Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine

100 St George St # J, St. Augustine
(904) 792-9860

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Gillespie's Bourbon Pecan Ice Cream Pint
Cookie Crush Ice Cream Pint
Parent Trap Ice Cream Pint
Almond Butter Chocolate
Blueberry Toast Crunch
Queen Salted Caramel
Flight of Ice Cream
Lavender Ice Cream
Cookies and Cream
Strawberry Fields

Menu

Pint Ice Cream To Go
Parent Trap Ice Cream (Pint)
Creamy and salty peanut butter swirled ice cream with chunks of everyone's favorite Oreo cookies. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Cookie Crush Ice Cream (Pint)
Oreo icing mixed into our ice cream base and perfectly blended with crushed Oreo cookies. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
The Aviator Ice Cream (Pint)
Chocolate and hazelnut Nutella ice cream blended with chunks of biscoff cookies and hazelnuts. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Blueberry Toast Crunch Ice Cream (Pint)
Cinnamon toast crunch soaked ice cream with a homemade blueberry compote swirl. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Queen Salted Caramel Ice Cream (Pint)
A rich and creamy caramel ice cream with flakes of pink Himalayan sea salt. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Gillespie's Bourbon Pecan Ice Cream (Pint)
Butter pecan younger brother. Buffalo trace bourbon-soaked into ice cream with pieces of chopped, roasted pecans.
Session Chocolate Ice Cream (Pint)
A chocolate lover's dream come true, decadent chocolate ice cream packed full of melted chocolates and notes of roasted cocoa. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Almond Butter Chocolate Ice Cream (Pint)
Dairy-free. Luxurious chocolate ice cream blended with coconut milk, creamy almond butter, ripples, and dairy-free chocolate chip chunks. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Cloud 9 Ice Cream (Pint)
A deliciously light sweet and salty almond ice cream with flakes of sea salt and homemade marshmallow fluff. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Key Lime Pie Ice Cream (Pint)
Our take on the beloved Florida key lime pie, rich vanilla base ice cream with freshly squeezed lime juice, lime zest, and buttery graham cracker crust pieces. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Coffee and Donuts Ice Cream (Pint)
A delicious and uplifting coffee ice cream made with coffee from the Kookaburra and chopped pieces of glazed donuts from Fiction donuts. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Strawberry Mint Sorbet Ice Cream (Pint)
Dairy-free. Fresh strawberry sorbet with muddled mint pieces. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Triple Vanilla Ice Cream (Pint)
Three times as delicious made with a vanilla bean paste, fresh vanilla beans, and vanilla extract. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Straight Strawberry Ice Cream (Pint)
Strawberry-infused ice cream with freshly chopped juicy strawberries. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.
Ice Box Lemon Ice Cream (Pint)
When life gives you lemon make an icebox of lemon ice cream, juiced and zested fresh lemons blended with lemon-infused ice cream. Includes a small bag of our handmade sprinkles and two brown sugar and butter galette cookies.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+48 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+47 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Updating to say our most recent visit was - as always - top notch! Oarian went above and beyond for our kiddos and was super sweet. We are always so impressed with the quality of the ice cream at Mayday but the service is really why we return. Thanks Oarian! (1/2026)

We love Mayday! But our experience today was tops! I brought in a raggedy group of 4th graders on a field trip and Phoenix was phenomenal in her kindness, service, and patience. She was so sweet...
January 2026
Possibly the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Unique, delicious flavors. Rachel gave us superb recommendations! The entire staff was great and handled the crowds well. Went two days in a row on our trip. Worth the hype!
January 2026
Very friendly staff and great vibe overall! Had ordered key lime pie and one seasonal flavor. Both were great! They are happy to let you try as many flavours as you like until you select what you really want!
January 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Treylor Park - Saint Augustine - 61 Spanish St
Cocktail Bar, Tacos
The Cuban Café And Bakery - 100 St George St
Cafe, Cuban, Bakery, Pet Friendly
Café Del Hidalgo- Ice Cream, Food, And Drink - 35 Hypolita St STE 101
Cafe, Gelato, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Pet Friendly, Vegan

Mayday Ice Cream Historic St. Augustine

100 St George St # J, St. Augustine, FL 32084
(904) 792-9860