Athena Restaurant

14 Cathedral Pl, St. Augustine
(904) 823-9076

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Lindsay Walker

Best hummus and pita I’ve had. Everything was really good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Troy Webber

Tasted like a lot of pre-made food straight from Sysco or some other low quality food distributor. Grape leaves were hard, had a chalky interior, and tasted canned. Gyro meat was undercooked and seemed to come from a gyro cone made in a far away factory. Salad was warm. Dressing was typical mass-produced nonsense made with soybean or canola oil. Not a good experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Clark Brown

We went to the restaurant twice this week. Friday, and Sunday. Friday it wasn't open at 11:00, so we went to another restaurant. We went by today, Sunday at 11:10, and they weren't open. I called, and they said 15 minutes. Twenty minutes later, still not open. We were very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Marta 20

I’m not recommending this place!The service was absolutely terrible, and our server, Chloe, was the main reason. She was rude, inattentive, and unprofessional from the start. Instead of coming to take my order, she made me shout it across the table.
She forgot our drinks entirely. When it came time for the bill, she again didn’t bother to come over — I had to stand up and hand it to her myself.
We asked to split a dish (which has a $3 fee), but she didn’t explain anything, just brought an extra plate and still charged us the $3 without clarification. Overall, her behavior was careless and awkward, and she clearly didn’t care about providing proper service…later I noticed that an automatic 18% gratuity was already included, which likely explains why she put in zero effort. Easily one of the worst servers I’ve ever had…bc of her I was already upset probably that’s why food was not the best for this money and atmosphere,but it’s another story,I don’t want tell anything about this just want to pay attention management about this woman who is terrible server!Ithank you

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

nina zamani

I tried this restaurant two times and every time was amazing.
10 out of 10❤️

Mario Zendeli

If you hungry and everything else is busy then go but if you have options then avoid this place.
$17 gyro that doesn’t even bring fries, those were $4 extra.
The chicken souvlaki was actually boiled chicken with spices.
Fries looked to have been cooked with old oil.
Overall a very subpar experience for the type of food that easy to cook and homie.
Ohhh also 3% surcharge for credit card use? Are you serious? With these prices you have to charge a surcharge?
Crazy

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Milena Vozrud

I went to this place in saint Agustin and we had a server named Chloe and she forgot our drinks for like 45 minutes then I had to go ask for where my drinks are and she said she forgot and even after that it took 15 minutes for her to pour 2 Pepsis and one lemonade FIFTEEN MINUTES the food over all was ok they did not give us forks or spoons did not give us water and it smelled so bad like raw meat everywhere and there was like 10 other people and we stayed there for 2HOURS I do not recommend 😕

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Eduardo Jaramillo

extremely rude waitress and host

M K

The food itself wasn’t bad. However, our food didn’t come out until much later, when other tables that arrived after us were already finishing their meals. When you’re not part of the majority, the unfortunate part is that in situations like this, you’re left wondering whether it might be racism.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Zulma Gutierrez Mesa

Service above and beyond. I wish I have 10 stars. The food is also great. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

christy fletcher

The customer service was very kind and friendly. Quick service and the food was great. We enjoyed the atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Meagan Oas

A group of 6 of us attempted to eat here Saturday night (12/13) the hostess was very nice and stated we could do the booth at the very front and put a chair at the end, then we wouldn’t be in anyone’s way. There were several people leaving with strollers so my friend and I sat down at the booth so we could be out of the way. The gentleman came over and apologized for the dirty table and we explained we were just trying to stay out of everyone’s way and he was super appreciative. Cleaned the table and we thanked him. Then came another girl, who I assumed was supposed to be our waiter. She was incredibly rude telling us we can’t just sit at a table. I explained the situation and again stated we were just trying to stay out of the way. She then began to tell me we could have gone outside, there’s other people around that are waiting. Mind you, those other people came in well after us. And again, we had been given that table already! Our entire party was seated at the table where we were then ignored. No menus. No hello. Nothing. The same girl that was rude to us, continued to sweep the floor and just look at us. We waited for approximately 5 minutes while we were just stared at and finally left. Such a disappointment.

Service: 1

Chris Cauley (ChrisC)

The gyros are delicious and everyone was so nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen

Super waitress. Food good

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Mikaela Rae

Absolutely love it here! The atmosphere is so relaxing and the food is always delicious! You have to try the Saganaki!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...