Little Casa Maya

197 Blackford Way, St. Augustine
(904) 295-8240

Recent Reviews

Teri L.

Awful. How can you make mess up guacamole??? they made it soooo salty, my tongue was shot for two days. Not exaggerating at all. Not only was the guacamole salty but the quesadilla was salty as well. ‍‍‍ There will be no second chance here

Tiffany P.

I gave this place a second try. It is pretty over priced for what it is and the service is whatever. I decided to call in an order for pick up. I ordered the cevichè which was so salty I could barley eat it. I also ordered the Yucatán salad (half size) and added shrimp. I saw that this salad had mango, I love mango so I ordered it to give it a try. The salad came in a small to go box and there's was no mango. The description also stated that they had a house dressing. I didn't get the dressing for my salad. I spend over $20 and I'm still hungry. I am never going to this place again.

Dan Sche

Excellent Breakfast. Food was fresh and prepared to order. Staff was quick and friendly. Pricing was very reasonable.

Logan Williams

If you're looking for tasty authentic tacos, then go anywhere else! Taco Bell taste better coming out then the tacos I got from little casa maya. Paid $15 for three tacos that taste like they were made from styrofoam.

Debbie Dunaway

Interesting menu. Loved the crepes. Wish they had margaritas.

Mister Wedding

I got the best Fajitas the other day and I will definitely be going back for Banana Crepes

Susan Spsracello

The people are friendly, the sandwich was excellent ,named Huinic.

Karen D.

Never again!! I ordered the Mahi tacos...what a joke!! My 3 tacos for 15.95 consisted of soft shell, ONE piece of flat romaine lettuce, one small strip of mahi that was half the length of the shell, chipotle mayo tasted like PLAIN mayo, ONE tiny container of pico (enough for one taco), NO cheese. Don't waste your time!!

Jennifer C.

Exceptional flavor. I feel like I visit Merida every time I eat here.

Andres Vega

Superb traditional style Mexican food!

Bryan Walter

I really wish I could rate this place higher. I have been here about 6 times since they have opened and all 6 times I have been the only customer when I walked in ( dine in and take out). All 6 times my order has been incorrect after specially explaining that prior it was wrong and emphasized what I wanted. For instance , the steak tacos I have asked for toppings on the side. On one occasion this was ignored. Another time all toppings where just not provided . I have asked for every to go order to please make sure sour cream was provided on side . All attempts have failed .

Carol Rovinsky

A customer of Casa Maya downtown, I was excited to try their smaller version on US1 South of town. It was EXCELLENT !!

Debra Willis

Delicious fresh food and friendly staff.

E Lucas

AhitExceptional food with relatively low prices. Chips are extra, but the food is so awesomely prepared, you likely won't mind the extra charge if you want them. I had take out, and went with the fahitas, and chose shrimp as my protein. Enough food for six, spilling-out-the-sides small, fresh tortillas, but I was only given three tortillas. The rest will be eaten with the rice and beans that came with the entree. Sides of sour cream and guac came with it also. $17.95 or there abouts. So cheap for the amount you receive (not counting the tortillas).

Joe Freeman

Well I went there about a month ago at 2 pm....2PM on a Saturday. They were just closing even though their hours clearly stated they would be open til 9 PM. I figured no problem I'll try another day. Last Saturday I went by at 8:20 pm... a full 40 minutes before their listed closing time of 9 PM. The 2 young ladies looked at me as if I were interrupting their night and they turned me away AGAIN. Will not make the same mistake again. Advise to management....fire your staff they are obvious too lazy to work. Why post business hours if you don't abide by them????? I'll happily take my hard earned money elsewhere. This joint will surely shut down in less than a year.

Load More