Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine
100 St George St # J, St. Augustine
(904) 792-9860
Recent Reviews
Sort by
The server kindly informed me that they do not wash ice-cream scoops between different selections so dairy ice-cream is contaminated with the few nondairy flavors. We much prefer Cold Cow or Lalas ice-cream.
Em at Hypolita Mayday is awesome!! Friendly, sweet and welcoming! Will be back!
Our family has been visiting Mayday every day for the past two weeks, and we simply cannot get enough of their amazing ice cream! The flavors are absolutely delicious, and the quality is top-notch. But what truly sets this place apart is the incredible staff. They are always very friendly and welcoming.
A special shoutout to Phoenix – you are truly extraordinary! You always go above and beyond to help our family, making each visit even more special. Your kindness, energy, and attention to detail never go unnoticed, and we appreciate you so much!
If you're looking for a place with not just great ice cream but also an outstanding team, Mayday is the place to go!
We still have another week in St. Augustine and we will definitely keep coming back!
A must visit stop! Swing in and see Phoenix and try the triple vanilla. It's the best!
Sylvia was amazing! The ice cream was equally wonderful. Loved unlimited samples.
Bella our ice cream server was friendly and pleasant. She recognized us from the last time we had visited, lol the day before.
The triple vanilla ice cream was exceptional!
Well, all the flavors we have tried have been outstanding!
Caleb is the best!
Palmer was the best! Such great ice cream and staff! Make sure you try the sprinkles and cinnamon waffle cone :)
Palmer was awesome! Please bring the dirty chai back! Such great ice cream it was so good I forgot to take a picture until the end . 😊
The ice cream was incredible. Caleb even helped me buy a shop shirt to add to my collection. We will definitely tell our friends about Mayday Ice Cream. Thanks Caleb.
Restaurantji Recommends
such a cute place with delicious ice cream! kate was great!
Palmer was so helpful!!! And patient
Vawa, (the one who makes the ice cream) lol. Picked out the flavor for my second scoop of ice cream in my 2 scoop cup.) The two young ladies working the counter were fun and worked well together.
The ice cream was creamy and very good flavor.
Amazing experience. Caleb was very helpful and courteous 🙏
Em was amazing! Super great personality && great knowledge of products. My friend and I were in town for the seafood festival and decided we wanted ice cream em helped us with all of our flavor needs! 😋
Loading...