Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company

Everything we tried was amazing would highly recommend if you like cheesecake!!

fabulous I highly recommend

My mom got the 3 cheesecake tasting and was glowing, my dad got the 4 in double chocolate cheesecake and ended up eating the entire thing, looked like it was really kinda painful so maybe share it like they recommend. Free iced tea and pineapple upon arrival. Small rooms, dark wood and lighting, welcoming nonjudgmental host. Couldn’t be more delightful or beautiful. 7 stars for this place

My favorite place in all of St. Augustine!! Incredible ambiance…delicious and creative cheesecakes & wines. Impeccable service. I especially loved coming here during Christmas time.

Grea:
Wine
Cheese cakes
Service

I wonderful experience

Omg! Hands down the best cheesecake we have ever had ...wow!!! Aaamazzzzing..lol. Definitely making plans to revisit again soon.

My family and I came multiple times during our trip to Saint Augustine. The environment was fantastic. The decor and service was very peaceful.

The cheesecakes were great too. Much better than the cheesecake factory. The prices were fair. The sample platter let's you try three flavors for $9.

My only criticism is that they were out of stock on many flavors.

What a unique and delightful experience. I'm not even a huge cheesecake fan, but everything was excellent! I'll be back!

The food was awesome, and the folks who were seating and serving us were super friendly! We tried the cheesecake sampler, and they paired wines with each cheesecake for us. Highly recommend!

It's not what it used to be. We used to LOVE coming here for the service and spoiling desserts. Now, you have to get through a very rude and condescending gate keeper that gives you the riot act. It's ridiculous and awkward. We used to refer people to go, but they all encountered a similar situation. It's a turn off! What a shame!

Love this place! This is a MUST go to when you are here. The cheesecake is amazing. Make sure you make a reservation if you are wanting to do the cheesecake flight experience.

Bar Harbor Cheesecake Company in downtown St. Augustine is a charming spot worth checking out! The cheesecake flights were definitely the highlight—delicious, creative, and a fun way to sample several flavors. Prices were very reasonable, especially considering the quality and portion sizes. The charcuterie board was just okay—not bad, but not the most memorable one I’ve had, especially for the price. The service was great, and they really made you feel like home as well! The wine flight was enjoyable, though not particularly standout. One of my favorite things here is definitely the refreshing and yummy complimentary sweet tea that they provided! They also have a security deposit of $9 for a walk in but their website says they accept reservations as well with no cost. Overall, a great place for a sweet treat and a relaxing stop while exploring downtown.

Not happy with new policy of 9 per person for reservation. Food is good enough that you don't need it.
Also place was completely empty. They only used the two tables side by side which really killed the ambience of a date. It was a few hours before closing and a different person waited and each table. They don't really seem to care about the customer's. Just my opinion.
The cheesecake is to die for, but probably won't come back again

Decent cheesecake, but the price you pay for the size cheesecake you get is absurd. Clearly they were taking the opportunity to take advantage of tourists. But this local won’t fall for it twice. Hoping others don’t either until they lower prices.

I've been to the locations in St. Augustine & Bar Harbor. They have excellent cheesecake!