Custom Cakes in St. Augustine, FL

Heavenly Cheesecakes & Bakery Bakery • $$
3874 N Ponce De Leon Blvd, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake

“Best bakery in St Augustine. My family found this place on a drive one day and we continue to visit as often as we can. My children love the chocolate chip cookies. The turnovers are incredible and of course the cheesecake is fantastic. If you need another reason to try this place my little two year old now recognizes the parking lot points and says yum :)“

5 Superb31 Reviews
Sweet City Cupcakes Cupcakes • $
233 W King St # A, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Baked Gingerbread Cookies
Cupcakes and a 4 Inch Cake
Various Cupcakes
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“We celebrated my birthday in Vilano and my husband chose this bakery for my cake. He couldn’t have chosen a more perfect place!! Not only was the cake everything I wanted and more!!!! But it was beyond delicious!!!! Thank you Dana for making my birthday so special 😊“

4.9 Superb40 Reviews
Simple Sugars Organic Bakery Bakery •
370 Heritage Landing Pkwy, St. Augustine

“I can not recommend this bakery highly enough! We purchased a birthday cake. The cakes decoration was breathtaking! The first question of us who enjoyed it and everyone to whom we showed pictures of it was “does it taste as good as it looks?” The answer: even better!!! Thanks for making an important birthday celebration extra special!“

5 Superb5 Reviews
Luli's Cupcakes Bakery • $
82 San Marco Ave, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Birthday Cake
Cannoli Cake

“Looking for a charming spot in downtown St. Augustine? LuLi’s Cupcakes has it all—gourmet cupcakes, rich coffee, specialty drinks, and light breakfast options. With flavors like Cookies and Cream, Cannoli, Red Velvet, and even gluten-free treats, there’s something for everyone. Perfect for families or a cute date, LuLi’s combines a warm, welcoming vibe with irresistible flavors. Whether you’re savoring a Peanut Butter cupcake or enjoying a Chai latte, it’s a delightful way to start or end your day. Don’t miss this sweet gem!“

4.1 Good71 Reviews
Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Shop • $
128 St George St, St. Augustine

Customers` Favorites

Custom Milkshake 20oz
Cups & Cones
Waffle Cones

“Free ice cream my name was Eric need I say more. I will it was delicious thanks!“

3.5 Good46 Reviews