My wife and I tried the strawberry cheesecake the best we have had in a long time. I’m a baker by trade and I take my hat off to the baker. ??
Steven Caesar
Tiny little bakery that packs in a huge amount of tasteGreat pastries and prices
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michele P.
This is THE best cheesecake I have ever eaten. Better than Juniors, or any other NY cheesecake, baked or otherwise; even better than my grandma's Italian ricotta cheesecake. So having said that -- obviously there are different types! We all have our favorites. I much prefer my own homemade over my bff's - whose cheesecake tastes like a refrigerator cheesecake, but she claims she makes the best. Don't tell her I said hers is so-so. And when it comes to turn-off-the-oven-and-leave-it for two more hours Italian ricotta six eggs grandma Dearie's, well mine is now the best - my Dad agreed. Grated lemon, ricotta, cream cheese and mascarpone, and dash of almond extract- Zwieback for the hint of a crust- a 4 generation recipe from Naples, adapted by my dad, perfected by moi. But for a creamy, dreamy taste of - well, heaven on earth, nobody does cheesecake like Heavenly!!! I will never bake another! My friend Flossy and I could easily sit down with 2 forks and polish one off in a single sitting. The cakes are pricey, but those who bake using prime ingredients will understand. We tried the raspberry but both of us prefer plain- nothing but cheesecake. They do sell other flavors if you prefer. So good, so dreamy, so creamy, so Heavenly!!! PS they also sell cookies, scones, breads, frozen cheesecakes on a stick coated in chocolate & now individual sizes! It's a tiny shop tucked into a corner of the produce shop on US1 near Fort Mose in the same lot as Kyle's Seafood, so a great shopping stop! Great guys with a great sense of humor.
Ryan H.
We stumbled upon this place 1 day driving home from st augustine. Stopped in and bought a strawberry 6 in. It was delish. Went back before Xmas eve and he was sold out. Seems everyone was smart and pre ordered . So I pre ordered for new years eve . I must say I did have huge sticker shock when it cost me 70 for a 9 inch key lime and a 6 inch white chocolate. They were ready when I arrived on Saturday 12/30. Saved for NYE. They were fantastic. The white chocolate was a little thick but im not sure what I was expecting when I ordered it . Shared with my neighbors they all loved the key lime. He also makes amazing turnovers .
Linda K.
The cheesecake is truly Heavenly! The store is extremely small but worth the trouble! Staff was efficient.
Janet Steiner
The cheesecakes are so yummy, and so many varieties . All are delicious? And the service is awesome! The only place I ever buy them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake
Hugh Jensen
Best cheesecake I've had since I left NYC...34 yrs ago the other baked goodies are also top notch especially the turnovers and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andrew O'Connell
Walter is so polite and help! The food is amazing and the prices make sense unlike so many of the newer bakeries in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rasa Chiras
I love this place! The cheesecakes are great! I love their guava and cheese turnovers! My husband loves their large chocolate chip cookies. He also recently started making sourdough bread which is amazing! Be sure to go now!
Beth B.
The name is no lie! Every bite is a little slice of heaven! You've never tried cheesecake like this. I struggled to decide between cherry, raspberry and heath bar - what a challenge! Then was informed I just missed the fresh peach cheesecake that was heading to Georgia for a competition! Sorry to miss out on that but please let us know if it wins! (As it should). Finally settled on the cherry and it was spectacular- with little pieces of sweet cherries mixed into the cake. Best of all, it's so delightful and satisfying you won't tempted to eat the whole thing at once! So go ahead and splurge with a piece of heaven.
Yummy! It was a little hard to find but so worth it! The cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies were fresh and delicious.
Crystal Smith
Hands down the best cheesecake, EVER!!!! Actually, I don't think I've had anything bad from Heavenly Cheesecake.
Dorothy Miller
Absolutely delicious cheesecake! Better than mine!
Kathryn Finley
Heavenly is a great description for the yummy cheesecake, chocolate chunk cookies and turnovers! We are camping near St. Augustine and these were perfect for dinner desserts, beach sunrise treats, etc.Can’t wait to try more items!
Tracey Woods
Oh my goodness!!! The best bakery in the free world. The scones (we can then fruity biscuits in our house) are moist and full of flavor. The snickerdoodle cookies are soft and delicious, I didn't think I liked snickerdoodle, but I like their cookies. The bakers are so kind and genuine. What a treasure.
My wife and I tried the strawberry cheesecake the best we have had in a long time. I’m a baker by trade and I take my hat off to the baker. ??
Tiny little bakery that packs in a huge amount of tasteGreat pastries and prices
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is THE best cheesecake I have ever eaten. Better than Juniors, or any other NY cheesecake, baked or otherwise; even better than my grandma's Italian ricotta cheesecake. So having said that -- obviously there are different types! We all have our favorites. I much prefer my own homemade over my bff's - whose cheesecake tastes like a refrigerator cheesecake, but she claims she makes the best. Don't tell her I said hers is so-so. And when it comes to turn-off-the-oven-and-leave-it for two more hours Italian ricotta six eggs grandma Dearie's, well mine is now the best - my Dad agreed. Grated lemon, ricotta, cream cheese and mascarpone, and dash of almond extract- Zwieback for the hint of a crust- a 4 generation recipe from Naples, adapted by my dad, perfected by moi. But for a creamy, dreamy taste of - well, heaven on earth, nobody does cheesecake like Heavenly!!! I will never bake another! My friend Flossy and I could easily sit down with 2 forks and polish one off in a single sitting. The cakes are pricey, but those who bake using prime ingredients will understand. We tried the raspberry but both of us prefer plain- nothing but cheesecake. They do sell other flavors if you prefer. So good, so dreamy, so creamy, so Heavenly!!! PS they also sell cookies, scones, breads, frozen cheesecakes on a stick coated in chocolate & now individual sizes! It's a tiny shop tucked into a corner of the produce shop on US1 near Fort Mose in the same lot as Kyle's Seafood, so a great shopping stop! Great guys with a great sense of humor.
We stumbled upon this place 1 day driving home from st augustine. Stopped in and bought a strawberry 6 in. It was delish. Went back before Xmas eve and he was sold out. Seems everyone was smart and pre ordered . So I pre ordered for new years eve . I must say I did have huge sticker shock when it cost me 70 for a 9 inch key lime and a 6 inch white chocolate. They were ready when I arrived on Saturday 12/30. Saved for NYE. They were fantastic. The white chocolate was a little thick but im not sure what I was expecting when I ordered it . Shared with my neighbors they all loved the key lime. He also makes amazing turnovers .
The cheesecake is truly Heavenly! The store is extremely small but worth the trouble! Staff was efficient.
The cheesecakes are so yummy, and so many varieties . All are delicious? And the service is awesome! The only place I ever buy them.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Strawberry Cheesecake
Best cheesecake I've had since I left NYC...34 yrs ago the other baked goodies are also top notch especially the turnovers and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walter is so polite and help! The food is amazing and the prices make sense unlike so many of the newer bakeries in town.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love this place! The cheesecakes are great! I love their guava and cheese turnovers! My husband loves their large chocolate chip cookies. He also recently started making sourdough bread which is amazing! Be sure to go now!
The name is no lie! Every bite is a little slice of heaven! You've never tried cheesecake like this. I struggled to decide between cherry, raspberry and heath bar - what a challenge! Then was informed I just missed the fresh peach cheesecake that was heading to Georgia for a competition! Sorry to miss out on that but please let us know if it wins! (As it should). Finally settled on the cherry and it was spectacular- with little pieces of sweet cherries mixed into the cake. Best of all, it's so delightful and satisfying you won't tempted to eat the whole thing at once! So go ahead and splurge with a piece of heaven.
Restaurantji Recommends
Yummy! It was a little hard to find but so worth it! The cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies were fresh and delicious.
Hands down the best cheesecake, EVER!!!! Actually, I don't think I've had anything bad from Heavenly Cheesecake.
Absolutely delicious cheesecake! Better than mine!
Heavenly is a great description for the yummy cheesecake, chocolate chunk cookies and turnovers! We are camping near St. Augustine and these were perfect for dinner desserts, beach sunrise treats, etc.Can’t wait to try more items!
Oh my goodness!!! The best bakery in the free world. The scones (we can then fruity biscuits in our house) are moist and full of flavor. The snickerdoodle cookies are soft and delicious, I didn't think I liked snickerdoodle, but I like their cookies. The bakers are so kind and genuine. What a treasure.