Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine
100 St George St # J, St. Augustine
(904) 792-9860
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Really good ice cream!! Cookie crush , was so good and mint ice cream was also good!!
Rachel was great! She helped us pick out flavors and offered samples. Mayday is the best, you won’t be disappointed.
Their ice cream is fabulous, and the young lady was so friendly........
Tim waited on us, he was fantastic! Friendly and helpful. Helped us pick the perfect flavor for our cone.
Very good local ice cream and super friendly and helpful worker Tim
We always have the BEST experience & the BEST ice cream & sprinkles @ Mayday in St Augustine!! Mary & Micha were great this time! The whole staff are always a joy!!
It's incredibly delicious. If you don't mind the wait times, which means speaks for itself, , then definitely stop by.
Homemade delicious ice cream
Updating to say our most recent visit was - as always - top notch! Oarian went above and beyond for our kiddos and was super sweet. We are always so impressed with the quality of the ice cream at Mayday but the service is really why we return. Thanks Oarian! (1/2026)
We love Mayday! But our experience today was tops! I brought in a raggedy group of 4th graders on a field trip and Phoenix was phenomenal in her kindness, service, and patience. She was so sweet and got them all exactly what they wanted - with sprinkles of course. And they all loved every flavor they chose (how could they not?), because Mayday is always delicious.
Rachel was awesome, she was fast and very friendly, hope to come again
Restaurantji Recommends
Possibly the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Unique, delicious flavors. Rachel gave us superb recommendations! The entire staff was great and handled the crowds well. Went two days in a row on our trip. Worth the hype!
LOVE LOVE LOVED RACHEL !! She was very nice annd accommodating… and the ice cream was good too lol !
Rachel was so sweet and scooped out our ice cream with love <3
Excellent service with Dez, this stop is essential in my trip to City of Saint Agustine 🍨
Ice cream was phenomenal! Shout out to Claire who helped us, great service and made the experience 10/10!
Loading...