Great food. Sauce is excellent.. Got the Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner with garlic bread and added of course some cheese cake to take out .Will return when down from New York again
Chris Snow
Great food and service. We shared the pepperoni and sausage Stromboli. Portions were huge. The garlic bits were top notch.
Ordered baked pasta dishes. One lasagna and one spaghetti and meat sauce. Was good, hot and fresh. Was not “OMheck this is the best pasta ever” good but it was flavorful and tasty enough I would eat there again. Garlic knots were very soft, good and baked fresh. A few outdoor dining tables. I’d recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Mike R
Simply excellent NY cheese pizza, thin, crisp crust, juicy with a very tasty tomato sauce. Just the right amount of cheese and the crust edge is crunchy, lightly salty. Just a great 18" large pie at $16 all in, what a deal too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Aimee
We had a mixup and thought we were ordering from a different place next door to us so we had to find and drive a bit far to retrieve our pizza. Well sometimes the universe knows better and we had an amazing deluxe pizza. It was gone before I could get a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Bahama Bud
Best place for a pizza in Saint Augustine, bar none! Great atmosphere and owner is a king among men. Family run and you will be treated like family. Five***** across the board!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Bryan Goethe
Not your regular pizza spot. Good wings, great pizza. The crust...amazing. Plenty of toppings. A small is about the size of Domino's medium! Good customer service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Great Pizza
Dennis Hall
My wife and I are visiting St Augustine for Thanksgiving week. I decided to order pizza for Wednesday night so we would have leftovers for Thursday night.After reading some reviews from several pizza restaurants I called and ordered a large half cheese and half pepperoni pizza.My wife and I are very disappointed in the pizza, we are foodies and enjoy a good pizza but this wasn’t it.There wasn’t any real flavor to the sauce or the pizza dough. I wish we had the time to try our other pizza locations around St Augustine but heading home on Friday.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Mn M
Pizza was delicious. The spaghetti wasn't the best but tasted okay overall. We'll definitely come back for the pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Meatballs Baked Spaghetti, Garlic Knots, Great Pizza
This place is absolutely disgusting! No inside seating! They had a few tables outside in front of the business, tho. The pizza I ordered tasted like it had chef-boy-r Dee pizza sauce on it. My husband said his calzone wasn't much better. The customer service was quite lacking as the register operator literally stood there at the counter doing anything else except waiting on us (and we were the only patrons at that moment.) The canned beverages had dirt/dust on them INSIDE the cooler. Was NOT AT ALL a good experience.
Robert Fales
Love the place been eating there. A long time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe L.
Did pick up for 3 Pies. Regular, Veggie and White. They all were good. Not something I would say "wow I want to order that again!" But it's the closest to my house so we tried it being we are new here. You won't be disappointed, it's a solid pizza. Just not what I'm used to coming from NJ, but in all fairness to them and about 3 other places I've tried for pizza none of them are. I think when you come from a place where pizza is really good, say NY or NJ then you have to have pizza for a quick fill in meal and not expect it to be something you're going to order for dinner and love it. So far since we've been here the past two months I can say the best food I've had is at home. Time to take a trip to NJ!
Michael Bates
Wish I could give them Zero, in this day and age there is no excuse for not having an online menu, not just a cellphone shot of the inhouse menu that is unreadable
AGUSTIN SAENZ
As a Native of New York City born and raised and of course pizza was part of my life as so many New Yorkers so i got lucky and run into Anthony pizzeria New York Style so i went in asked if they sell pizza by the slice Anthony the owner said yes and there's a lunch special 2 slice and a fountain drink i said kool so i started asking him questions about how does New York Pizza taste different than the others Anthony answered the question correctly so i told that i would let him know if it tasted like New York Pizza well my friends in Florida the pizza tasted so good just like New York Pizza and as we know us New Yorkers we also eat our pizza cold so in the course of the day I did eat it while it was cold and let me tell you this is the the best NEW YORK PIZZA you all going to run to here in Florida I highly recommend ANTHONY PIZZA NEW STYLE y'all will love it. Thank you Anthony from Agustin United States Navy RetiredP.s. see you soon
Trying for the first time !
Great food. Sauce is excellent.. Got the Eggplant Parmigiana Dinner with garlic bread and added of course some cheese cake to take out .Will return when down from New York again
Great food and service. We shared the pepperoni and sausage Stromboli. Portions were huge. The garlic bits were top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni & Sausage, Garlic Knots
Ordered baked pasta dishes. One lasagna and one spaghetti and meat sauce. Was good, hot and fresh. Was not “OMheck this is the best pasta ever” good but it was flavorful and tasty enough I would eat there again. Garlic knots were very soft, good and baked fresh. A few outdoor dining tables. I’d recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Simply excellent NY cheese pizza, thin, crisp crust, juicy with a very tasty tomato sauce. Just the right amount of cheese and the crust edge is crunchy, lightly salty. Just a great 18" large pie at $16 all in, what a deal too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
We had a mixup and thought we were ordering from a different place next door to us so we had to find and drive a bit far to retrieve our pizza. Well sometimes the universe knows better and we had an amazing deluxe pizza. It was gone before I could get a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Best place for a pizza in Saint Augustine, bar none! Great atmosphere and owner is a king among men. Family run and you will be treated like family. Five***** across the board!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Not your regular pizza spot. Good wings, great pizza. The crust...amazing. Plenty of toppings. A small is about the size of Domino's medium! Good customer service.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Great Pizza
My wife and I are visiting St Augustine for Thanksgiving week. I decided to order pizza for Wednesday night so we would have leftovers for Thursday night.After reading some reviews from several pizza restaurants I called and ordered a large half cheese and half pepperoni pizza.My wife and I are very disappointed in the pizza, we are foodies and enjoy a good pizza but this wasn’t it.There wasn’t any real flavor to the sauce or the pizza dough. I wish we had the time to try our other pizza locations around St Augustine but heading home on Friday.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Pizza was delicious. The spaghetti wasn't the best but tasted okay overall. We'll definitely come back for the pizza ? ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Meatballs Baked Spaghetti, Garlic Knots, Great Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is absolutely disgusting! No inside seating! They had a few tables outside in front of the business, tho. The pizza I ordered tasted like it had chef-boy-r Dee pizza sauce on it. My husband said his calzone wasn't much better. The customer service was quite lacking as the register operator literally stood there at the counter doing anything else except waiting on us (and we were the only patrons at that moment.) The canned beverages had dirt/dust on them INSIDE the cooler. Was NOT AT ALL a good experience.
Love the place been eating there. A long time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Did pick up for 3 Pies. Regular, Veggie and White. They all were good. Not something I would say "wow I want to order that again!" But it's the closest to my house so we tried it being we are new here. You won't be disappointed, it's a solid pizza. Just not what I'm used to coming from NJ, but in all fairness to them and about 3 other places I've tried for pizza none of them are. I think when you come from a place where pizza is really good, say NY or NJ then you have to have pizza for a quick fill in meal and not expect it to be something you're going to order for dinner and love it. So far since we've been here the past two months I can say the best food I've had is at home. Time to take a trip to NJ!
Wish I could give them Zero, in this day and age there is no excuse for not having an online menu, not just a cellphone shot of the inhouse menu that is unreadable
As a Native of New York City born and raised and of course pizza was part of my life as so many New Yorkers so i got lucky and run into Anthony pizzeria New York Style so i went in asked if they sell pizza by the slice Anthony the owner said yes and there's a lunch special 2 slice and a fountain drink i said kool so i started asking him questions about how does New York Pizza taste different than the others Anthony answered the question correctly so i told that i would let him know if it tasted like New York Pizza well my friends in Florida the pizza tasted so good just like New York Pizza and as we know us New Yorkers we also eat our pizza cold so in the course of the day I did eat it while it was cold and let me tell you this is the the best NEW YORK PIZZA you all going to run to here in Florida I highly recommend ANTHONY PIZZA NEW STYLE y'all will love it. Thank you Anthony from Agustin United States Navy RetiredP.s. see you soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5