but was quite strong for someone sensitive to smells. However, this also indicates the restaurant’s commitment to cleanliness, which is ultimately reassuring.

It is definitely a place worth visiting.

Recommended dishes: Reuben

Karen Paulley-Camm

Ventured in after fighting all the crowds in town. Two Floridians that came to area to Airbnb for a sister's bday weekend. We just wanted a beer and glass of wine and it took us a lot to find a place we could get in. Thought some light food would be good but bartender told the kitchen was closed as did a fat man at the bar. Bartender threw me a bag of chips "on the house" and told me who I could complain to about food not bring served after 9. I didn't ask or want the info to complain. I took my wine and sisters beer and we listened to the band and were content. In leaving someone shouted good riddance." Pretty sure it was the fat, male patron. Just want to say that was really rude and not warranted.

Rylie Bevill Barnes

Very neat spot. Cool, local vibe. I’ve had much better reubens before, our party ordered three and all three were good, not great. Our kids gobbled up the grilled cheese with avocado & bacon.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kelly Bacigalupo

The absolute best sandwiches I've had! So glad we stopped.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich

Yevette Peveler

Tori is amazing - and her story is one of strength and courage. Be sure to visit so you can talk to her and feel inspired???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Tomlin

A very fun place to go! We enjoyed our server and the beers they carry. Try the Conquistador sandwich, it's outstanding!

Patrick cotroneo

We ate lunch there yesterday. Great food, great service and a very nice unique atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Marty

Dean Goodenough

Neat place, nice bartender &

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nachos

Marcia Palmer

Find John on a Sat or Sun. Thank you for the great 'after concert' advice man. We had a blast at Sarbez, and the grilled cheese was da bomb. Ann O'Malley is a hoot. Awesome entertainment, great beer, great atmosphere. Positively make it an adult bevie stop on your St A visit. We'll see ya'll soon.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Sri Lakshmi Sara

I was walking by this place and had to stop by because of the amazing smell.
Oh god the food was absolutely amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ron Fort

Have been going here for many years. The food is always so good and the drinks are great. Sometimes live bands and other night's trivia or something to keep you going. Great place and Irish pub.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nice Beer Selection, Soup, Reuben, Sandwich

Loading...